8 ms·
Clinton ran own computer system for her official emails
- rubiquity 12y agoAre we supposed to pretend the NSA doesn't exist and Hillary Clinton has a bunch of emails the government doesn't know about?
- ctdonath 12y agoIt's not the NSA we're worried about. It's that Secretary Of State Hillary Clinton was receiving, storing, and transmitting official secrets illegally on a secret personal email server, subject to extreme risk of antagonistic foreign powers snooping that server and acquiring those secrets. One may wonder why she would arrange such a system in her own home. One may wonder if she wanted such covert foreign access to such documents, the security risks being so obvious.
- sp332 12y agoThe NSA doesn't seem to share much with other agencies. So most of "the government" might not know about it.
- knotty66 12y agoDid you read about parallel construction? https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/08/dea-and-nsa-team-intelligence-laundering https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/08/dea-and-nsa-team-intel...
- tedunangst 12y agoAt this point I think everybody has read about parallel construction.
- o0-0o 12y agoThe problem is not that the government doesn't know about them, it's that the PEOPLE don't know about them.
- rubiquity 12y agoBut if the emails were sent from the government's servers the people still wouldn't know about them.
- artmageddon 12y agoFor all intents and purposes, yes, the people wouldn't know about it, but there's supposed to be some form of oversight into the actions of political officials, and this circumvents it.
- joelrunyon 12y agoBut you could (in theory), request them under a FIOA
- Mtinie 12y agoI don't see a reason that you would be detered from submitting the same FIOA request for these emails. I expect the likelihood of getting a response and a set of documents sent to you would be the same as it would be if her emails were hosted through the Department of State's mail server.
- joelrunyon 12y agoBecause it's on a private server, not a government operated one. Gives her legal coverage.
- nitid_name 12y agoIf she had her own mail server, it's probably fair to assume she could have set it up as her outbound mail server and to use TLS of some sort when connecting to it.
- pdabbadabba 12y agoYes they would. They would be handed over to the National Archives as a matter of course (except the classified ones, etc.) It's still possible that they could be handed over from her personal account, but this bypasses the various controls that are supposed to be in place to ensure the fullest possible disclosure.
- dublinclontarf 12y agoDefine "The Government", it's not a single uniform body, various branches and factions work with and against each other.
- TheRealDunkirk 12y agoGovernmental -- i.e., public -- communications are supposed to be available for review. Certainly, the Secretary of State can legitimately claim national security issues, but using an external system just gives the appearance that Clinton would like to be able to obfuscate even-legitimate internal requests for her communication. For instance, the paper trail about Bengazi is already damning enough. I'm quite sure she'd like to avoid showing her office's internal -- and her personal -- correspondence on this issue. Unless you're suggesting that the NSA would present that communication (which I agree they have access to) in court, I think this is a non-sequitor.
- caseysoftware 12y agoI was interviewed by NewsRadio 106.7 about this about an hour ago. The podcast will be online here in a couple hours: http://michaelgraham.com http://michaelgraham.com
- toast0 12y agoIf Clinton can run her own email server, why are so many people allergic to running their own servers? (PS, hope she had a business internet connection so she wasn't violating ToS)
- nissimk 12y agoClinton employs a large staff of people, some of whom are apparently email experts. I think that probably helps to reduce the allergy symptoms.
- waps 12y agoNo, because it's a violation of the law. The federal government is supposed to keep records of everything they do, for several reasons : 1) they are accountable to the people. Granted this is a principle. At some point in the future, everything the federal government did will become open knowledge. 2) It must be possible to get them in front of the justice system. This is a basic principle of a separation-of-powers democracy. The justice system is, by law, entitled to access any and all documents, emails, everything any agency has (just so we're clear : not talking about the judge down the street, although they have some access, but the supreme court has full, unquestionable, access) 3) FOIA (freedom of information act). Citizens and others can petition the justice system to make government documents public. Unless the justice system and the federal government agree something can not be made public, it is made public. This is extremely prominently mentioned on every computer system anywhere near the federal government. Record keeping requirements this, email archival that. Ms. Hillary Clinton did not miss these requirements. She knowingly violated the law and conducted official government business in an illegal manner. Ms. Clinton knowingly, and with the aid of dozens of people working for her on the public's dime violated the law. In theory the minimum punishment for this is to become unelectable for 5 years, but "somehow" I doubt that will happen. Also there seems little doubt that the emails she will make public will be a filtered version of the original. This is comparable to fraud (though technically not fraud) : if you did this as a CEO of a publicly traded company, it would be considered fraud, and you could very well go to jail for that.
