3 ms·
Google has always had issues with legitimate e-mail the spambox, but then again, I have yet to see a spam filter with no false positives. Google just errors a l
by lucb1e 12y ago
Google has always had issues with legitimate e-mail the spambox, but then again, I have yet to see a spam filter with no false positives. Google just errors a lot more on the side of classifying email as spam compared to most email services (more false positives, but less spam in the inbox). What makes this even more annoying is that they hide the spam folder so that users don't even know that it exists anymore. I always have to give directions where to find it and invariably get reactions like "Oh, I didn't know GMail had a spam box!" or "Ah thanks, I would never have found that."
I did consider setting up a route in my mailserver to GMail using my Google account credentials for their SMTP server, but then decided they should better get their own shit straight. It wouldn't scale to do this for everyone.
- sergiosgc 12y agoGmail is awful regarding false positives. People discount it because: a) it's a free service; b) false negatives are more frequent and thus more annoying. What is difficult in spam classification is having no false negatives and no false positives. Any decent CS graduate can create a spam classification system with no false negatives given the leeway to introduce false positives. That's what Gmail did.
- lucb1e 12y ago> b) false negatives are more frequent and thus more annoying. I think this is the case for the user. For the sender it's a major issue and a huge annoyance, but you don't measure user satisfaction by asking senders.
- drzaiusapelord 12y ago>so more false positives, but less spam in the inbox This is a pretty strong understatement. The spam filter in gmail is incredibly aggressive. My secondary email is a gmail account and anytime I have a registration email from a service or anything with a couple URLs in it, it goes straight to spam. Meanwhile, the product we use at work is tons smarter, but gives the occasional spam into the inbox. I guess someone at google decided that people seem happier when there's no spam in their inbox. People seem to drop 20 IQ points when they see spam. They either instantly rage about it or send the email to the helpdesk demanding an explanation on how someone dared email them something they weren't interested in. Its a bizarre behavior. Yet, when they're forced to fish through a spam folder or an anti-spam web interface, they seem to mind that less. Which is bizarre as its tons more work. I think the guys at gmail realized this and just erred on the side of caution by giving people as much as a clean inbox as they can handle. Even if they don't like it, who are they going to complain to? Google? Who at google gives two shits and even if someone did, how could your reach them, and if you did who has the power to change policy? Meanwhile if you run mail servers, you get complaints about how your email goes into spam, even when you have all your DNS ducks in a row and have a good reputation. When you tell gmail users to talk to google about it, they scoff and tell you to piss off.
- delecti 12y agoI don't know that I've ever had a false negative (spam in my inbox) in my gmail, and I've had it for just over 7 years now. I also don't know that I've ever had a false positive, but I tend to not check my spam folder very often so it's possible I've missed things. Maybe I'm just an outlier, but I'm perfectly content with my gmail.
- bodyfour 12y agoI wouldn't have such a problem with its false positive rate if they at least learned from them better. It doesn't seem to matter how many times I mark an email as "Not Spam". The next day an email from the same sender from the same server with the same Received: path will land right back in Spam again. I realize that gmail can't immediately globally unblock based on "Not Spam" reports (otherwise spammers would ruin things by marking their own bulk mail) but could they at least apply them to my mailbox? I guess adding the senders to my address book would help, but it seems like a silly thing to have to do. I already told it that a message is "Not spam", can't it take it from there?
- specialp 12y agoThe problem now is that GMail is so big, it becomes "well your emails are being filtered in GMail so you need to fix it". With smaller providers it would be that they were being too aggressive with email filtering. Fixing the problem is sometimes very hard with large providers as you really have nobody to contact for help or whitelisting. You can do all the best practices for sending emails (SPF, DKIM etc) but that will not help if you get filtered or blocked for some arbitrary and unknown reason. So for this reason people give up and either send their emails through well known mail senders or switch their users to services like GMail. This is sad as perhaps the last communications medium with open standards is being forced proprietary due to the difficulty in dealing with the large email providers. My company switched to GMail for our email, and Mandrill for sending out our mailing list although we have competent sysadmins.