3 ms·
You seem to have a decent grasp of the author's point, since you just reiterated a huge chunk of it! The point, as the author repeatedly tried to explain in th
by jerf 17y ago
You seem to have a decent grasp of the author's point, since you just reiterated a huge chunk of it!
The point, as the author repeatedly tried to explain in the comments, is not that this is some sort of actually good idea for a probe. The point is to use it to examine the entire concept of "habitable" by creating a fairly objective standard. It's like how psychologists name and classify disorders just so they have an objective standard to discuss the matter with, long before they understand the disorder. Exploring the meaning of "habitable" explicitly without reference to Man's ability to change the environment is the point.
Yes, the standard is arbitrary. I'm surprised to see so many people freak out over that. Mathematicians do it all the time.