4 ms·
I have a pet peeve, it's people thinking that my situation is the same as theirs, and giving me advice that is wrong for me. I get around 2400 spam a day. I'v
by RiderOfGiraffes 17y ago
I have a pet peeve, it's people thinking that my situation is the same as theirs, and giving me advice that is wrong for me.
I get around 2400 spam a day. I've tried three different spam filters recommended to me by people I trust and who generally know about these things, and they get about 97% to 98% accuracy. Worse, they produce false positives. With 50 spam per day, plus having to trawl through the spam bin to look for the false positives, I decided to write my own.
My spam filter is highly tuned to my traffic and I get about 10 spam through per day. More, there are about 2 false positives per month, although that's very hard to quantify.
The problem with putting up a form is that people want a reply, and yet they can't type their own email address properly. About half the emails I get through my various forms have subtle and not-so-subtle misspellings of the return address, and it can cost me hours to track them down.
No, obfuscated email addresses is still my best tool in this situation.
- mseebach 17y agoYour visitors that can't spell their own email address is likely to screw your obfuscated address up as well. I've seen email in my outbound queue to whatever@domain.dot.tld and variations. I wouldn't be surprised if someone never realizes that AT is @ (in non-English speaking locales, @=at is not at all obvious. In the Nordic languages it's known as (elephant's) trunk-A. ) and gives up before the mail leaving the client. reCaptcha Mailhide (http://mailhide.recaptcha.net/ http://mailhide.recaptcha.net/) is a good solution to this. It hides your e-mail behind a CAPTCHA, but once it's solved it's an actual, well-formed address, that can be copied or clicked. Also, it's very clear if you've solved the CAPTCHA - it's no always clear if solved the "riddle" of an obfuscation correctly.
- RiderOfGiraffes 17y ago> ... visitors that can't spell their own email address > ... likely to screw your obfuscated address up as well > ... it's no always clear if solved the "riddle" of an > obfuscation correctly. They are likely to screw it up, but at least they get the feedback of a bounced email. There is a recovery mode, and it's their problem. With an incorrectly spelled return address on a form there is no recovery mode at all, and they get no feedback that it hasn't worked.
- raganwald 17y agoit's their problem Isn't that the point of the article? That you are offloading work onto the peopel you ostensibly want to get in touch with you? (I'm not saying it's wrong for you to do so, just that your statement seems to line up perfectly with the author's premise that obfuscating your email address is taking your problem and making it their problem).
- RiderOfGiraffes 17y agoThe author suggests that using a form makes the problem go away. My experience says that people who can't de-obfuscate an email address frequently can't type their return address correctly. The obfuscated address gives them feedback in the form of a bounced email, and thereby gives a recovery mode. The incorrect return address in the form gives no recovery mode at all. To me, that's conclusive proof that the form is worse than the obfuscated address. Further, there's a balance to be achieved. I've analysed the types of people I want to contact me, and of those who can't work out my address there are two types. One type is those that I really don't care about - nuisance, spam, content-free, or time-wasters. The others that I do care about usually have a different route to me, one that's specifically tailored to them and made as easy as possible. That one has a specially designed anti-spam measure built into it.
- raganwald 17y agoI have to agree with your disdain for forms. I hope that when given the choic ebetween obfuscating an email address and providing a form, our response will be to improve our spam filtering and offer a plaintext mailto: link. Plaintext links have high usability. The mail is organized within the user's mail program where it can be retrieved, collated by subject, and so forth. It can be copied and pasted. It's the abslute best thing for them :-)
- pyre 17y agoHow many servers bounce email anymore as opposed to just 'blackhole'ing it so that spammers can't probe a domain for valid email addresses?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- TheElder 17y agoI'm using Gmail for my domain and received zero spams in well over a year. My email address is all over the web. What are you using for your spam filter?
- RiderOfGiraffes 17y agoI can't use gmail because I have the requirement to create email addresses on-the-fly. I have my own domain and can do that. The result is I need good spam filtering. My filtering now achieves around 99.6% filtering, and about 1 detected false positive per month. It would be interesting to see how gmail copes with my 2400 spam per day, and what accuracy it achieves, but it's a non-starter because of how I use email.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- nrr 17y agoI do this all the time with plus addressing.
- holygoat 17y ago... except that about 80% of form validation code incorrectly believes that foo+bar@zog.com is invalid.
- petewarden 17y agoI use a custom domain, but have it set up to forward all addresses to Gmail, mainly to use their spam filter. I'm not sure what your particular use-case for the on-demand addresses is, but you might be able to set up some Gmail label rules to sort it for you on that end too. The only downside is that you have to manually verify your custom domain's 'sent from' addresses in Gmail, so you can't easily reply from arbitrary addresses.
- pmjordan 17y agoI suspect you already know about this, but the google apps/domain service lets you add aliases and mailboxes painlessly.
- daleharvey 17y agoIf spam is still a problem, its pretty obvious your spam filter isnt working properly, that was kinda the point of the article