7 ms·
Computing is too easy
- scotty79 12y ago> Our laptops are sleek and polished. Our operating systems are fluid and intuitive. This is clearly a joke. And a cruel one. Laptops are just two steps away from overheating and falling apart no matter how much glue they put in these days. And operating systems are laggy and messy. They have still 50% of laggines and 90% of messiness of what was the standard two decades ago.
- prottmann 12y ago"fluid and intuitive" I must laugh at this too. I need a search tool to find my installed programs and settings. Most of the time i need google to find out, if a changeable setting exists ;) Operating systems are stupid since many years, on every new Version i think "god, please change not too much", cause on every new Version things not getting better and not easier and not smoother. Yes, they look nicer, they have more "blink" and more animations, but all of this not help me to work better or faster.
- jimmaswell 12y ago>I need a search tool to find my installed programs and settings. as if simply typing the name of or keywords for what you want to find into a search bar isn't fluid and inuitive?
- Gracana 12y agoAssuming that you know the name of your volume manager is "gigolo" and that your remote desktop client is "remmina," etc. If you're lucky the program might have a reasonable name, but still your OS decides the most likely thing you're looking for is ancient manuscripts... http://i.imgur.com/0ePB9sT.png http://i.imgur.com/0ePB9sT.png
- sthreet 12y agoFor some reason, when I search "mount and blade"; dracula.txt and equator.txt show up. For some reason processing comes with several books from project gutenberg by default, and they show up when I look up some programs.
- digi_owl 12y agoWell there is always the Gnome way, where the menu entry has one name (Archive Manager) but the command has a very different one (file-roller).
- jsight 12y agoIf I type "add printer" into the search on Fedora (Gnome Shell), the first item in the list is "Printers" with helpful text letting me know that this is the tool for adding printers. It's much easier than it used to be, IMO.
- jimmaswell 12y agoYou still found "Printers" which is probably it.
- prottmann 12y agoAnd if you not know the exactly name? Example i type "browser" -> nothing found. And i am absolutely sure i have installed chrome, seamonkey and ie. ;)
- jimmaswell 12y agoThat's why the applications are supposed to have relevant tags that are looked at by the search.
- Supraperplex 12y agoAnimations help a lot of people to better understand what is going on in the machine.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoYou are viewing the world through rose-tinted glasses if you think OSes were better twenty years ago.
- PakG1 12y agoOSes were better twenty years ago because they were more predictable and stable because they couldn't do as much, especially if there was no multithreading. Limitations ensured stability and reliable performance. Today, it's too easy to overload your system. Except now I just realized that 20 years ago was Windows 95. Dang, I'm getting old. :(
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoThey were neither more predictable nor more stable. Twenty years ago, if an application crashed, so did the entire OS. Twenty years ago, applications and the OS were very tightly coupled and they would both deliberately and unintentionally trample on eachother, often with disastrous consequences.
- digi_owl 12y agoMaybe not stable, but perhaps predictable (at least outside of the MS sphere) because there was not as many interconnected processes bouncing around in the background.
- jsight 12y agoAs an OS/2 user twenty years ago, I disagree. Really, it was about twenty years ago that I switched to Linux which didn't crash due to a simple application crash either. Stop making me feel old. :)
- tormeh 12y agoWindows 95 sucked so bad. Not missing multiple bluescreens a day.
- chrisfarms 12y agoCassette loading was probably what piqued my curiosity. I distinctly remember being baffled by how playing special "music" could turn into something on the screen and spent along time forcing a poor spectrum to listen to my "Rave 92" tape.
- shiggerino 12y agoComputing isn't too easy, it's too hard, and modern systems aren't contributing a solution, they are just glossing it over with their crippled tools. Not just crippled tools for office workers, also crippled tools for programmers and artists. Some things might not be possible to fix. Teaching people to RTFM, for instance. No search engine will be able to replace consistent and comprehensive documentation written by the people who know the system intimately, but it's hard to convince most users, many developers, even, that this is actually worth the effort it takes, both to read and write. Being able to model data and reason about complexity, even for non-programmers, is a something else you can't really get around. Ever had people in your organization with outlandish ideas that just don't compute, right up there with "why don't you just write a program that writes programs". I've had to explain that yes, I can write a program that does what you want, but it's not going to finish before the heat death of the universe. During all of this arguing a whole bunch of computers are sitting idle when they could be doing useful work if only their operators knew how to tell them to. I too cut my teeth on HyperCard, and the best thing about it really focused on doing things people really needed. Organizing and reasoning about people's data, whether it was appointments, contacts, orders, stock, notes, things that are hard to do on paper, but easy for a machine to handle. It went straight to the core of the issue. How to best tell the computer to do useful work. Of course it failed in many respects, but the real tragedy is that they seemed to stop trying after that.
