2 ms·
Do you really think that what is being advocated here is employing people who don't know how to program at all for programming jobs? I don't get that sense at a
by kbenson 12y ago
Do you really think that what is being advocated here is employing people who don't know how to program at all for programming jobs? I don't get that sense at all.
I think we are far beyond the original scope of the article. When the discussion is about hiring people based on their potential because of how they would have been able to develop if privilege was normalized, then yes, I think that and equivalents is what it boils down to, because I don't think privilege does all that much after a person has identified their career and interests. I think it primarily affects the finding of that career and interest, through exposure and training.
At the point where someone suggests hiring people with fine arts degrees to write physics simulation code, because diversity, I agree the plot has been completely lost.
A bit more extreme than what I meant to imply. I guess it really comes down to what hiring based on potential really means.
And, because I haven't said this for a while, I'm kindof trying to play the economic argument here, because that is your focus. I'm not conceding my feeling that economic arguments can't be trumped by moral ones.
I've been trying to field the idea that the economic argument is the moral one. Or at least it may be, and I think it can't be immediately discounted as not being the moral one.
Good conversation, overall, thanks.
To you as well. I found it really productive, it gave me a lot to think about.