6 ms·
And this picture which is actually on huawei site as the part of the promo (!) illustrates the best why Jony Ive said (1) that "a circle doesn't make any sense"
by acqq 12y ago
And this picture which is actually on huawei site as the part of the promo (!) illustrates the best why Jony Ive said (1) that "a circle doesn't make any sense" for a smartwatch:
http://consumer.huawei.com/minisite/worldwide/huawei-watch/assets/images/medium/bg_06.jpg http://consumer.huawei.com/minisite/worldwide/huawei-watch/a...
----
1) http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/02/23/shape-things-come http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/02/23/shape-things-co...
- tylerpachal 12y agoThat's the first thing my eyes jumped to, I am a bit surprised that they didn't pick a nicer looking `view`, instead of one with awkwardly truncated text.
- agumonkey 12y agoBecause they didn't bother rethink/adapt the UI (yet).
- GuiA 12y agoStill doesn't make much sense. The vast majority of text humans read is displayed on rectangular surfaces.
- yellowapple 12y agoSo? The vast majority of automobiles humans drive are powered by the combustion of gasoline, but that in and of itself doesn't make a plug-in electric car impractical. I agree that some things need to be reworked in order to better suit a non-square display, but with the exception of the Facebook demonstration, I thought all the other pictured use-cases were rather brilliant and nice-looking.
- agumonkey 12y agoMajority isn't a good argument you know. Let them explore. Personally too thick and square watches repel me, and I don't intend to read Shakespeare from my wrist either. 2 'full length' rows at the center are probably enough text to read.
- mrestko 12y agoCan you not scroll?
- dozy 12y agoYes, you can scroll.
- brianobush 12y agoI think being limited to only square designs is short-sighted. We just don't need a laptop in a small form factor, but a new way of interaction. Hopefully, TTS and ASR with proper dialog management will remove the need to read small messages.
- revelation 12y agoIt's designed such that you can quickly decide with a glance "am I interested in this". A wall of text simply wouldn't be appropiate. If you are interested, after all, you swipe up and can read the text just fine.
- dozy 12y agoYou can scroll that card to see the rest of it. I fail to see how this is a problem.
- fpgeek 12y agoAnd, in fact, scrolling the card is exactly how it works for a square Android Wear watch too. The only difference is that (with the possible exception of ugly word-wrap cases), the truncation is only vertical, not horizontal as well. Considering how much has to be truncated on a watch screen anyway, I think it is hard to make the argument that the square interface works and the circular one doesn't.
- sp332 12y agoYou have to scroll the text up nearly halfway just to see the beginning of the lines. That means most of the space on the screen is wasted because I can't read lines that are not right in the middle of the screen.
- Fiahil 12y agoThe problem lies within the Android Wear UI, not the smartwatch itself. I hope they will "fix" that, now there is another round watch available after the moto360.
- cromwellian 12y agoIve also blasted the Moto X for offering so many customization choices and shipped a watch predicated on massive customization. Let's get one thing straight. Apple lambasts everyone else's designs until they adopt them. Recall that: 1) Mini-tablets are too small to be usable, you'd have to "file down your fingers to use them" 2) Large screen phones are a) things people don't want and b) don't fit your hand properly. Remember this Thumb commercial? http://9to5mac.com/2014/09/09/the-iphone-5-ad-that-apple-wants-you-to-forget/ http://9to5mac.com/2014/09/09/the-iphone-5-ad-that-apple-wan... 3) Customization and Widgets in the OS are bad, until iOS 8 gets them 4) Johnny Ive on Moto Maker ("“Their value proposition was, ‘Make it whatever you want. You can choose whatever color you want,'” Jony was quoted as saying in the interview. “I believe that’s abdicating your responsibility as a designer.”") Even BGR noticed this hypocrisy (http://bgr.com/2015/02/19/apple-watch-customization-jony-ive/ http://bgr.com/2015/02/19/apple-watch-customization-jony-ive...) There's many more incidents to this list, but it's typical Apple behavior to pooh-pooh things about competitor products or features right up until the point that they ship them. Then the entire world must pretend that prior to Apple, no one did it, or didn't do it right.
- nostrademons 12y agoTo be fair, basically every major corporation and most people do this. I can think of a half dozen Google examples just from my time there, and more than a few Facebook ones too.
- fpgeek 12y agoI think what's unusual about Apple here is: 1. How vehement their condemnation is (especially since, in retrospect, they're already busy working on exactly what they're condeming), 2. How quickly and comprehensively they flip the story when their version is ready and 3. How predictable this pattern is for them. Given past experience, I almost expect Apple to be working on actual toaster-fridges in a skunkworks project somewhere (in addition to the metaphorical ones I'm positive they're working on).
- mcphage 12y ago
- Istof 12y agoif in fact it is a problem, it is a software problem
- kenko 12y agoI'm going to guess that the last line, the one with the truncated text, says "Youtube, it's awesome" in full. Context is pretty powerful; this doesn't seem like a bad image at all: to me it demonstrates precisely that a circular face isn't a problem.
- angryasian 12y agoas a moto 360 owner its hardly a problem. I can tell right away if its something I want to read in a glance, in this context from the picture alone. I'll immediately dismiss it, otherwise I'll scroll up for more information. Even with gmail notifications, this is not a problem. I think this entire quote by Ive is similar to Jobs argument, that 3.5" is perfect size or 10" tablet is the perfect size.
- Florin_Andrei 12y agoMy thoughts exactly. Stuff at the bottom is quick, short notifications anyway. Want more details? You'd scroll up anyway. Works fine for me - in fact, I was pleasantly surprised how well the thing works. I used to think smart watches were a gimmick, now I'm a believer. The 360 rocks.
- ch0wn 12y agoAs an owner of the Samsung Gear Live (square) and Moto 360 (round) second this. The picture posted there is the preview of the actual message and it provides enough context to decide whether you want to swipe it up or not. Whether the message is truncated uniformly at the bottom or at some pieces to the sides doesn't make any difference in practice.
- Aissen 12y agoThis takes a page from Metro's (now Modern UI) truncating semantics: if it's truncated, it means there is a continuation and you can scroll it.