3 ms·
>>If any one is harassed at work make a complaint with HR I agree with you in general, but no, please don't do this. The reason has been discussed many times o
by enraged_camel 12y ago
>>If any one is harassed at work make a complaint with HR
I agree with you in general, but no, please don't do this. The reason has been discussed many times on HN. Basically, HR is not your friend. They aren't a "mommy" or "daddy" figure that you can complain to when someone mistreats you. Their primary job is to protect the company from troublemaker employees - such as those who file complaints about their coworkers. If you report a coworker, especially for a potentially litigious thing like harassment, HR will nod and assure you that they will handle it, but secretly think "this guy is a walking lawsuit" and find a seemingly unrelated reason to terminate you (or make you leave).
I only talk to HR for administrative stuff, such as benefits paperwork and other such trivia. I advise everyone do the same.
- dogma1138 12y agoIn Europe, or at least in the UK many companies have actual "external" companies that manage harassment cases. I can't speak for Google or US law for that matter, but I'm pretty sure that there are enough options to get this matter settled without getting fired if the case is just. And if not you are fighting the wrong battles, if the laws and policies of such companies in the states do not provide an actual safe environment to make complaints then that's the battle you should be waging.
- falcolas 12y agoProtecting the company can also include firing the person who is opening the company up to lawsuits. Firing someone after they report sexual harassment would also open the company to wrongful termination suits, especially since the communications will be recorded. Copying a personal lawyer on those communications would help as well. What is most likely to happen in cases of harassment is making the accuser happy, since that provides the company with the most protection. And since so many companies have zero tolerance policies against harassment, it becomes very simple to terminate an employee who is a liability for that company.
- A1kmm 12y ago> find a seemingly unrelated reason to terminate you (or > make you leave). That doesn't make sense. The guy who is going around harassing people is creating the liability, not the victim, and will probably create more liability in the future. I would be very surprised if there was any jurisdiction in the world where terminating an employment contract terminates employer liability for harassment; a terminated former employee who has been harassed is a much bigger threat to company profits than a current one. The only reason any reasonably competent HR department would fire someone for making a valid complaint of harassment would be if they were ordered to by their superiors to protect themselves or their management colleagues (which is, sadly, a risk in some companies). Obviously, going to HR should not be someone's first move for a one off comment. The person probably doesn't realise that they are being offensive, so a reasonable escalation is to tell them you are offended (and why) first, and if it continues, then go to HR. If it still continues, and HR doesn't do anything meaningful to address the problem (or fires you wrongfully in retribution), then escalate by hiring an employment lawyer to bring a lawsuit against the company, or depending on your jurisdiction, complaining to the relevant government body. This is fair to the person making the remark (they have a chance to learn that their conduct is offensive), the company (they have a chance to know about and address the problem before facing any external action), and the person who was offended (the problem is fixed one way or the other). In this case, both sides were potentially in the wrong - throwing your drink on someone could be viewed as an assault and more serious than a single offensive remark. I think that had Kelly Ellis followed a reasonable pattern of escalation, there would be less harassment at Google now, all three parties (i.e. the two people and the corporation) involved would be better off, and we wouldn't be hearing about this now. Obviously it would be even better if the remark had never been made in the first place. It makes me wonder if Google HR does not give employees training about not harassing people and how to respond to harassment - that is pretty much standard at most big companies of their size, and probably pays for itself in reduced liability (if they get sued out of the blue, they can point to the training to try to shift the blame to the person doing the harassing rather than the company - obviously that won't work if the plaintiff complained to them and they did nothing).