3 ms·
Or is the mere fact that I made it about a woman proof of its sexist nature? No, it is not the mere fact that it is about a woman. It is the context here and t
by Mz 12y ago
Or is the mere fact that I made it about a woman proof of its sexist nature?
No, it is not the mere fact that it is about a woman. It is the context here and the framing of the comments. It is the fact that, on the whole, this piece is not being talked about with the kind of respect with which her spouse's writing gets treated here. It is the fact that you and others are not asking how she knows or what it would take to prove it or any other questions that come from a place of "Well, this very powerful, intelligent, successful person has said something I do not understand and I would like to understand it better and learn from it." No, the comments here are mostly dismissive of the very idea that anyone can be any good at this or can objectively know they are far better than average. Most men get asked to show their work. Women get told they are full of shit. There is a difference between the two, a very big difference, and that difference boils down to fundamental respect.
It is in part a contextual thing that is very hard to prove bias on, but if you experience it, you eventually know that there are just no circumstances under which you will be taken seriously and there will always be some excuse and some plausible explanation why no one takes you seriously or respects you while they claim it is unrelated to your gender.
I will just leave this link here on the off-chance that you genuinely would like to understand what I am trying to convey:
http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2014/03/the-creepiness-of-silence-of-lambs.html http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2014/03/the-creepine...
- paul 12y agoI believe there is truth to what you say. It's very difficult to prove of course, but I've definitely noticed that certain founders seem to face a lot more skepticism than others. The great part about this business is that I can make money by investing in those that others are missing :)
- Mz 12y agoUnless they are so discouraged and boo-ed down that they give up, don't bother, can't get what they need to make it work and so on. In which case, you are leaving money on the table by allowing HN to remain too much of a Boy Zone.
- graeme 12y agoRealistically, what could be done about it? Serious question. I had the same reaction as you to these comments. It seemed like Jessica was getting a lot of skepticism relative to what PG or one of the male partners would have received from similar claims. But I don't know how I would change things. Any suggestions? Note: I'm truly baffled that many commentors here seem to think that judging character is i. impossible to do correctly, ii. undesirable, iii. skill in judging character is intrinsically impossible to evaluate
- Mz 12y agoIt is something I have been working on for a long time. I think things are getting better on HN. I think my comments here were relatively well-received. There was a time when my experience of HN was pretty negative. If you are male, some things that you can do include: Engage women in discussion about ideas and a) don't gush at them just because it's a woman speaking up b) don't give them condescending pats on the head of "encouragement" as if they would be more successful if only their girlie little feelings are helped to be more positive c) and invite them to push back. I previously had a blog post about "shoving matches." I am not currently finding it, which may mean it was not republished when my blog was moved, likely due to combination of it probably wasn't that well written and I am frequently busy with other things. In a nutshell, think of the scene in "Remember the Titans" where the white team captain gets into a shoving match with a black team member. Initially, the black team member is afraid to push back. That's the kind of thing that could end badly in the racist environment in which they live. But the team captain shoves again and invites him to shove back. He does finally shove back, they engage in a friendly shoving match, and that is the moment where the team becomes a team and race stops mattering. This can be done to a woman. It is possible to encourage her to argue with you in public in a way that is not dismissive of her. It is possible to invite women to stand their ground and defend their ideas. And that's one of the big things that needs to happen on HN.
- graeme 12y agoOh, actually I meant what could the mods do about it? Since you mentioned allowing HN to be a boy zone. I think (hope?) I'm fine personally as far as female engagement goes. I run a forum in my niche, a niche that's slightly majority female.
- scobar 12y agoHave you noticed any specific traits founders who face increased skepticism have that aren't apparent in other founders?
- throwawaymaroon 12y agoI don't actually know that she is or isn't getting more criticism because she's a woman. I just think you really underestimate how much contempt is stewing for YC and PG.
- DanBC 12y ago> No, the comments here are mostly dismissive of the very idea that anyone can be any good But this isn't something people are pulling from nowhere. There's plenty of research showing that people are lousy at making judgements. She hasn't said how she can make good judgement or how she knows she makes good judgement - there's just a bunch of handwavey stuff and people are criticising the handwavey descriptions, not necessarily her work.
