4 ms·
> A computer allows you to amplify the power of your brain considerably by trading understanding for extreme speed of execution. This allows a person that is no
by danso 12y ago
> A computer allows you to amplify the power of your brain considerably by trading understanding for extreme speed of execution. This allows a person that is not well versed in math for instance to arrive at the correct answers for math problems either by trying a bunch of solutions in a row (called ‘brute forcing’) or by using the computer to figure out a rough approximation to the answer which then leads to the crucial insight required to get an exact answer.
Yes exactly. Which is why I consistently disagree with people who don't think that programming is a new kind of literacy...either they have an incredible faith that computers will continue to be better beholden to their computationally-ignorant users, or they just don't understand that programming (or "coding") does not mean, "Teach everyone how to deploy a Rails bootstrap app on Heroku".
Is traditional literacy -- reading and writing -- any more than an amplifier? It's possible to be able to communicate without reading or writing, but the ability to transcribe your thoughts in a durable format (even in this age of unlimited digital video) and to interpret the transcribings of others...that ability greatly amplifies your ability to communicate and interact with society.
Computers obviously are another such amplifier...so why shouldn't programming be seen as a worthwhile kind of literacy?
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 12y agoMaybe because not all programming amplifies your brain. Some programming is about being busy and making money[0] often at the expense of brain health. Sure the machine can run things quickly, but you can also spend far too much time telling it what to do. It's actually so bad that people are making a profession out of this. [0] http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000339.html http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000339.html
- brudgers 12y agoIf by "programming", we mean some concept that includes running an Excel spreadsheet, then I at least somewhat agree it's similar to literacy. Otherwise, it's a bit in the realm of "Only millwrights can 'really' use wheels," where 'really' is our True Scotsman. Programming without engineering best practices is still programming. With time, applications for technical innovations migrate downward to ordinary cases and the standard for judging technical expertise becomes higher over time.
- Double_Cast 12y agoI'm skeptical. Reading & writing is a skill necessary enough in modern society that illiteracy is practically crippling. I imagine an illiterate would have to ask someone else to read to them every half-hour at best. E.g. "I'm trying to google 'how to tie a necktie', how do I spell 'necktie'?" My intuition says basic programming-literacy by contrast is (while a powerful skill) unnecessary for the average Joe's quotidian life. He might frequently need GUI's, but he won't need to understand the guts. Can you come up a situation that programming could accomplish in a way that a well-designed GUI couldn't? If anything should become the new literacy, I'd expect it to be discrete math based on its generality and source of analogies.
- groby_b 12y agoYou presuppose there'll always be a GUI. That's similar to the assumption that I don't need reading skills since there'll always be an audio version. True for many cases, but the more you approach one-off, the more you'll find there is no audio version. Or no GUI. The question is, are there examples where the cost of acquiring and applying the skill is worth the savings? In individual instances, doubtful. Done habitually, probably - the case for reading is fairly well established. The case for computational literacy might be hampered by the very spotty availability of data. Once you can obtain data sets, it definitely becomes worth it. Silly overprivileged example: When I was looking for a place to live, I was evaluating the location to choose based on a heat map generated from 20+ different metrics. As a result, I found a place that * Was well below what you usually pay * Was pretty unique for the area I'm in * Makes me happy every day * Only cost me a 15 minute increase in commute time. (This is L.A., so consider that an achievement of epic proportions ;) Was that one instance worth spending time learning how to work with computers? No. But it's one single neat payoff. And if the data hadn't required custom scrapers, it would've required only minutes of my time.
- Double_Cast 12y agoCorrection: I presuppose there'll always be a GUI for the cases where the average Joe has a show-stopping problem frequent enough to warrant someone else to build a GUI solution. Literacy is needed because (a) people need it on a daily-basis at least and (b) it's a meta-skill since it's impractical for people to learn other subjects without it. Contrast literacy with programming. I don't expect that programming will be as frequent or spontaneous except in a future where either (a) brain emulations exist or (b) citizens interface with reality exclusively through emacs. Nor do I consider programming a meta-skill in the sense that refusing to learn it will impede you from accessing every other area of human knowledge. (But I'm glad you're enjoying L.A.)