3 ms·
> Facebook controls them and decides if and when your access to them shall be revoked. I share the Persona love but I don't think this is complete: yes, Facebo
by acdha 12y ago
> Facebook controls them and decides if and when your access to them shall be revoked.
I share the Persona love but I don't think this is complete: yes, Facebook could zero-day you and drop support but it's really unlikely that they wouldn't announce something in advance which would allow you to pivot, leading to:
> At least with an email address, you can bootstrap an independent relationship.
You can also do this using a Facebook login by having a way for the user to enter an email address. The difference is that you can avoid hitting them for it up front and triggering the “Are they going to spam me?” worry which makes people question using your site in the first place.
You could introduce it at some point where it has a benefit to them – “Please enter your email address if you'd like new turn notifications”, etc. – or, were Facebook to announce that they're discontinuing this service, ask them for another way to login in. Most sites already have a bunch of separate social login services linked to a single identity, this is only one more.
- stickfigure 12y agoAs someone who has built this (one of my sites, http://voo.st/ http://voo.st/, is literally the poster child for Persona+Facebook login), it's practically impossible to unify accounts unless you get an email address up front. Otherwise you end up with separate accounts and a post-facto merge process that almost always requires some level of administrator touch. Yes, you can solve any problem with a big enough customer support budget. Not helpful.