3 ms·
Imagine a contract that says "You owe me 5% of the revenue you make in any product derived from my project." This is reasonable, it is how royalties work for ma
by sanderjd 12y ago
Imagine a contract that says "You owe me 5% of the revenue you make in any product derived from my project." This is reasonable, it is how royalties work for many different things and it's a pretty battle-tested model. I think we can all agree that if you sign such a contract and then don't pay the royalties, then you can reasonably be taken to court for failing to comply with the contract, and forced to pay what you owe, plus damages to keep you from trying it again. The GPL is similar to a contract like that, except that it says "if you agree to redistribute your derived works under this same contract, you don't owe any royalties at all." So it's similarly reasonable to be taken to court for failing to comply with those terms, and forced to pay damages.
So I think the "harm" is that they failed to adhere to the contract they made with him. That may not be satisfying to you, but that's certainly enough in itself for this to go to court. Contracts is fundamental to how modern societies function—courts enforce that when parties agree to legal terms, those terms are adhered to.