3 ms·
VC's are not risking their money they are risking yours. VC's get money from your insurer, pension provider, 401K and similar saving options. While you might i
by dogma1138 12y ago
VC's are not risking their money they are risking yours.
VC's get money from your insurer, pension provider, 401K and similar saving options.
While you might invest and gamble with your own money, VC's are literally gambling with everyone's future. And these days the regulations limiting insurance companies and private pension providers in investing their money in a VC or other types of risky capital are looser than ever.
While I won't to pretend to understand the details behind the article, but just looking at the many "startups" without a clear business plan, revenue stream not to mention profits which are valued in billions of dollars all of a sudden should make everyone's eyebrows rise if just a little.
10-15 years ago if you made an exit in 100's of millions it would be a worldwide sensation, these days it seems you sneeze and get 100M in funding and the WSJ posts an article about your company being valued higher than the GDP of some developing nations.
I remember when in the mid 90's Checkpoint got like 70M $ in it's NASDAQ IPO which was then a sensation which was talked about for year, these days that's considered a cold round 2 funding run for the next sexting app.
Even with "inflation" and all that other nonsense the fact that since 2006-2007 you could probably count at least 40 US techstartups which got valued for over 1bln should hint a that something stinks.
Heck evernote which their current business model seems to be more focused around selling 70$ socks and 200$ messenger bags instead of you know their own actual techonlogy is valued these days at what 4-5bln, really? A company with 18M in yearly revenues after almost 8 years with no real assets to speak off, with a user base smaller than even marginally popular online games with almost no profit that hasn't even returned it's initial investment runs is valued at 300 times their pre-tax income?
- sixQuarks 12y agoPension funds and similar investment vehicles put a tiny percentage of their money into VC funds. Those losses shouldn't affect the individuals much.
- dogma1138 12y agohttp://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2014-09-23/are-public-pensions-inflating-a-venture-capital-bubble http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2014-09-23/are-public-p... Insurance companies and pension funds make up 50% and upwards of an average VC. The rest of the money also comes from sources which directly affect you such as local government, banks, and other "public" institutions. "Rich individuals" on the other hand do make up only a fraction of the VC source funding with less than 2% on average. And while it's true that it doesn't represent the portion of the money a pension fund has invested in a specific VC. If you look at the breakout of your pension fund you'll find just how ridiculously high that percentage actually is. And BTW an insurance company or a pension fund that gets hit with even 5-10% loss means that tons of people lose coverage, premiums sky rocket and you end up losing more money that you could invest yourself otherwise.
- sharkweek 12y agoCalPERs only allocates ~1% to VC (still billions). VC is actually a pretty soft risk in the big picture of their private allocations: https://www.calpers.ca.gov/eip-docs/investments/policies/inv-asset-classes/pe/pe-prog.pdf https://www.calpers.ca.gov/eip-docs/investments/policies/inv...
- dogma1138 12y agoIt's their target not sure if those are actually the figures because in 2014 they were to scale from 7 to 1% in 5 years. There's info on that in the article. It was also not because of risk but because of low returns. Besides public funds you also have corporate and private funds which also risk a huge portion of their money in risky capital not only VC.
- sixQuarks 12y agoYou're using statistics in a misleading way. Total VC investments in 2014: $40 billion 300 largest pension funds control: $12.7 trillion Total annual VC investment is 0.003% of pension fund value. That doesn't even include insurance companies and other smaller pension funds. It doesn't mean anything when you say half of VC funds come from pension funds. It's still a miniscule amount when looking at the total value of pension funds.
- rlucas 12y ago1. dogma1138, your own cite doesn't support your "insurance and pension is > 50%" figure. The Bloomberg link shows a 2014 graphic where: Public pension: 20% Corporate pension: 7% Insurance companies: 7% Union pension funds: 2% --- "Insurance and pension" total: 36% (This is the fraction of the VC's fund that is committed by those types of institutions, NOT how much of those institutions' portfolios are in VC; see below for that.) 1.5. Elsewhere in this thread, dogma1138 suggests that the Bloomberg mention of CALPERS trimming their VC allocation is "to 1 percent, from 7 percent..." What is left off is the crucial kicker: "...of its private equity portfolio." Meaning that even CALPERS is allocating only 0.5% or so to ALL its venture capital managers. 2. The fraction of an institutional portfolio that goes to any one VC fund is usually well under 1%. How it actually works (foundation / endowment model): - Estimate asset class returns, volatilities, and covariances. This is done with historical analysis and some forward-looking hand-wave mumbo-jumbo. - Chart out the "efficient frontier" of expected return per unit "risk" (volatility of return) across several model portfolios (each of which is a set of % allocations to the various asset classes). This makes a nice hyperbola that looks like a "C" and you pick one of the ones in the top left, meaning, more return and less risk. - That asset allocation will almost certainly look something like: Public Equity: most Bonds: second-most Hedge Funds: small Private Equity: small "Alternatives" in vogue at the time (timber, gold, real estate, rice paddies, comic book royalties, whatever): small (Where "small" usually means < 15%) - Then, within the "Private Equity" bucket, you divvy that up and do a similar exercise: Large Buyout: most Middle-Market: recently more fashionable Venture Capital: small (Here, the VC part of private equity is likely 0-25%, unlikely to be a big part of the PE bucket.) - Then, within each of those buckets, you pick a variety of "managers." Probably at least 3-5 in the VC bucket. - Then, with each VC "manager" (VC firm) you allocate your commitments such that you can have some continuity of investment across the serial funds of that firm. (Note: if you don't have the size or sophistication to manage managers, you might just buy a "fund of funds" to achieve diversification within the VC sub-allocation of your PE allocation). If an institution has 10% allocated to PE, they might have 2% allocated to VC, and of that, 0.5% might be allocated to a particular manager (firm), and it might well be put no more than 0.25% into a particular fund. 2.5 Insurers and pensions work differently from the above (endowment/foundation model) in some ways, the same in other ways. Crucially they both have to manage the expected liabilities of near term payouts -- but they don't do that with private equity / venture investments, they do it with bonds. See "immunization." They do, however, try to generate a "total return" on the surplus that is not expected to be used near term. Also I'm leaving out minimum 5% spend, etc., I know. 3. It is totally rational to put a small but meaningful sliver of your large portfolio into venture capital, especially and crucially at a time when entire industries (e.g. taxicab, booksellers, maybe internal combustion cars??) can get decimated by technology disruption within a decade. If nothing else, it's like buying a cheap put against the old-line stocks in your portfolio. 4. Yes, VC has its issues but dogma1138 is not pointing out any of them. So, I'm sorry, but you're completely out to lunch if you think a VC fund or private equity fund is going to cause an insurer or pension "even 5-10% loss [such that] tons of people lose coverage, premiums sky rocket," etc.
- tlogan 12y agoI 100% agree with you. Majority of companies in the private market will go to zero. The other problem is that today's so called "tech companies" have very little with tech. And, sadly, many companies including Evernote found out that hype pays more that actual working product. So they sell socks: why not? It gives them more revenue then Evernote subscription. So there will be no new Oracle, new Cisco, new Sun in this bubble... Just bubble... 3rd in my life.... I hope will make money in next one.