- wyc 12y ago
- aw3c2 12y ago*Hillary
- sp332 12y agoWhoever is the most relevant gets the shorter name, in a kind of Huffman-like coding. If you say "Bush" now, people think you mean the 43rd president, even though earlier they would have thought of the 41st president.
- BocceBaal 12y agoIf I see 'Bush' now I actually think Jeb, who wants to be #45.
- tormeh 12y agoBut the headline should differentiate because there are more than one Clinton in the public sphere. "H. Clinton" would have been enough.
- tedunangst 12y ago"her" wasn't a sufficient clue?
- tormeh 12y agoI don't think Her was in the headline at the time. I think it was just something a la "Clinton ran email server from home" or something.
- sp332 12y agoI think you're right. Here's the old one http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/U/US_DEM_2016_CLINTON_EMAILS_HOMEBREW_SERVER?SITE=AP&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2015-03-04-03-15-48 http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/U/US_DEM_2016_CLINTON_E... and the newer one http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/U/US_DEM_2016_CLINTON_EMAILS_SERVER?SITE=AP&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2015-03-04-08-09-46 http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/U/US_DEM_2016_CLINTON_E...
- fl0wenol 12y agoI want to be mad that a high-profile public servant created and used an email capability that allowed her to skirt record laws if ever challenged. But... it's a really good idea. Hell, I used to run my own back in the day before my ISP started prohibiting it (around 2003ish?) So I'm conflicted.
- billpg 12y agoAre you a public official conducting the public's business through your own mail server? If not, you've got nothing to feel guilty about. (At least not in this regard. You may or may not have other unrelated things to feel guilty about.)
- lotsofmangos 12y agoI left a personal email and webserver running in my parents shed for a few years on an old debian box. It was useful, I keep meaning to set up another one. Personally I think that it is great that a high profile public servant went and ran their own personal server from their house. It suggests a level of competency and it encourages other people to try and set up their own servers from home.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ratsbane 12y agoWas the server actually at her house or was the domain name just registered with that as an address? Neither option seems even slightly damning.
- damoncali 12y agoI interpreted it as "she's using Google Apps on her own domain, which has a registered address of her house". But it's not exactly clear.
- o0-0o 12y agoWho Is Eric Hoteham? Clinton's private server was registered under his name. Is he real?
- joelrunyon 12y agoI think the bigger issue is that she's skirting rules that the rest of gov't has to follow. Similar to the trend of government setting rules for everyone that they conveniently exempt themselves from.
- davesque 12y agoNot necessarily. A much more important issue to me is the fact that top-ranking government officials are using e-mail for official business at all. If there's any reason to be concerned that Clinton was using an insecure account for official e-mails, that implies that other government officials use e-mail to communicate sensitive information. Since e-mail is inherently insecure (unless you're using GPG or PGP or some other kind of message level encryption, which they're probably not), this is the real problem here.
- Retric 12y agoHaving worked with / for the US government, encryption and signing email is actually fairly common. For the most part people use a 2+ factor authentication and their smart cards have private keys. EX: http://www.cac.mil/common-access-card/ http://www.cac.mil/common-access-card/ After it's set up Outlook then let's people encrypt with a simple click. The recipient then needs their card + PIN to decrypt. PS: This is one of those cases where the US Government seems to be significantly ahead of the private sector in terms of actual adoption and use.
- vondur 12y agoPretty interesting that it's being run from her own house. I guess if anyone has any idea about how the NSA operates, it would be her.
- imgabe 12y agoSurely, this must have been common knowledge at the State Dept. Wouldn't they have noticed that her emails came from a domain that wasn't dos.gov? And if she was communicating with other State Department officials, wouldn't the emails they received from her at their dos.gov email be part of the public record anyway, defeating the purpose of running your own server?
- lisper 12y agoHer emails may have looked like they did come from dos.gov. It's trivial to spoof a From header.
- hga 12y agoDoes not appear to be the case, "Guccifer" was the first to bring this to light after he broke into Sidney Blumenthal's AOL account, they came from "hdr22@clintonemail.com".
- 3am 12y agoHah! Try spoofing an email to a recipient in the State Dept and tell me how it works out :)
- lisper 12y agoFind me someone in the State Department willing to be the recipient and I will happily conduct this experiment. Why do you think it would be any harder to spoof an email to the State Dept than anywhere else?