- Swizec 12y ago> Some things might not be possible to fix. Teaching people to RTFM, for instance. No search engine will be able to replace consistent and comprehensive documentation written by the people who know the system intimately, but it's hard to convince most users, many developers, even, that this is actually worth the effort it takes, both to read and write. People will RTFM if it isn't boring, dry, and useless. There's a fine balance to be struck between nice-to-read prose and giving people exactly what they need, quickly enough for them to actually read your stuff. But the thing is, if your documentation is difficult to read and doesn't flow well, it might as well not have been written. Everybody will give up before they learn. And vice-versa, if your documentation is TOO nice to read and does too much hand-holding. People will gloss it over and miss important details. Teaching is hard. Much harder than people give it credit. And because there are no unicorns who can both intimiately understand the system and be good at documenting it, you should do the next best thing - have a person with enough technical background to be able to talk to the experts, but is also good at writing about it write your docs. This seems to be the approach taken by most self-published tech writers these days. They're good enough to understand the system, but also decent enough at writing about it.
- pjc50 12y agoThere's one of these articles every few weeks. I'd argue that the response has been the "maker" movement, built around Arduino and Raspberry Pi. People also need to distinguish between "you have to tinker in order to use the thing" and "you can tinker if you need to". Old cars were more tinkerable and less reliable.
- ontouchstart 12y agoWhen I got my RPi 2, the first thing I did was to make it to boot headlessly in debian and skip all the X window crap. It is a joy to play with it via ssh on a sleek Macbook Air from anywhere in my house. Now I can study how redis works by compiling it in a docker container. Wish I had it in 1980s.
- EliRivers 12y agoOld cars were more tinkerable and less reliable. Reliability is a curve; a function of how much maintenance is spent on it. No question at all that a modern car with zero maintenance will be more reliable than an old car was with zero maintenance. But with a surprisingly small amount of maintenance, an old can can be more reliable than a modern car with the same amount of maintenance. Sure, it'll take a while before one of them fails, but I can (and do) keep a thirty year old car running with maintenance that probably averages to about ten minutes a week. I suspect very strongly that if I spent ten minutes a week maintaining a modern car (which, from what I can tell, would be me looking at the lights on the dashboard to see if the car is asking for more water or oil), it would fail before the old car did.
- pjc50 12y agoFor certain cars, yes; there are plenty around that have been round their odometers a few times. But we've forgotten the higher proportion of cars that were lemons straight from the factory or suffered early rust or electrical failures (this may be a more British thing).
- dagw 12y agoI think you are looking at a strong case of survivorship bias. The sample of 30 year old cars that still work represent some of the best made and most reliable cars made 30 years ago. Most of the unreliable and badly made cars from 30 years ago have died and been turned to scrap.
- 300bps 12y agoI agree with the article. The differences between 10 year old me on my Commodore 64 and my currently 10 year old son on his Windows 7 computer are astronomical. When I turned my 64 on it was "READY" for me to make it do something. I spent days typing in BASIC and 6502 Assembly source code into it just to play a game. My son has a seemingly infinite supply of videos on YouTube to entertain him. Near infinite supply of free-to-play ready made games (with in-app purchases). There is no natural incentive for him to learn how to produce anything on computers.
- baldfat 12y agoI also agree. Today we need people who can miss the forest for the trees! I can't believe the lack of basic computer skills that people have coming into the workforce and someone that can use Word is considered a computer person. Even the new IT people only know GUI and Microsoft with no experience with Mac OS or Linux, and no idea about anything but the silo they are working in. I was one of those kids who had to program games at 7 on a Sol20 in 1977 and than de-bug since every basic was different. When I found out if I could learn Assembly I could play more game I learned that. The day I got the 300 baud modem was life changing and I had to pay for a second line due to everyone else in the house being mad they couldn't use the phone.
- sthreet 12y agoTime to complain about my school. Our "computer" classes consisted of learning to: type, format word, type in a spreadsheet, format powerpoint (in a way that I think powerpoint is unnecessary for), one week total of messing around in garage band, one week of typing out the exact lines of html, copying instructions for dreamweaver. EDIT: And then we do 'job' stuff in that class. Including making resumes that include our ability to use basic microsoft/adobe programs. I could have learned to do that without a manual or internet before the class. I can learn way more with internet just messing around in photoshop/gimp every once in a while.
