8 ms·
The Drug Cartels' IT Guy
- huherto 12y agoNot only IT professionals. My family knew a young man who did contracting work on a small town. Very hard working. They took him, and no one has heard about him ever since. The rumor is that they use them to build the facilities they need. He left a young wife with small children. Really tragic.
- S_A_P 12y agoMy first thought about the enslavement is that the threat of killing their family would be a powerful disincentive to turn on the cartel. Either way this is tragic, I feel for all those affected by this.
- wahsd 12y agoI also don't agree with the sentiment that the intellect of these people would lead them to turn the tables on their captors. Are you really going to risk having your whole family eradicated? I think it would only take a couple surveillance pictures of all of their family members for them to cooperate even if they realize there is no way they will make it out alive.
- whyaduck 12y agoYes - Bunker's commentary (he's the War College professor) seems overly generalized and a bit weird. "Prima donna's"? How does he know know "hacker types" don't function well in captivity? Was there a study?
- MichaelGG 12y agoBut there's not a single case, there's 100% leak prevention. You'd think at least one family would have fled and made it known. Nobody but dead men run opsec that tight, right?
- ufmace 12y agoI think the interesting question here is to what extent are the personnel responsible for building this comm infrastructure kidnapped/enslaved/coerced versus being there mostly voluntarily. There's some merit to the argument that it's much riskier and probably more expensive for the cartels to kidnap and hold these people than to pay them enough to work voluntarily. The main argument against that is how many people have disappeared with no contact with their families, and that the families aren't getting any money. But then, we don't know where these people are, what they're doing, and what degree, if any, of coercion is being applied. The wild card is the Governments' unwillingness to even acknowledge the problem. That suggests that it embarrasses them. What's more embarrassing to the government, though? That the cartels might be powerful enough to kidnap people at will all over their country? Doesn't sound particularly newsworthy or worthy of suppression, considering what else is going on there. How about the extent to which upper-middle class educated people are willingly working with the cartels to build high-end infrastructure? I could see that being very embarrassing indeed. It makes it seem like the cartels are inching closer to being the legitimate government of major parts of the country. That sounds much more like something worth denying and suppressing. I have no idea if there's any truth to it, but the motives seem to line up in that direction.
- smacktoward 12y agoIn the case of the cartels there's varying degrees of "voluntarily." Mexican and Colombian cartels have long been able to coerce "voluntary" cooperation from people they need by posing them a choice: plata o plomo, "silver or lead." In other words, you can cooperate with the cartel and be rewarded with cash, or not cooperate and be "rewarded" with bullets. It's your choice! But it's not much of a choice, of course. What's interesting here (to me, anyway) is the need to physically kidnap and hold the person, rather than just coercing the behavior the cartels want via the plata o plomo approach. The cartels certainly have enough plata to hire talent, if it's needed; and once hired, the threat of the plomo should keep them quiet, right? So what would the cartel gain by enslaving the person? I'm not sure.
- S4M 12y ago> So what would the cartel gain by enslaving the person? I'm not sure. My guess is that they are afraid that this person goes to speak, or gets contacted by the police and install a backdoor in the cartel's system. Maybe the heads of the cartels, not knowing how IT works, are super paranoid about it and want to keep their IT "personnel" at hand constantly.
- pakled_engineer 12y agoThere was a guy here who provisioned 'secure phones' to a bunch of gangsters and they shot him when they turned out to be not as secure as advertised.
- 33W 12y agoIn regards to finding the narco radio stations, wouldn't it be trivial to triangulate their location and destroy them?
- avn2109 12y agoI thought this too, since as far back as the 1940's the Nazis could put the necessary radio triangulating hardware in a van. But then I realized that the people tasked with doing the finding are on the payroll of the Cartels, and will therefore go to great lengths to never find any transmitters.
- sliverstorm 12y agoI don't think you have to be on the payroll of the cartel to want to never find the cartel.
- cheepin 12y agoyeah, not wanting to die is probably enough incentive for whoever replaced the last guy who found a cartel.
- peteretep 12y agoCouldn't an AWACS plane to find + some drones to execute be worked from sufficient distance as to remove cartel influence?
- _cudgel 12y agoAt some point, you'd think we'd have the sense to legalize all these substances that the cartels trade in to cut crime and drain them of their money and power.
- a3n 12y agoToo late. As the article says, they're into much more than drugs now. The problem is no longer drugs, it's cartels.
- sliverstorm 12y agoWell then clearly all we have to do is legalize everything else they do too!
- MichaelGG 12y agoYeah, like Google is into much more than advertising now. Taking out drug money would be a massive crimp in their style. In fact, I'd be surprised if it wouldn't pretty much destroy their style, and suggestions to the contrary are just given by the government to continue the drug war.
- hackuser 12y agoPreviously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8568394 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8568394
- rwallace 12y agoHave any of the missing people ever been seen alive again? This article and the previous one on the topic posted here both seem to be saying no, the mortality rate is one hundred percent. If that's true, it suggests a personal rule for anyone living in or visiting that area: if the cartels come for you, fight to the death on the spot rather than let yourself be taken.
- smeyer 12y agoAssuming you only care about your own life. If the two alternatives are (1) be kidnapped, do some work, then murdered vs (2) fight to the death and have your family killed in retaliation, I could see how your suggested personal rule might be suboptimal for a lot of people living in that area.
