"a more tedious, sermonizing, simplistic and unconvincing ... poorly disguised" You don't see any insults? Well I guess you wouldn't: you're the one who consi

"a more tedious, sermonizing, simplistic and unconvincing ... poorly disguised" You don't see any insults? Well I guess you wouldn't: you're the one who considered it appropriate to demean my comment as "a fit". In any case, your argument about "honest reactions" being good defends my comment just as much as his. Yet you don't seem to be considering our comments equally valid. And I don't either, since it's just not true that all honest reactions make good comments.