3 ms·
> Why should I lie to them about my level of interest and personality just to get a job offer? I think that's the crux of these two different viewpoints, and I
by sanderjd 12y ago
> Why should I lie to them about my level of interest and personality just to get a job offer?
I think that's the crux of these two different viewpoints, and I think it is merely different tactics falling out of different strategies. On the one hand, if your strategy is to find work that you're interested in and are a great personal fit for, then it absolutely makes sense to prioritize being yourself above getting the job. If, on the other hand, your strategy is to get this job, either because you're very ambitious and this is a high-paying, high-status, or career-expanding position, or (more likely for most people in the real world) you really really need a job to pay your bills, then it might make sense to "please the interviewer in order to be granted the prize of a job".
tl;dr; The answer to your question that I quoted is, Because you prioritize getting this job over getting the "right" job.
The more interesting question is whether the tactic of being nonchalant still works better, even if you're desperate to get the job. I think it probably does, but the great Catch-22 of the job market is that it is so much easier to get jobs when you don't need them.
- picks_at_nits 12y agoI wanted to take some time before answering this, to make sure that my feelings did not change, and they haven’t. I do not consider a question of pretending to be someone I’m not a question of “strategy.” I do not need to convince myself that it leads to some better outcome for me to be authentic with people. It’s one of my values, and values are things you explicitly recognize are sometimes sub-optimal for the things you wish to pursue.
- sanderjd 12y agoI think you read my comment in a much more personal way than was intended, but I can see why, and I'm sorry for that. I didn't at all mean to suggest that you (personally) are playing out a "strategy" that you have devised to get ahead, and I absolutely got the impression from your original comment that it is a matter of values for you, which I think is great. My point was mostly that for many people interviewing for jobs, that authenticity is a luxury that is difficult for them to achieve.
- picks_at_nits 12y agoI think I understand what you are trying to say, but when you describe values as “luxuries,” I think we’re standing on opposite sides of a chasm shouting at each other.