3 ms·
Just like playing a CD in an unapproved player (with skip protection) creates an unlawful copy in memory? A copyright is not absolute ownership of a bit patter
by mindslight 17y ago
Just like playing a CD in an unapproved player (with skip protection) creates an unlawful copy in memory?
A copyright is not absolute ownership of a bit pattern, but a balance of the interests of consumers and producers. Apple is clearly attempting to abuse copyright law; such in-memory copies are implicitly granted with the disc as they're necessarily for the software to operate.
- benofsky 17y ago> such in-memory copies are implicitly granted with the disc The story isn't saying no-one is allowed turn on their Macs because we're pirating OS X by making copies of it. Apple's point is Pystar is breaking the license under which OS X is distributed by installing it on a non-Apple computer therefore any copy is an unlawful copy.
- tedunangst 17y agoWhen you buy a CD, does it come with a license that only authorizes it for play in approved players? No.
- mindslight 17y agoAnd if it did, would it be enforceable or laughable? How would playing an audio CD even require agreeing to a license? The original seller may have agreed to a shrinkwrap contract, but one purchasing a used CD certainly hasn't. Copyright protection coverts duplicating the content of an object, not use of the object.
- joubert 17y agoWell, the fine print on most of my CD's include the prohibition of unauthorized LENDING of the disc.