3 ms·
It's funny that both you and the other commenter assume I'm taking an editorial position on this. I was taken aback by the asymmetry of effort and cost. They hi
by javajosh 12y ago
It's funny that both you and the other commenter assume I'm taking an editorial position on this. I was taken aback by the asymmetry of effort and cost. They hired a "small team of lawyers" to deal with a letter. It wasn't a lawsuit. It was a piece of paper with words on it!
Sort of similar to when you launch a big AWS cluster and when you hit "enter" you know you just spent a lot of money.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThe piece of paper with words on it was created by a bunch of highly paid lawyers to get their attention. If it was a typical demand letter, it probably demand not only that they cease and desist from use of the infringing mark, but that they turn over any and all material employing the infringing mark for destruction, as well as a complete accounting of their financial interest in said mark. I imagine Triggertrap's legal bill was about 10% for the time to explain 'they're right, you're wrong, give it up already' and 90% for the drafting of a reply letter and compliance sufficient to get the injured party to call the matter closed. Now, that's a lot to ask for in a letter - usually a Trademark C&D goes along the lines of 'stop or I'll sue' - but in the context of a money-raising campaign, and given the fact that Red Camera company had historically and famously employed the pre-order launch strategy themselves, I think it would have been appropriate to come down on Triggertrap like a ton of bricks. Don't forget that trademark law works on a 'defend it or lose it' basis - if you don't vigorously contest infringement of the mark, then some later infringer can raise a defense of constructive abandonment. Not a lawyer, but I've long been interested in this subfield of law. Monitoring and defending the mark against potential infringers isn't cost-free either.
- javajosh 12y ago>The piece of paper with words on it was created by a bunch of highly paid lawyers to get their attention. You do know the difference between speculation and knowledge, right? I'm not saying that you're wrong, but I want to point out how much you're reading into this situation. Consider the possibilities: what if that letter was a fake, crafted by an early stage competitor just to waste their valuable time and money? An effective hack, because it's probably not even illegal.
- anigbrowl 12y agoTriggertrap's legal team would begin by verifying the provenance of any demand letter. Any letter like that is going to start by introducing itself as being either from a firm's general counsel or (more often) a law firm acting as outside counsel, and it's not hard to verify the sender's legal credentials and client relationship. A fake letter would be easy enough to identify and might even attract criminal penalties. In some states, legitimate but overzealous demand letters can be grounds for civil fraud action by the recipient, eg http://www.stormoenlaw.com/extortion-risks-from-overzealous-demand-letters.html http://www.stormoenlaw.com/extortion-risks-from-overzealous-... Of course I'm speculating about the contents, but I am familiar with the legal issues, know lawyers who practice in this area, and the camera market, as well as people at Red Camera. I think you overestimate the ease of the 'hack' you're imagining.