4 ms·
Not that I disagree with you, but illustrating your point by comparing a madly cost-effective ASIC today to a madly overpriced PC several years old is a bit mis
by andrepd 12y ago
Not that I disagree with you, but illustrating your point by comparing a madly cost-effective ASIC today to a madly overpriced PC several years old is a bit misleading.
- freehunter 12y agoHow is it misleading? Do you think everyone running uTorrent is going to have the latest and greatest hardware specially tuned to mining Bitcoin? What we're comparing is what uTorrent could be getting versus what they will actually be getting with hardware their users actually run. Perfectly apt comparison, in my opinion. The idea is to show how useless this endeavor is.
- sharpneli 12y agoThe point in electricity consumption stands across the board for all hardware. CPU mining is just that ineffective compared to ASICs. Basically uTorrent folks are willing to turn tens of millions of dollars worth of electricity, paid by someone else, into heat just so they can grab a thousand or so of profit. I have no idea who thought it would be a good idea. How sociopathic a person must be to suggest it originally?
- ptomato 12y agoI mean, the software exists to allow you to reap the benefits of other people's work without paying them. I'm not sure why this is surprising.
- sharpneli 12y agoFirst of all this must be made well known, so that people will avoid uTorrent. Second of all this is bit different from normal theft in the orders of magnitudes involved. If you steal 1000€ from someone the other person loses 1000€. In this case uTorrent guys are stealing 1000€ and receiving only 0.1€, or robbing 0.1€ and causing 1000€ worth of damage. It's like burning down a department store, destroying all the goods in it and the building, just to rob a single cash register.
- andrepd 12y agoIf it stands across the board, all the more reason not fudge up by using an overpriced dated laptop as comparison instead of a recent desktop for instance. It would even illustrate the point better (even your "gaming" grade desktop will be orders of magnitude less efficient than a specialized ASIC).
- IkmoIkmo 12y agoThat's the entire point. The point is that bitcoin mining is a lottery, and you get more tickets the more hashpower you have. In other words, it's a competition. The average person running a MBP that's a few years old gets 2 MH/S (call em lottery tickets). But the majority of people mining are doing so with ASICs that get 1 or 2 million MH/S at a quarter of the cost of the second hand price of a MBP. That's the reality today. The comparison between the two isn't my point. It's merely to illustrate WHY running a MBP for 1 year, 24/7 at 100% of CPU nets you a fraction of a single penny. It's because many others mine with specialized equipment. The basic point is that if you get 2 lottery tickets and there are 100 tickets in total, that's great. If you get 2 lottery tickets and there are litterally trillions of tickets, you won't win, and over the course of a century you will earn less than 1 dollar. That's not misleading it's literally what is happening. uTorrent's average user will generate a fraction of a penny in bitcoin revenue, while generating 10-20 dollars of extra electricity costs, while using up 50% of its CPU. These facts come from data of today's hashrate, not from analogy. I just wrote down the comparison to explain why the hashrate is so gigantic and why running millions of Macbook Pros through uTorrent can't compete with it and won't generate any real money, despite spending loads of money on electricity costs.
- bhouston 12y agoSo basically uTorrent is abusing its users in the extreme to try and make money. It is making its users spend money on electricity (because users can not stop them) in order to make much less money through bitcoin. I wonder if that is a new permission Apps should request -- the ability to run high intensity CPU jobs. Anyhow, this part of uTorrent needs to be removed by the next update of Windows's built-in malware removal tool.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- andrepd 12y agoI know all that. My point is that in order to make a fair comparison you might as well compare an ASIC with a <1 year old desktop, instead of an overpriced several years old laptop, especially because your point still stands the same. There is absolutely no need to fudge up the numbers because ASICs outclass general purpose hardware by orders of magnitude anyway. It's dishonest and with absolutely no need for it. As an aside, my 2 year old laptop gets 20MH/s and a latest-generation desktop CPU gets close to 100MH/s.