4 ms·
The only reason to buy local is for a lower price, otherwise what's the point? Everything is local to somewhere. Very nice article though!
by ars 12y ago
The only reason to buy local is for a lower price, otherwise what's the point? Everything is local to somewhere.
Very nice article though!
- del82 12y agoI've found that produce picked yesterday at the farm up the street tends to last longer than produce that's been trucked from the other side of the US, not to mention the difference in the amount of energy it took to get it to me.
- evgen 12y agoThe produce up the street may have taken less energy, but the produce grown on a small farm 50 miles from you probably required more energy to reach your door than green grapes from the local supermarket shipped in from Chile. Do not discount the efficiency of the modern transportation network.
- Sivart13 12y agoBecause maybe you want your money to pay for the food and not the global transportation networks that brought you the food? Do you really believe the only reason to buy one thing over another is the price?
- lkbm 12y ago> Because maybe you want your money to pay for the food and not the global transportation networks that brought you the food? Sure, okay, but...why? Better for the environment? Doesn't seem to be the case. Tighter-nit community? Idealogical opposition to roads? Protectionism? Serious question. Why?
- ars 12y agoLocal produce usually costs more in transport, not less. Which is why it's more expensive: To pay for that. If I find local that's actually cheaper then I know it traveled less.
- analog31 12y agoAs I understand it, produce varieties have been bred to survive longer distance shipping, making them tougher and possibly less flavorful. Of course YMMV on that score, since it's surely a matter of taste. I grew up in southeast Michigan, where there was a fairly robust market for local produce in the summer. Things that you could get such as local tomatoes were a cut above anything that I've been able to find in my present locale. Unfortunately, I now live in a state that doesn't have as much of a produce crop, and it's harder to find farm stands that haven't discovered the "upscale farmers market" phenomenon, where prices are often 2x what you can pay for similar quality in the supermarket. My present practice is to buy whatever is nice, local or otherwise, which depends on the season.
- ars 12y ago> produce varieties have been bred to survive longer distance shipping No, shipping takes very little time. They are bred to survive long storage. If anything that makes local worse - you have to store the produce to be able to have it for more than a few weeks in a year. Better to ship it from each area as it grows in season, then you don't have to store it.
- nraynaud 12y agoI think this whole "local" stuff smells a bit like bullshit, and a lot like old time bigoted xenophobia. Farmers from my country are better and more deserving than farmers in other countries (while at the same time pushing US-made GMO seeds on other countries by any means). We see the same reasoning in manufacturing, with an objective collusion between the left ("cool, it's made by tattooed hipsters in tight pants") and the right ("cool, it's made by god protected Americans, who are, frankly, the pick-up driving, gun-toting angels of this world") against "overseas" and for "re-shoring".
- lkbm 12y agoI think food's different. The idea is that transporting food is a waste of energy and thus that local food will be more environmentally friendly. Doesn't seem to hold up, generally, but naïvely, it's a reasonable heuristic. It's usually not a nationalistic thing, but a distance thing. With manufacturing, however, it is usually nationalistic. There's also a strong protectionalism behind "made in America" movements. To me, those seem to essentially be equivalent to snitching in the prisoner's dilemma: we're better of iff we favor our own products and foreigners don't favor their own. But nationalism aside, it could definitely be that due to the idea that American-made (or first-world-made) products are better, the target audience is people who value quality over price, and thus quality will be chosen for in manufacturing and the business can still thriv. If you manufacture in newly-industrialized nations, you're doing it to cut price as much as possible, often sacrificing skill/experience=quality. I should also add a third consideration: a lot of chocolate is produced by slave labor. A lot of t-shirts are made in abusive conditions. A lot of toys are made in emission-unrestricted factories. Choosing an industrialized country means choosing relatively stringent and enforced workers' rights and environmental protections. This may even hold true with food, despite the way we treat migrant farm workers in the US. Avocados producers in Mexico are often under the thumb of by drug cartels. Those produced in California--probably not so much. I've always assumed it's more beneficial to buy the cheapest and donate the money you saved to an effective charity. But how many people calculate and apportion out their savings that way? Sounds nice, but if it's not feasible to get people to do it, the rational decision is to advocate for an achievable alternative. Maybe local is that, at least with some goods.
- 12y ago
- jeffdavis 12y ago(1) variety across regions; (2) variety across seasons; (3) harder to scale up, and therefore less likely to be refined/processed/unnatural; (4) forces people to be creative about food, which adds to the culture. Of course, those might not be true, but they are plausible enough to be attractive reasons. One might argue that, technically, importing strictly increases options, and therefore makes it easier for an individual to eat a wide variety. But it also makes it easier for someone to get a little too comfortable eating exactly the same things for too long without thinking.
- primroot 12y agoIn practice importing diminishes options, both for the locations that find their market flooded with the standard supermarket-optimized foods, and the for the poor countries that are compelled to make their land produce the "best" for the sake of profits. In the last century 75% of crop diversity was lost, and in the decades after the Green Revolution poor countries became net importers of food. Simplistic logic that looks at effects completely abstracted from the system, would make such outcome look impossible.