3 ms·
"because there's no generally agreed upon positive account for how cognition works, AGI is impossible in the near term." Mis-characterization as it's completel
by AndrewKemendo 12y ago
"because there's no generally agreed upon positive account for how cognition works, AGI is impossible in the near term."
Mis-characterization as it's completely plausible that we can get to AGI without emulating cognition at all. So that is explicitly not the point I am making and no one is even stating as much.
You said it yourself though:
but it's piecemeal and has not been adequately integrated
Integration is the foundation of GENERAL intelligence and is exactly what I am saying. How learning across domains works is a black box - like total black box right now - which means we can't build a roadmap to it without probing the edges more.
Excellent accounts of how intelligence work can be contained in the minds of a few researchers who aren't going to the trouble of publishing them and proving them to others. Instead, they're just hard at work on the highest payoff activity: designing software that realizes and proves their vision/idea.
Hooray, a hypothesis! Is there anything that you can point to that would support the idea of lone wolf AGI developers? In my study there isn't due primarily to computational and mathematical requirements that take a community to support. Even in such a case there is basically nothing we can do about it because it's unknowable - like lone wolf terrorists. So practically it's not worth discussing. Note also that this isn't even what Bostrom et. al are discussing.