3 ms·
I should preface this by saying that there's a huge amount of education research published every year, and it generally falls on deaf ears. (Some of my friends
by smt88 12y ago
I should preface this by saying that there's a huge amount of education research published every year, and it generally falls on deaf ears. (Some of my friends do this research, and it's obviously very dispiriting for them.) I hope that the anecdotes you collect here will simply be a supplement to a review of that research. There are many professors and non-profits that would love to help you.
I also want to say that I'm strongly against traditional homework structure. I'm a huge proponent of a flipped classroom[1]. It decreases the opportunity/incentive to cheat, makes learning more social, and uses the teacher's time in a much more effective way.
Some background:
I come from a family of math geniuses (literally). I'm not one myself, but I was still very above-average at my highly-ranked high school.
Because I "just got" math and science without any trouble, I almost never did my homework. I loathed (and still loathe) tedious, repetitive work.
The result is that I'm much worse at math and science as an adult. I've forgotten most of calculus and physics. Like all learning, it sticks better with repetition.
My brother also skipped his homework. He's so good at math that he can figure pretty much anything out -- there's no element of memorization, like there is for some people. But it does take him longer because his experience at any given math problem is limited or, in some cases, zero.
If he were a computer, you could say that his CPU is so powerful, he doesn't have to rely much on RAM. Most humans (like myself), however, have lots of available memory but much less CPU. Keeping some things in memory makes us a lot faster.
All this is to say that your students, especially your smart ones, will rebel against doing their homework. For that reason, I'd strongly recommend a reliance on word problems.
First of all, word problems are much more like real-life problems. Second, they keep things at least somewhat interesting. Even if the resulting calculations are the same every time, there's some element of puzzle/mystery (as well as variety) with a word problem.
I actually studied physics and calculus at the same time, and it made calculus much more interesting when I was always able to connect it to real-world physical problems. I imagined my own context around the dry numbers on the worksheets.
So if you do have traditional, take-home homework, try to minimize the monotony, even if the repetitiveness is there by necessity.
1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flipped_classroom http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flipped_classroom
- japhyr 12y agoI hope that the anecdotes you collect here will simply be a supplement to a review of that research. Definitely. We're a small alternative school, of about 30 students. We're planning to revise our policy with students. We're going to collect student stories about homework first, then look at some research, then look at a few exemplary policies, and then draft our own. We'll include some measures of whether the policy is meaningful or not as well; a policy that isn't followed well is meaningless. I feel strongly that people's stories put the research in context. Knowing personal stories around homework makes the research much more meaningful and relevant to students. All this is to say that your students, especially your smart ones, will rebel against doing their homework. Yes! They already do, because many of them have been burned by years of bad homework policies. We're trying to undo the effect of those bad policies, and build a positive mindset around doing meaningful work that students are interested in outside of class time.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- smt88 12y agoIf you work very closely with the parents and get them on board, you'll stand a much better chance of getting the homework done (even if the student doesn't enjoy it). I've known friends' parents who believed all their kids' homework was being done or that it was busy work, so they never monitored it or forced their kid to do it.
- edc117 12y agoThank you for that link; it was the first introduction I'd had to that concept. A lot of it resonates with the experiences I've had with traditional learning throughout my high school and even college years, vs 'active' learning I found I had to adapt while doing my master's degree.