3 ms·
Microsoft had a monopoly on desktop operating system sales. The question at issue wasn't whether bundling unrelated products is bad in principle, but whether i
by idlewords 17y ago
Microsoft had a monopoly on desktop operating system sales. The question at issue wasn't whether bundling unrelated products is bad in principle, but whether it amounted to an anticompetitive practice because of Micorsoft's complete control of the market.
Our memories are fine, you just picked a poor analogy.
- gaius 17y agoI'd be really curious if anyone has figures on percentage of desktops that were Windows then vs percentage of searches that are Google now.
- zaphar 17y agobeing a mononpoly is not illegal or even necessarily bad. It's what you do with that monopoly status that is important. Until someone shows that Google is abusing it's power they will be fine. Up to know everything Google has done falls under the category of improving customer experience and generally making the internet and world a better place. Google was on the wrong end of the stick with regards to a duopoly in map data so they fixed the problem. In fixing the problem they made a duopoly a "triopoly" (is that even a word?). This in my mind is an improvement.
- InclinedPlane 17y agoMonopolies are like monarchies. There may be a good one now and then but the system itself is faulty and prone to badness. A good monopoly will generally turn into a bad monopoly over time, because there are no competitive forces keeping it honest. Though there are rare exceptions. A competitive market tends to be long-term stable, resulting in better sustained, long-term results for customers. Google is very dominant but nothing it does could really be considered a monopoly, even search. Very few google products have significant "lock-in" the way most monopolistic products do.
- fnid 17y agoYou only feel this way because you like Google. MS including a browser so people didn't have to FTP one or get one from friends made the world better too. It's probably that decision that helped the web grow to what it is today. I remember what it was like trying to get on the internet before IE was included. It was a pain. Also, consumerism's arguably bad for the world, due to over consumption, etc, so advertising isn't really good for the world, thus google is bad for the world.
- michaelfairley 17y agoDidn't the anti-trust case have more to do with the fact that it was impossible to uninstall IE, and that various actions would cause IE to be reset as the default browser?
- zaphar 17y agoI wasn't commenting on MS and it's policies. However I believe the issue with MS was less the browser bundling and more the difficulty in removing it. And strong arm tactics keeping alternate browsers from being installed by manufacturers. My point still stands. Google is not making it difficult to use a different gps system or using strong arm tactics. This sets them apart from MS.
- jeremyw 17y agoActually, during that period, I was often vexed that very few separated the good idea (bundling a web browser free) from the bad (anticompetitive OEM deals) -- at least in the national papers. It all got lumped into Microhate.
- bad_user 17y agosorry, i downvoted you by mistake :)