4 ms·
These laments are a bit overblown. I worked for Maxis during the big closure in 2004, when the company was in Walnut Creek. A small group moved to Emeryville,
by stickfigure 12y ago
These laments are a bit overblown.
I worked for Maxis during the big closure in 2004, when the company was in Walnut Creek. A small group moved to Emeryville, many people (including the Sims teams) moved to Redwood Shores, and some some people didn't make the transition. Think of it like layoffs, following on the colossal failure that was The Sims Online (although, ironically, what's left of that team had already moved to EARS).
This is pretty much the same thing. Spore was a disappointment, SimCity was never a massive moneymaker, and whatever games they've been working on since got cancelled. The Emeryville shop has had a decade to produce a hit and it hasn't worked out. Some folks have already been laid off. Some folks will get moved to EARS. Some folks will be looking for a new job. The cycle continues.
It's unlikely that any of the individuals responsible for the specific versions of whatever old game you fondly remember playing are still around. At the end of the day, what you're lamenting is the loss of an office building and a logo.
- TwoBit 12y agoYep. And what people don't understand here is that EA isn't killing Maxis, they're shutting down the Emeryville studio. Half of Maxis was already at the Ears studio on the Sims and other work. Sim City will be maintained and probably be a slow but steady seller for the next 7 years. All the best developers from that studio will simply be moved to jobs in other studios.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- cLeEOGPw 12y ago> Spore was a disappointment Spore was a textbook example of bad management. They spent 80% of time, money and effort on creature designer - a feature that did not make up even 20% of game, closer to 5%. Game had complex and massive functionality for libraries, various downloadable creatures, even tunes for cities, outfits for citizens - all things that were not just unnecessary, but one might say even made game less attractive (because usually you end up not being such great designer and all cities look equally generically bad). Essential features, such as autosave, were lacking. It is hard to fathom how detached from reality the managers were.
- mseebach 12y agoI don't know anything about the game or how it failed, but what you describe reads like a classic caricature of an engineer's wet dream: lots of fancy tech that's fun to build but not very useful to the end user, while comparatively boring but useful features (autosave) gets passed over. Sure, management also failed (any failure is by definition a failure of management since they're supposed to be responsible for the project) - but textbook? You hardly made the case for that.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoManagement letting engineers build whatever cool toys they want instead of features customers want and need sounds like it ought to be a textbook example of what not to do. Maybe you can't herd cats, but you can at least train them to use the litter box and not scratch your television.
- stickfigure 12y agoMaxis (and EA in general) doesn't really work like that. The producers and game designers are in charge; engineers may have some input but there are professionals running the show. And those professionals screw up a lot. It's a hard business. Maxis in particular suffered from the problem of having a bright, famous designer who produced two major hits. This gave him license to make dozens of failures. Unfortunately, Maxis started "betting the farm" on his last couple creations, with budgets into the high tens of millions. You don't get to roll the dice many times at that price.
- Shivetya 12y agopretty much explains Master of Orion III. to expand on that, likely the person in charge of a feature which consumed so much resources was untouchable. Considered too good to fail or have, gasp, a bad idea
- joeld42 12y agoThere's some really cool prototypes from the making of of spore that got put online. It's fascinating stuff: http://www.spore.com/comm/prototypes http://www.spore.com/comm/prototypes I would say that every part of Spore was fun, or at least could be, but they never were able to get them to mesh together in a cohesive whole.
- drzaiusapelord 12y ago>These laments are a bit overblown. Not to mention, a lot of these studios would have ended up bought by someone because, at the end of the day, they are investments geared and designed for an acquisition. Its not like EA came in there with machine guns and enslaved everyone. The point of these businesses is to make money first and make games second. There is no utopia where they aren't seeking buyers and a big paycheck. Its a rare shop that turns down "fuck you" money. Even indie-cred neckbeard hero Notch sold out to the "evil" MS empire. Enjoy your games, but don't expect everything to last. I kinda like the way the system works in some ways. It means the talented and the risk-takers who do a good job get paid. It also means there's going to be new blood soon in the space the Sims and Sim City lived in. The same way the zombie and world-builder genre, which was just expensive and milquetoast AAA titles, is now the darling of smaller and indie shops with excellent results. I'd love a new company to take on the Sims market. The Sims product is good but the lack of a real co-op or multiplayer is inexcusable. The managerial and creative fuck ups at Maxis are legendary at this point. Its best to put this cow out to pasture. Shame the entire Maxis team didn't fold. This not the Maxis of old and whoever is left over now failed to contemporize long ago.
- chc 12y agoWouldn't a hypothetical multiplayer Sims game look basically like Second Life?