4 ms·
Generally speaking newer kernels are considerably more stable than older kernels That may be generally true of kernels, but when you are guaranteeing compatibi
by kbenson 12y ago
Generally speaking newer kernels are considerably more stable than older kernels
That may be generally true of kernels, but when you are guaranteeing compatibility and support for a set of hardware, I would argue that after you've confirmed they work for a kernel, freezing that version and back-porting fixes and features that are worth it with another testing cycle is generally more stable.
- mrmondo 12y agoCan you give me an example of some hardware that is in general use that is no longer supported in Kernel 3.18/3.19? (I'm not saying you can't - I'm genuinely interested in this question)
- kbenson 12y agoIt's not that it's not supported, it's that the driver may have been modified to support other devices, or a portion could have been rewritten, and that could lead to short-term instability until they identify and fix any problems introduced.
- pgaddict 12y agoIt's not just about removing support for hardware - that happens from time to time, but generally not with reasonably recent hardware. It's also about minimizing risk of bugs in the new parts - even if you do a very thorough testing, you can't really eliminate the risks, so the more conservative deployments simply keep the old kernel versions. I do have my own experience with this, particularly with 3.10 - we've thoroughly evaluated it, yet after a few days on production all the machines crashed because of deadlock in the I/O stack. Very time consuming to debug where the actual problem is (virtualised environment, ...). So while I run Gentoo on most of my personal machines, I do understand why people are conservative.