5 ms·
Gov.uk isn’t finished
- afoot 12y agoI really admire the commitment to openness and transparency displayed by the team on this project. Even though that may be common in the startup world or open source community, it's still somewhat rare in lots of other types of projects.
- emodendroket 12y agoI think it's interesting to see how well they've done. I think that if the US were also to employ programmers directly we'd see better products than with the current system.
- endtwist 12y agoHave you seen 18F (https://18f.gsa.gov/ https://18f.gsa.gov/)? That's exactly what they're trying to do.
- emodendroket 12y agoWow, that's the first I've seen it. Neat. I hope that this gradually becomes the dominant model.
- danohuiginn 12y agoThey've chosen just about the worst imaginable name...
- tombot 12y agoDoes 18F mean anything special?
- Cthulhu_ 12y agoMight refer to 18-year old female, a common trope in dating sites and porn.
- Someone1234 12y agoI found this in an article: > The name 18F refers to GSA headquarters building, which is located on 18th and F streets in Washington. I agree that 18F is a bad name. They should have just called it "Government Digital Service" like the UK version of the same.
- liyanchang 12y agoPeople high up in the government agree with you! From the aftermath of healthcare.gov, two US government entities were created: 1. 18F - An pool of in-house developers working with agencies to build (or rebuild) services. https://18f.gsa.gov/ https://18f.gsa.gov/ 2. US Digital Service - A group of technologists quietly trying to rescue projects (like healthcare.gov, the VA) and change policy. http://www.whitehouse.gov/digital/united-states-digital-service http://www.whitehouse.gov/digital/united-states-digital-serv... Plenty of roadblocks and difficult times ahead for both groups - but unlike before when failure was guaranteed, they've already had some wins and have a non-zero chance of success.
- auton1 12y agoA contrary opinion: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/02/18/the_inside_story_of_govuk/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/02/18/the_inside_story_of_...
- alextgordon 12y agoI'm afraid I have to agree. gov.uk has been a reversion to the mean. It's not nearly as good as direct.gov that preceded it. On the other hand it replaces many cruddy government websites that had impossible navigation. So it replaces variance with consistent mediocrity: the McDonalds of websites.
- alextgordon 12y agoTo those downvoting, let me illustrate: This was the old directgov site: https://i.imgur.com/s7lHXGD.png https://i.imgur.com/s7lHXGD.png This is the new gov.uk site: https://i.imgur.com/IgyTCLL.png https://i.imgur.com/IgyTCLL.png Which do you think does a better job of presenting the information?
- shellac 12y agoAndrew Orlowski added 'professional contrarian' to his business card many moons ago. (You can say much the same for the Register in general) It's a shame because what used to be a useful source is now just noise. Maybe he's right in this case, but who would ever know?
- forloop 12y agoI was using the job search[1] on the gov.uk domain yesterday, and the UX is extremely poor! If the job site was a for-profit, it would probably be put out of business by competitors! But, since the government can jail people for not handing over their resources, products aren't held accountable by the Market (big 'M'). I wouldn't even mind if it had an API[2], so I could make a more useful tool[3]. But instead I have to manually go through a ton of jobs each day so I can get unemployment handouts from daddy government (if there was no such thing as VAT, I probably wouldn't need these! Anyway). Gov.uk looks a bit nice with its san serif typeface[4] and minimalist design; but it's varnish on a clunky turd. --- [1] https://www.gov.uk/jobsearch https://www.gov.uk/jobsearch [2] I couldn't find one yesterday. I'm going to have another look. [3] Currently learning Python and looking for a little side project. [4] Looking at the CSS, the particular font is 'nta'—and is presumably custom.
- CatsoCatsoCatso 12y agoThe custom font is most likely New Transport or a modification of it. It's a variant of the typeface used on British road signs. https://gds.blog.gov.uk/2014/03/05/new-transport-for-gov-uk/ https://gds.blog.gov.uk/2014/03/05/new-transport-for-gov-uk/ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transport_%28typeface%29#New_Transport http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transport_%28typeface%29#New_Tr... They're using it for its aesthetic and for its keeping with the national infrastructure.
- forloop 12y agoIt's almost certainly a modification, if it is New Transport. After all, what makes a road sign readable is different from body copy. But that's an interesting comment! Aside: I've probably been past the road sign on that Wikipedia page.
