3 ms·
It seems like the take home lesson to all hackers and hobbyists out there: Hardware is HARD. Fullstop. $500,000 is nothing for even something as 'small' as thi
by Balgair 12y ago
It seems like the take home lesson to all hackers and hobbyists out there:
Hardware is HARD. Fullstop. $500,000 is nothing for even something as 'small' as this.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI don't think that is the correct lesson. The lesson is that if you are building a product and you don't already have all the expertise in house to finish the design, then you cannot predict what it should cost. Building hardware is actually "easier" in some senses than building software because it is so testable. More importantly building to the 'proof of concept' stage, or prototyping, is essential in a hardware design. I expect that building their device for $500K was eminently doable, with an in house hardware engineer, embedded software engineer, and a mechanical/manufacturing engineer or someone who is really talented and can do all three acceptably well. You don't get their fancy injection molded case, you get something much more boxish, and your controls are simpler. Perhaps the better lesson is don't assume anything you cannot do yourself but can describe is either easy to do or simple to do.
- ghaff 12y agoThe thing with hardware is that there's a lot more "works" or "doesn't work" to it. That's a gross oversimplification of course but software has a lot more latitude to be in the sorta works but is also pretty buggy and doesn't really do everything promised camp. I agree that there seems to have been a gap in even knowing what they didn't know. But an informative and honest post.
- Balgair 12y agoI thought the summary at the end was true though, but I still think that the takeaway for hobbyists and hackers is that getting a hardware device to market is HARD (caps intended). Cloning software is trivial, while getting things from China or wherever is not. If you are a hacker with all 3 skills you mentioned, then you probably can say that it is merely 'tough', but then again, you probably already have a great job with stock options, as you are rare in these fields.
- pkaye 12y agoIn this case the issue is not that it is HARD but that they don't have people with the right experience in their team. Also in pure software projects, you can cover for your mistakes with personal sacrifices and working crazy hours but with hardware, some mistakes really cost money.
- sliverstorm 12y agoThe idea behind the "hardware is hard" message isn't that hardware is impossible, but to get software engineers starting hardware projects to stop trivializing it. Engineers have a tendency to dismiss all disciplines outside their own as easy, the sort of thing you can pick up in a week if you need.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoIndeed. Two of my friends managed to build a custom robotics platform that bridges Lego Mindstorms and traditional electronics for way, way less money. They managed to do that because both are EEs who were fully competent to design and manufacture the prototypes of the product. They're on Kickstarter now (https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1992634922/robocore-the-heart-of-your-personal-robot https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1992634922/robocore-the...), with a finished product (seen it myself, it works as advertised) and they're aiming for 1/10th of the amount. The lesson should indeed be, don't go to Kickstarter unless you are dead sure you have all the expertise you need to finish the project in-house.