- mergy 12y agoI'm okay if she ran Postfix. If she ran Sendmail, I have issues.
- 3am 12y agoSo, anyone with a brain realizes this is a political hit job leading up to the 2016 presidential election. So the promotion of this story has very few honest brokers involved & a lot of partisan motivation. But I am genuinely curious about this. It doesn't seem like wrongdoing per se, or even anything unethical. But I don't like the trend of losing documents from the historical record. And I think that (while her email security is probably better than State Dept. as a whole) it probably would have been better as the leader to hold herself to the same standards as everyone in the organization as a general principle. Curious to hear if anyone here has .gov experience and can give useful insight into the story.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rian 12y agohehe someone has been watching house of cards a bit too earnestly.
- whoisthemachine 12y agoIt is unethical if she used it to hide government business that should be available to the public.
- mullingitover 12y ago> So, anyone with a brain realizes this is a political hit job leading up to the 2016 presidential election. This. Recall that only a few weeks ago, the leading republican candidate was falling all over himself announce that he was publishing all his emails from his time in office. In the seemingly desperate rush to make a spectacle of it, he didn't even redact the emails [1], and released a big pile of private data as a result. Also, given the state of the State Department's computer network [2], who can blame her? But the most telling part is that she wasn't even the first Secretary of State to do this, she was the last. I don't say this because I'm a supporter, it just seems like obvious political theater being run by the rival camp and merits being called out. Personally I'm disappointed that both the Clinton and Bush campaigns aren't being laughed off the stage. Political aristocracy is repugnant and has no place in this country. [1] http://www.theverge.com/2015/2/10/8013531/jeb-bush-florida-email-dump-privacy http://www.theverge.com/2015/2/10/8013531/jeb-bush-florida-e... [2] http://gizmodo.com/state-department-computer-systems-hit-by-hackers-1659549503/1686899463/+chris-mills http://gizmodo.com/state-department-computer-systems-hit-by-...
- jstalin 12y agoIs there an archive of domain mx records out there? That would seem to clear up exactly where her email was hosted. Edit: the current mx records are below: ;; ANSWER SECTION: clintonemail.com. 5495 IN MX 10 clintonemail.com.inbound10.mxlogic.net. clintonemail.com. 5495 IN MX 10 clintonemail.com.inbound10.mxlogicmx.net.
- danellis 12y agoHaving her email rely on Mexico's DNS servers doesn't seem like a terribly good idea.
- etcet 12y agoThe MX in this case refers to mail exchanger rather than Mexico.
- danellis 12y agoI was referring to the mx, not the MX, but you're right -- those records were truncated for some reason. It's actually mxlogicmx.com. (There is a mail provider using the mx domain, though. I don't recall its name.)
- scottlinux 12y agohttp://front.dnstrails.com/tools/lookup.htm?domain=clintonemail.com&date=20110101 http://front.dnstrails.com/tools/lookup.htm?domain=clintonem...
- hackuser 12y agoWithout government resources, it's hard to imagine this server could be secured, copying the data to two private companies creates much more exposure. The rule of security is to make the attack more expensive than it's worth to your adversary. How much are the U.S. Secretary of State's emails worth? Certainly they are worth billions, and I'd guess even trillions of dollars; the information could make existential differences, for example to security of entire nations. In addition, the money you could make with foreknowledge of U.S. policies, for example in oil markets, seems astronomical. I expect that foriegn intelligence services, with billions in reources and highly skilled personnel, had access to her mail. I expect some private interests also did.
- imgabe 12y agoIt seems the objection to this practice is that government email is supposed to be insecure by design in that anyone should be able to access it by making a FOIA request. To me, that seems kind of silly. I can imagine there a lot of legitimate reasons the Secretary of State would not want their email to be publicly accessible.
- hackuser 12y ago> It seems the objection to this practice is that government email is supposed to be insecure by design in that anyone should be able to access it by making a FOIA request. To me, that seems kind of silly. I can imagine there a lot of legitimate reasons the Secretary of State would not want their email to be publicly accessible. Security doesn't mean everything is inaccessible, it means you control who, when, and where the data can be utilized. Obviously not all of the Secretary of State's email should be publicly accessible, but 1) the law as implemented by the government, and not a private individual, should control access, 2) someone needs to ensure control is maintained and prevent unauthorized access, and a private individual probably doesn't have the resources to do it.