- CatsoCatsoCatso 12y ago"what makes a road sign readable is different from body copy" I thought the very same, seems a odd choice to me. Interesting that they're using it though. It would be wonderful for them to provide more information about it as the current pickings are very slim.
- toyg 12y agoI've met some of the guys working for gov.uk and they know the challenge is huge. A government is probably the worst sort of institution to try and change at a fundamental level using technology. They're good people trying their best. This said, I don't see the point of such a puff-piece unless it's a combination of 1) recent bad press from The Register and 2) national election being in full swing. There is a very high chance that voters will not return the same government to power, so I guess GDS are trying to preempt an inevitable wave of "spoil system", considering they were appointed directly from the cabinet.
- DanBC 12y ago> 1) recent bad press from The Register The Register is scum. I'm amazed anyone pays them any attention. It's kind of weird that the Register isn't one of the auto-blocked domains on HN. Their stories are mangled half-truths and misunderstandings. It's got a lot worse since Guy Kewney died, but even when he was alive they just weren't very good.
- Spearchucker 12y ago"The Register is scum." How so? I find it quite useful in staying on top of IT news in the UK. Their reporting is harsh, but to date, from what I know of the industry, appears to be accurate. If it's not some examples would help?
- anon1385 12y agoI'm not a fan of the gov.uk project (see my other comment on this thread) but the Register is a pretty awful site, and Andrew Orlowski in particular is a total crackpot. For example he writes crazy climate change denial articles. To be fair, it's the same kind of crackpottery that you can find in papers like The Telegraph most weeks. The Telegraph is trash too, but some people still take it seriously. I'd put The Register in the same bracket: it still can product ok coverage of some stories but there are a bunch of topics where their politics or petty personal feuds leads them to write terrible articles full of factual inaccuracies.
- 12y ago
- vitriol83 12y agoThis blog post is worryingly vague about anything of concrete value for users. It suggests a large reengineering effort without any idea of what they really want to achieve. For example, one of the blog posts it links to, they introduce the new VAT manual https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/vat-government-and-public-bodies https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/vat-government-and-... vs old http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/manuals/vatgpbmanual/index.htm http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/manuals/vatgpbmanual/index.htm It's identical, except for a modified stylesheet. This may be 'unapologetically unifying and simplifying the experience of interacting with government', but this is not very much to show for all the time that has been spent on GDS.
- Someone1234 12y ago> It's identical, except for a modified stylesheet. They're taking legacy sites and modernising them. They aren't re-writing HMRC's VAT manual and never claimed they were. You call it identical, but they've altered the underlying HTML layout and change the stylesheet to make it work better in modern browsers and made it easier to interact with using touch devices. That was their entire spec. That is their job. They've done their job. And while the content is "identical" by design, they fixed the part that was broken: bad markup and poor styling. PS - The old site looks absolutely terrible in Chrome 40. It "works" but I need to zoom to 200%, and with a touch device I keep hitting the wrong link because they're so close together.
- Spearchucker 12y ago"That was their entire spec. That is their job. They've done their job." The 25 exemplars say otherwise. They're about process re-engineering, technology modernisation and legacy integration. And they're also nowhere near complete (only 9 are live[1]). [1] https://www.gov.uk/transformation https://www.gov.uk/transformation
- Someone1234 12y agoI could have worded that quoted section better. People have been complaining that some legacy documents and manuals weren't available on the new gov.uk site. So now they've started bringing them over, updating them to work in modern browsers and on touch devices, so in this context their only spec was to make that content available on the new site. In the larger context, yes, they've been doing some actual redevelopment. But how do you re-develop a HMRC manual? Heck up until a few years ago it was only available as a PDF(!). Even the old site was a marked improvement, and this one just keeps that document pleasantly available for the future.
- matthewmacleod 12y agoI must admit, I had a dim view of what would come out of GOV.UK 3-or-so years ago. But I have to admit that I've been pleasantly surprised; the task they've set for themselves is gigantic in proportion, and so far the product has been pretty impressive. So this is good, and I hope they continue to improve digital infrastructure in the UK. I like to think the current projects are the most important step — general improvements to accessibility, discoverability and usability of government documentation. But I expect we'll see progressive implementation of government departments' tools on top of the gov.uk platform as it comes time to renew them — and so far, it feels like that's a much better option than what we saw in the past.