- rwallace 12y agoTrue enough. Is that the actual state of affairs?
- jpatokal 12y agoYes. http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/mexican-militiaman-and-his-family-killed-after-speaking-out/2014/06/27/16072be6-3dbb-4076-8da8-9ed0a3c8ccda_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/mexican-militiaman-and-h... http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1375578/Drug-cartels-murder-children-scare-rival-gangs-Mexico.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1375578/Drug-cartels...
- wyck 12y agoRobert Bunker's opinion is the only thing that makes sense in that article.
- Animats 12y agoThat article is mostly a rehash of a 2011 NPR article.[1] More technical information is available in Popular Science (I know, bad source) [2]. Here's a video of some captured gear.[3] From the video and descriptions, it looks like they're using walkie talkies with repeaters, like a police radio system. They used some minimal scrambling, just enough to prevent people with scanners from listening in. That's cheap, easily available gear. [1] http://www.npr.org/2011/12/09/143442365/mexico-busts-drug-cartels-private-phone-networks http://www.npr.org/2011/12/09/143442365/mexico-busts-drug-ca... [2] http://www.popsci.com/article/technology/radio-tecnico-how-zetas-cartel-took-over-mexico-walkie-talkies http://www.popsci.com/article/technology/radio-tecnico-how-z... [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MT9-dDxkbJc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MT9-dDxkbJc
- walshemj 12y agoso your'e a Telco guy going into bandit country why the fuck wasn't he escorted by a couple of bricks (fire teams). From what I know of telecoms during the troubles that is how it worked in the border areas between Eire and NI in no way did one engineer (lineman) drive in his van to a site in the more dangerous parts of the contry
- superuser2 12y agoWhen the cartels have state-level resources, at one point do we stop treating them like criminals and start treating them like enemy states?
- grecy 12y agoThese "be afraid of the outside world" articles are getting less and less subtle. > It’s a story that’s common across Mexico. People vanish Statements like that are so misleading. More people are killed in NYC and Chicago than Mexico city, but you never see headlines about that.
- nsp 12y agoWhile that might be true (at least per capita, I can't find any recent sources for the murder rate in Mexico City), Mexico does hold the distinction of having 10 of the top 20 cities in terms of murders per capital (US has 4), as well as an overall murder rate of 21.5/100,000 people vs the United States with 4.7, and almost twice as many in absolute numbers, despite a much lower population. That said, Mexico is a beautiful and vibrant country that I have pretty strong personal ties to, and I'm not a huge fan of scaremongering either. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_by_murder_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_by_murder_rate
- pizza234 12y ago> These "be afraid of the outside world" articles are getting less and less subtle. Afraid of the outside world? Ahem, how many journalists have disappeared in USA in the last years? And by any chance, was any of them hanged disemboweled on a bridge, or beheaded on a street? There's a huge difference in crime between Mexico and USA, with the former having many arguably failed states; therefore disappearances have a very different context and characterization.
- hondje 12y agoNo, its not misleading. These dudes do NOT fuck around. I live in Pueblo, Colorado. To be exact, I live in the East Side in whats known as a barrio/ghetto/hood. If you google Fearnowville Colorado you'll see my home. I also have a LOT of experience in hospitality and F&B and have had regular personal contact with a wide variety of immigrants. My homie Santos is an illegal from Neuvo Leon. Marianna grew up in Sonora. When I was 18 I went to prison for drug charges and made real friendships with mexican and american criminals of all stripes. I learned about ejidos, jesus malverde, mis animales, and I am intelligent. Now don't get me wrong, I'm clean and totally legit. I got kids and I don't roll with gangsters. I am respected by my peers and I earned that respect. So that's where I'm coming from. Now I gotta say you don't know much more about being a criminal than I do about Haskell. People DO disappear, and it happens a LOT. Here and there both. Here in my small southwestern town of 100,000 I can think of multiple black baggings.... once in the parking lot of a walmart, even. I know there's stats about Mexico DF that look good, but you believe the Mexican feds? Personal anecdote: my wifes grandpa was a man named Jan Bonte. He was born in .dk, his dad was killed by nazis and he was placed in a camp. He immigrated after the war, first to .nl where he met and married his wife, and then to the US. They had a family in Colorado and after a late-life divorce he moved to Kino in the Sonoran desert for winters and came back to Colorado for summers. Because he routinely crossed the border he was ordered to mule something, and he declined. After a month of no contact we received news he died. We went to clean his remains from his house, which was gruesome after spending October in the sonoran heat after being chopped up by an axe. Day 1 a duece n half came up with a gaggle of Mexican troops. Green uniforms, M-16s, idk if they were cops or 'cops' or what, but they gave us 3 days to gtfo. Day 2, we picked up his ashes and had a small ceremony. He had local friends, who told us what happened and who did it. Day 3, we were on the road I put so many personal details because seriously: dox it if you'd like. You'll see Jan isn't counted among the victims of the drug war but it doesn't matter. The important thing is "this is how it is" and to hope it never happens to me or mine. Aqui hubo una mano negra I don't have a point at all, I just feel I see/know an entirely different world from the average HN poster. You see alarmists clutching pearls and spreading tales - part of a bigger trend to spread fear and exagerate dangers. I see people I know and love suffer....and hope that black hand doesn't visit me.