4 ms·
I can see why you might say that superficially, but the difference is that feminists believe in empowering women to decide for themselves who they chose to inte
by ForHackernews 12y ago
I can see why you might say that superficially, but the difference is that feminists believe in empowering women to decide for themselves who they chose to interact with, whereas Saudi religious authorities believe in dictating to women who they can interact with. So in fact, they're almost polar opposite positions.
- leereeves 12y agoIsn't she dictating who men can even try to interact with? She didn't say "Leave me alone if I ask you to." She once wrote that a man is a harasser for trying: "If you are a strange man trying to talk to me on my way to or from work, when I am commuting alone, you are a harasser, pure and simple."
- maxerickson 12y agoYou are constructing a model from a short essay that was written to convey a certain point of view and then insisting that the model you have constructed must be 100% accurate. It's a strange exercise. If she literally means that even glancing in her direction is harassment, that is pretty extreme, but if you glance at someone and they don't seem to notice you, it's probably not the right time to hit them up for a conversation.
- leereeves 12y ago> You are constructing a model from a short essay that was written to convey a certain point of view and then insisting that the model you have constructed must be 100% accurate. That's quite a leap from my question. And not an answer.
- maxerickson 12y agoIt is an answer! Your question is based on the premise that "If you are a strange man trying to talk to me on my way to or from work, when I am commuting alone, you are a harasser, pure and simple." is complete and accurate description of what she believes. That premise is difficult to prove in either direction. It happens all the time that an essay exaggerates a message in order to make that message stand out.
- leereeves 12y ago> It happens all the time that an essay exaggerates a message in order to make that message stand out. I hope she's not doing that. Sincerely.
- maxerickson 12y agoWhy? What message do you read in the blog post? I see someone explaining that they have actually been mistreated by people 'just trying to make conversation' and that this makes it difficult for them to have any desire to ever 'just make conversation'. Sure, it's a miserable outcome if she sees the world of strangers as a hostile place, but it seems it might be based on experience.
- leereeves 12y ago> I see someone explaining that they have actually been mistreated by people 'just trying to make conversation' I'm sympathetic, but harasser is a serious word. It's not something that should be exaggerated in order to make a message stand out.
- maxerickson 12y agoShe is making the point that she no longer sees people in those situations as anything other than potential harassers. Maybe it would be fair to put a bunch of qualifiers in there to make it clear that in spite of this attitude, she knows that there are many nice people out there and that the essay isn't meant to apply to them, but I don't think it's obvious that it would improve the essay (which I see as an attempt to convey how she feels about the interactions much more than I see it as an attempt to besmirch the men of the world with the label 'harasser').
- varelse 12y agoIf I were female and I had two superiors in my chain of command treat me the way Vic Gundotra and Rod Chavez allegedly (and IMO probably) did, I'm pretty sure I'd start to see all men as potential harassers in the same way cops start to see everyone as potential perps after dealing with a minority of scumbags. I don't blame Kelly Ellis one bit. Don't blame the victim. I blame these two idiots, their co-workers covering their butts, and Google HR.
- Dewie 12y agoObviously the comparison is far from perfect. But to my knowledge, if a strange man approached strange woman in SA, he could get in trouble for that. There are expectations and restrictions on both sexes, which ultimately leads to the situation where strange men and women can't interact. If I'm mistaken and men can interact freely with strange women in SA, then my bad. And obviously she wouldn't be the one who laid down the law in that country. But the eventual outcome would have been the same. > , but the difference is that feminists believe in empowering women to decide for themselves who they chose to interact with, So, a strange man should just hold his peace unless spoken to? That sounds familiar. Either that or none of the sexes are allowed to initiate contact with another. Which again leads to the comparison to SA. EDIT: Imagine if a woman from non-SA thought "I want to live under Sharia Law" (for whatever reason). She could then make the free choice to move to SA. Now, while in SA, she would have the same (lack of) woman rights as other women in SA. But it was her own choice to put herself in that situation. In the same sense, women are freely able to express that they want something like sex segregation in "our" society. That is a free choice on their part. But if that somehow comes reality, they might not have so much free choice any more, if SA is any indication. But those two moments in time are different with regards to freedom of choice.