2 ms·
I'm not certain how you can structure your argument such that it does not also imply that professions that are majority female discriminate against men. Your i
by logfromblammo 12y ago
I'm not certain how you can structure your argument such that it does not also imply that professions that are majority female discriminate against men.
Your introduction of that graph appears to be an attempt at making an improper inference based on conditional probabilities. You can't just flip-flop between probability of woman, given job, and probability of job, given woman. There's math involved, based on additional data not necessarily obvious from the visualization.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conditional_probability http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conditional_probability
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confusion_of_the_inverse http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confusion_of_the_inverse
To make an inference about what women want, you have to remove the men from the data. It doesn't matter one little bit what the female numbers are in proportion to the male numbers. And what the female numbers show is that around 1985, women generally stopped wanting to earn CS degrees, preferring medicine, law, or physical sciences. The graph does not say why. It just suggests that women very abruptly reversed the previous trend and started choosing other careers. It also happened before the vast majority of people now working in the field had graduated from elementary school, which suggests that it is an institutional bias, and not a personal one.
It's easy to guess at the reason why, but those guesses would not be supported by anything short of surveying actual women with college educations, asking them "why not computer science?"
My hypothesis is that for those answers that cite the composition of the CS classes and faculty as a contributing factor, it wasn't because they were full of men, but because they were full of nerds. For a variety of reasons revolving around the capricious cruelty of adolescents, females are less likely to be in the nerd social caste, and possibly also strongly conditioned to avoid it.
That social dynamic fuels a lot of nastiness later in life. Sex balance in the workplace may be just another symptom of it.
But really, it's all useless speculation until someone actually goes out and asks some people about their reasons for doing things, in a manner that avoids known biases.
- wpietri 12y agoI think the only relevant argument I made here is that "women just don't want to tech" does not usefully explain the data. If you're saying what careers people choose is a complex function with many inputs and interactions with the social context, I agree. I am arguing against the view that career mainly driven by a simple, stable, gender-based biological intrinsic, which is the usual thing meant by "women just X", as in "women just can't science" or "women just want want to stay at home with babies".