- baldfat 12y agoIt is time to put the science back into Computer Science and have it in Middle School and High School. My school district computer classes are business classes and the teachers need business degrees.
- jgreen10 12y agoIt's not. Everything is disconnected from everything, everything requires me to learn a new GUI, my devices are actively preventing me from doing things I want, using data gives me a headache, my tools don't tell me what they can do, making apps is complex, I need to use a 1970s interface to do anything remotely, my Chrome tabs crash all the time, my Android apps crash all the time, iOS is too slow to know whether it's crashed. Computing has become a little superficial in the way we use it, superficial is easy, but anything else is way too hard.
- maffyoo 12y agoEvolution, progress, the march of the human race has fundamentally been enabled by our ability to efficiently abstract and encapsulate complexity into building blocks that form the next leap forwards in the advancement of science, knowledge etc. Complexity should only be by necessity not forced on everyone. its just progress
- cubano 12y agoYes. And so is buying cheap unhealthy food. Talking long distance. Hooking up. Being entertained (or at least, finding entertainment). etc etc... My point being, humanities entire push to modernity is nothing but step after step of making things "too easy." We are supposed to stop now?
- GeneralMayhem 12y agoI'm conflicted. On the one hand, as a developer, it frustrates the hell out of me when people don't have the slightest idea how computers work on the level of the "just write a program that writes programs" point from the article. On the other hand, I don't know how a car works in any sort of detail, and I'm sure mechanics feel the same about me. I (like to) think the difference is that I have some idea how to reason about cars, because I am at least familiar with the basic laws of physics and get the idea of internal combustion. The "it should just work" crowd aren't just incompetent as creators, they're incompetent as users, because there's no basis for reasoning.
- shiggerino 12y agoIndeed, the car/mechanic analogy is quite flawed. The driver is the user of the car, the mechanic isn't. Whereas the developer is also a user of the computer in the most fundamental ways. People who don't know how to use computers are merely along for the ride. Someone without a driver's license might have a tremendous benefit from a car. A lot of the time they even have a say in deciding where to go (especially if they pay), but ultimately it's the person behind the wheel that's calling the shots. And for people who spend their whole working life riding around in cars (as so many do with computers) it's well worth the trouble and effort to get a driver's license and get that extra bit of autonomy. The same should be true of computing.
- digi_owl 12y agoAnother thing is that even with more and more electronics coming into play, a car is still a mechanical system. As such, if a driver (user) complains about a new rattle or sound, the mechanical links can be traced back to the source. And that touches on another thing. Computers are deeply visual. Yes, it can output sound and such. But most of the interaction is done by text and images. This means that when it is just sitting there with the screen off, you don't know if it is idle or transferring your porn collection of the NSA headquarters. From time to time i wonder what would come out of putting a sniffer on the network and have it play some tones based on the packets picked up and their metadata. All too often i find myself likening computers to small children. When they are noisy you can relax, but when they become quiet you really need to worry. This in particular when exposed to Windows, and its habit of announcing new USB devices with plings and popups.
- 6d0debc071 12y agoComputing doesn't lead well, in its current form, to the development of coevolutionary mastery. That's the thing, I suspect. For example: Your text editor, with the exception of emacs et al, probably isn't particularly programmable in a form that the average user is likely to discover. There's probably not a way to right click on a button and see what function it's calling, or to right click on a transformed bit of text and see what's been done to it. The program itself isn't built for that. And the economic interest in not building it for that is obvious - if you let users have access to the full power of the machine, even worse to share their modifications, what do they need you for any more? How are you going to convince people to buy version 15 when they've got version 14 set up the way they want it? Your options have become increasingly strongly contrasted: Become a programmer or live in user-land. As if a programmer isn't just a more knowledgeable class of user and as if that's not a spectrum. It's nothing special about typing white text into a black screen. Even if we still lived in command line land, I don't think that we'd be better off. I don't feel like it has anything to do with how hard the computer is to use - at least not at a surface level. It seems to me more to do with how programmable your programs are and how easily you can start doing useful things with that power.
- emilng 12y agoI started out programming with a Commodore 64 and having instant access to BASIC when I turned on the machine was really awesome. As a professional developer now, I appreciate the low level knowledge that learning on the C64 provided, but the more important thing was low barrier of entry to development tools. There is a currently a very low barrier of entry access point for programming on everyone's computers currently in the form of the web browser. You can view the source for any web page and change things around in the dev tools and console. Too many people yearn for the good old days of low level access yet are quick to dismiss Javascript as "toy" language. In the old days BASIC was just a toy too. The "real" programmers wrote their code in assembly.