- CPLX 12y agoFrom what I have read so far there doesn't appear to be any evidence whatsoever that the server was hosted in her actual home. And that certainly would be a strange, strange thing to do. All it would take is an ice storm in Westchester to put her ability to read and send emails out of commission. Ockham's razor tells me it's more likely the media is speculating based on a whois record or similar. Scanning the existing comments I don't see anything more definitive than that. Is there any actual reason to think the email server was physically in suburban NY?
- jstalin 12y agoSee my post below. The mx records point to mxlogic, which provides email filtering services, not hosting (as far as I can tell). It looks like she may have indeed run her own email server.
- CPLX 12y agoRight, I don't find it implausible at all that she ran her own email server, by some definition of that expression. I do, however, find it at least somewhat implausible that said server was in a residential home in Westchester NY. More to the point I don't see any evidence at all that it was physically there besides speculation. If there is such evidence (like IP addresses or similar) floating around, that would be interesting.
- bigfaceworm 12y agoNot excusing the behavior, but it's not new: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bush_White_House_email_controversy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bush_White_House_email_controve...
- jstalin 12y agoI tried sending an email to that domain to see if it would bounce back, but it didn't. I was hoping to get the server's IP address. Looks like bouncebacks were working yesterday, but have been disabled: http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-03-03/hdr22clintonemailcom-how-romanian-hacker-exposed-hillary-clintons-secret-email-life http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-03-03/hdr22clintonemailco... Edit: I tried to telnet to the server: telnet clintonemail.com 25 Trying 208.91.197.27... telnet: Unable to connect to remote host: Connection timed out Where is that IP address? British Virgin Islands: http://www.ip-address.org/lookup/ip-locator.php?track=208.91.197.27 http://www.ip-address.org/lookup/ip-locator.php?track=208.91...
- spoiledtechie 12y agoI really hate the fact that this is a technical discussion or its an attack on her or a smear campaign. The underlying fact is, she broke the LAW. That means she should be dragged through the punishment of the law. Stop supporting her or making excuses. The society of today really stops caring so much about the rule of law, but rather what they have for an opinion. But I ask you if you if murder is against the law, do you support it? We shouldn't be supporting this either way. It was plainly against the law and she broke that law. If you have a problem with it, then change the law. Stop sticking up for someone that blatantly broke the law.
- maxerickson 12y agoWhat law did she break? I don't say that as support, I just haven't seen any clear explanation of that yet.
- spoiledtechie 12y agoAsk Google.. http://www.reviewjournal.com/news/nation-and-world/did-hillary-clinton-break-federal-laws-email http://www.reviewjournal.com/news/nation-and-world/did-hilla...
- maxerickson 12y agoYour link says Former U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton may have violated federal records laws by using a personal email account for all of her work messages, the New York Times reported on... and goes on to quote some speculation from unnamed experts. You said It was plainly against the law and she broke that law. I was hoping you could explain more than the press articles have been, because you made it sound like you could.
- growupkids 12y agoI'll probably get down voted for this, so be it. I worked in the Clinton whitehouse in the mid-90s. Every time you sent an email, which was on a cluster of VAX servers, you got a full screen notification about the presidential records act, and you had to agree affirmatively if something was, or was not an official record. If you said no, it still got archived, it just got flagged so a FoIA might not be valid against your email. We simply backed everything up to tape, and sent it to NARA. My first week there we got subpeoneDed. I remember being asked to volunteer to go up to greenbelt Maryland to help restore tapes for records requests. There is absolutely no way she or anyone else that worked woth here didnt know your needed to archive emails. Subpoenas happened regularly, and everyone knew Emails = record. Years later after I left I landed a contract with a government contractor to recover thse tapes, against federal lawsuits, emails are records and the courts want them. Par for the course. I'd argue the Clinton whitehouse was the first administration to truly face electronic records retention effects with the courts. Nixon maybe being the first with audio tapes, the clintons got email Subpeonas. So when I hear she was running her own email server and staying outside federal records retention requirements, I both nodded knowingly that I would expect nothing less from the wife of a man that learned first hand: keep no records, and then shook my head ruefully knowingly why she did it: Keep no records. When public leaders avoid record keeping requirements, this prevents public scrutiny, and that means they no longer work for you because they aren't accountable to you. Maybe you agree with her, but you'll never know what she did in your name. Hillary knew what she was doing. I have no doubt of this, as I said I would expect nothing less. I would be shocked if she didn't do this. Stunned really. I'm still paranoid about what I put in written form (text, email, etc.) to this day. This was calculated, to keep her unaccountable and off the record.