- Mz 12y agoI worked in insurance for over 5 years. The fraud department had many of the same practices I have long used to judge social situations and character and what people are really up to. I processed claims and part of that job was keeping an eye out for indicators that it should be referred to the fraud department for further investigation -- ie judging if the paperwork submitted indicated that this person was possibly/probably a lying scumbag, engaging in a crime and of poor character. There are well developed paradigms in, for example, police work and courts of law for judging who is probably telling the truth, who is almost certainly full of shit, what the evidence supports, and so on. I will reiterate: Just because most people are terrible judges of character and overestimate their own ability does not prove Jessica is terrible at it. And just because her explanations are hand-wavey and not as precise and data-driven as the HN crowd would prefer, that does not prove she is simply self-deluded and full of shit. If people were really criticizing the hand-wavey descriptions, as you claim, they would be making different criticisms from what I have mostly seen here. The door has mostly been firmly closed to discussions of how this works when it is done well. There haven't been questions about how to do this in a more data-driven, less hand-wavey way. It has mostly just been a matter of pissing all over her and dismissing her claims.
- n72 12y agoI read the blog post and I absolutely agree that there are "subtle dangers a woman faces daily in the pursuit of a serious career -- dangers most people do not speak about and often politely go along with, in a sheep-like fashion." I was in fact just arguing yesterday with someone here on hn who objected to an Outreach Programme for Women as discriminatory and I was arguing that institutional discrimination is pervasive and very damaging to women's careers (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9138481 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9138481). Ironically, however, what I'm calling out Jessica on is one of the main things which contributes to institutional discrimination, namely not examining one's biases strongly enough. There are many well meaning men out there who think they're not sexist and don't want to be, but because sexism is institutionalized they don't even realize they are. In the same way, Jessica may think she's not discriminating against people from other cultures or people who may be socially awkward and such, but she may well be doing so. If both groups, if they were more aware of their biases, they would likely be less discriminatory. You may be right, maybe I called Jessica out because she's a woman. I really don't think so, but am open to the suggestion I did. I really don't see anything in my post, however, to indicate gender bias was a factor. In fact, I was calling her out for precisely the type of thinking which leads to gender bias.
- Mz 12y agoPeople who have good social radar are often imprecise and hand-wavey in their explanations of it. I have had to learn to explain it in much more precise terms. And I have had some relatively unusual opportunities to firm up my mental models and make it more data-driven, because the audience I had (my very aspie older son) needed that in order to understand it at all. So, most people with good social radar are not going to be able to readily give the precise, data-driven explanations that the HN crowd values so highly. But the reason I suspect Jessica is being dismissed based in part on her gender, rather than the hand-wavey nature of her assertions, is because of the framing of the criticism she is getting. As I said earlier, a lot of the comments here do not boil down to "please, show your work and prove you are right." They boil down "Oh, you are full of shit and no one can know that and, god, my respect for YC just plummeted" as if she had confessed that her method for deciding who to accept involved casting their horoscope or consulting a psychic. When I first joined HN, the top three people here all had about 50k karma and there was a much more collegial environment than currently exists. I was never given access to that collegial environment. I never got a mix of some acknowledgement that I might have a point and some criticism that not everyone agreed with me and the opportunity to state why I thought x, y or z. Instead, men on the leaderboard closed ranks. For a long time, if I said anything, you could bet dollars to donuts that two different people (not the same ones every time) from the leaderboard would chime in to announce how wrong I was. It took me literally years to figure out that this was going on in part because, for a woman, I had a high amount of karma and I was, thus, rocking the boat. Initially, I had no idea because, at the time, my karma was so far off from qualifying for a bottom rung on the leaderboard that I figured I was a Nobody and no one should be noticing me at all. However, I was able to infer (based on that social indicators in the way people reacted to me, in spite of the lack of hard data – in other words, “social radar”) that I was apparently prominent for a woman, in spite of my pathetically low amount of karma. Eventually, I was able to dig up real data proving that fairly firmly (in spite of the limits on the data available to me). Once I understood the position I was in, I was able to quit attracting so much damning attention. So what I am telling you is that a) Hacker News has deteriorated in some ways generally, which has hurt the experience of most members and I would like to see the bar raised such that the collegial environment returns generally and b) I would like women included in that respectful debate of ideas in a way I do not believe they have been previously included. And one way you can help achieve that, if you so desire, is to change the manner in which you criticize women and their "hand-wavey" attempts to express themselves. One thing that would really, really help a whole lot is make damn sure you understand that "absence of evidence is not evidence of absence." In other words, just because women are generally going to not be good at defending their positions on terms that the men here will readily accept does not, by itself, prove they are wrong. Just because the explanation is hand-wavey does not mean she is full of shit. Ask better questions. Encourage women to get the data that backs up their position. If they can't immediately do so, genuinely "agree to disagree" instead of pissing on them like they aren't worthy of any respect. Give women an opportunity to grow into the ability to communicate in more precise terms and learn to effectively back up their statements. Because shooting them down and pissing on them is not something that will ever help women up their game and learn to go toe-to-toe with the big boys. It merely excludes them. And thank you for reading my blog post and engaging me in good faith.