5 ms·
The State of Web Type
- joshuapants 12y agoInteresting, I would have figured that Apple would be tops in typography given their pedigree. Even weirder that (recent) IE does so well in this space.
- riffraff 12y agoI think microsoft has had a good relation with typography for a while, i.e. the C* fonts in office 2007/vista have been praised by many.
- cabirum 12y agoIE have always had good printing and typography support. Things text-align-last are supported since 5.5 and just recently made it into some modern browsers.
- mkozlows 12y agoSee also the recent "Safari is holding back the web" articles. IE is historically awful, but modern IE is generally better than modern Safari.
- arclight 12y agoDo you have a link to this series? I found some articles on the subject, but nothing that looked like what you were describing. Thanks!
- buro9 12y agoThe link is good http://stateofwebtype.com/ http://stateofwebtype.com/ But it doesn't detail the real-world differences in hyphenation support. We ultimately chose to disable features that were claimed to be supported as the support was there but inconsistent. A great start though, but it would be nice to also see the CSS and examples for each browser cited as supporting something.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- alricb 12y agoOne potential issue with Web fonts: security. The formats are notoriously complex, and FreeType has had a lot of vulnerabilities related to that.
- mkozlows 12y agoI'm more skeptical of the benefit of auto-hyphenation than the author is; it's been my experience that even with a proper hyphenation dictionary, you get some weird hyphenations that you want to manually undo (or force). Which means that if you're working with print, where you can do those corrections/fixes, hyphenation is great; let the algorithms work, do your little bit of fine-tuning, and it's good. But on the web, you can't do your fine-tuning, so it's auto or nothing -- and "nothing"/unjustified text typically has less annoying failure modes than auto-hyphenated/justified text does. And I think the author is flat wrong about preferring unstyled content flashes over delayed rendering of content that's waiting for a font. The unstyled flashes are massively distracting and disorienting to a reader; the delayed rendering just makes it seem like the page is a bit slow to finish loading.
- KwanEsq 12y ago> But on the web, you can't do your fine-tuning, so it's auto or nothing -- and "nothing"/unjustified text typically has less annoying failure modes than auto-hyphenated/justified text does. Can fine-tuning not be achieved with the soft-hyphen [0] and the word joiner [1] ? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Soft_hyphen&oldid=625641896 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Soft_hyphen&oldid... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Word_joiner&oldid=644348648 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Word_joiner&oldid...
- mkozlows 12y agoYou can't see the rendered-on-the-user's-screen result, is the thing, and dynamic layouts mean that it might appear differently in different places.
- dghf 12y ago> Browsers could implement the same line breaking algorithm as used in TeX, but have decided not to for performance reasons. This is an odd reason — TeX was developed and runs on computers much less powerful than those commonly used in mobile phones. Yes, but not at a speed that many would find acceptable for formatting a web page, even on a modern computer. Nor need it be: you only have to generate your (La)TeX document while creating or editing it; a couple of seconds for a short document is thus tolerable. Whereas a web page has to be formatted by every visitor on every visit -- maybe several times if they resize their browser. It needs to be more or less instant.
- jacobolus 12y agoThere’s clearly a trade-off here. Personally I would love to have a page that I’ll spend 30 minutes reading take 1 second longer to render in return for dramatically better paragraph composition.
- dghf 12y agoFair point. It sounds like the ideal would be a browser setting: fast-and-dirty justification for the impatient vs TeX-style line-breaking for aesthetes.