5 ms·
Or you know, they can stop being jerks and release sources for the code they derived from the GPLed one. > It's just that this GPL thing doesn't even register
by shmerl 12y ago
Or you know, they can stop being jerks and release sources for the code they derived from the GPLed one.
> It's just that this GPL thing doesn't even register on their legal radar
It should register.
> Similarly any concerns raised by engineering are never taken seriously by the legal council.
Not in any serious company to my experience. Being so lax on legal matters for such company shows very low level of their management's professionalism.
- the_af 12y agoEspecially since the GPL is one of the most widely known copyleft licenses out there. I can expect a layman to not know about it, but the software engineers at VMWare?
- shmerl 12y agoIt sounds from the above comment that even if engineers raise this issue, their legal department dismisses it. I find it bizarre for any serious company.
- charlesnw 12y agoYes exactly. Most large organizations (with in house counsel) take feedback from software/systems engineering very seriously. For compliance (especially licenses) contract requirements etc. Legal exists to serve/protect the organization.
- gnoway 12y agoThat comment is just supposition. The author has not demonstrated any knowledge of VMware development or legal practices.
- dogma1138 12y agoYou assume that a software engineer knows any more about copyright law than a random person from the street? Cuz I'm pretty sure they don't also in virtually every company it will be "don't bother with this, let the lawyers deal with it". Companies violate patents licenses agreements and all other legal nonsense all the time, that's what they got lawyers for.
- huhtenberg 12y ago> Being so lax on legal matters for such company shows very low level of their management's professionalism. Actually, no, it doesn't. It merely means that the management views GPL violations as a low-probability calculated risk. As in "we know that we can be in compliance, but we won't be wasting any resources on it until it's justified". It has nothing to do with the professionalism.
- jcoffland 12y agoIn a world where lying and cheating when it's convienient is considered professional, you're right.
- angersock 12y agoWelcome to business!
- shmerl 12y agoYou mean unethical business.
- a1369209993 12y agoSo business.
- angersock 12y agoEthics don't enter into it--you might be thinking of negative externalities. That's the responsibility of the person running things next fiscal year. In the mean time, quit worrying and go deliver shareholder value.
- shmerl 12y ago> That's the responsibility of the person running things next fiscal year. In the mean time, quit worrying and go deliver shareholder value. No, that's a weird attitude (i.e. I'll create a mess today, next person will clean it tomorrow). One has to be responsible for the mess, and actually preventing it to begin with. What you described is exactly the lack of professionalism.