4 ms·
The Puzzling Galaxy at the Edge of Time and Space
- jgh 12y agoI'm a little confused - the article says it's 2.2 billion light years away yet the expectation is that it would be a very immature galaxy. Wouldn't it have had ~11.6 billion years to become a more mature galaxy before the light we're looking at left? The Earth is older than the light from that galaxy. So why the surprise at its apparent maturity? Edit: to answer my own question the galaxy cluster that's doing the magnifying is 2.2 billion light years away. It took some googling to figure that one out!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- civilian 12y ago> This galaxy is so distant that it would have been invisible without the gravitational lensing effects of a large galaxy cluster called Abell 1689, located nearly 2.2 billion light years away in the constellation Virgo. Straight from the article. :)
- jgh 12y agoYes, I see now that I was only half paying attention to the article and skipped a bunch of words ;)
- trey-jones 12y agoIs it not a possibility that this galaxy was already much further from the "center" of the universe 12 billion years ago? I am not an astronomer by any stretch.
- rollo 12y agoThere is no such thing as a center.
- littletimmy 12y agoThis point always confused me. Isn't the "center" just the point where the big bang took place and started the expansion of the universe?
- everyone 12y agoIf you inflate a balloon, the surface area of the balloon increases and some dots drawn on the surface would get further apart but you couldnt say that the enlargement has a 'centre' The entire surface is simply expanding everywhere at once. The universe is like that with an extra dimension.
- castis 12y agobut if you played the expansion backwards, would it not arrive at a location somewhere vaguely equidistant from the farthest edges of said expansion?
- bbcbasic 12y agoStill confused! With a balloon surface if you travel in one direction long enough you will end up back where you started. Does this analogy apply to the universe. If there is no centre then either the universe is infinite, or it wraps around on itself like a balloon?
- everyone 12y agoI believe whether the universe wraps around, or is infinite is still a matter of some debate. I know some researchers are currently trying to determine the size and shape of the universe by trying to see all the way to the other side and back to our side, for example. In some cases with things in physics and cosmology, lets say dealing with 4 or 11 spatial dimensions you've just got to accept that our minds are not designed to be able to visualize some concepts, though we can understand and make progress by understanding the math. Heres a random article introducing some ideas about the geometry and topology of the universe. http://io9.com/5811706/if-you-keep-going-around-the-universe-will-you-end-up-where-you-started http://io9.com/5811706/if-you-keep-going-around-the-universe...
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoMaybe we're seeing all the way around, and back to here again!
- ChuckMcM 12y agoWhile unlikely, I particularly like that idea.
- mactitan 12y agoOr maybe A1689- evolved into it's magnifier Abell.
- jckt 12y agoIf you're referring to what Einstein referred to as the "finite, unbounded" universe, i.e. a spherical topology of the universe, measurements from the last decade and a half have shown that to be most probably (if not completely) wrong[1], and that our universe is in fact "flat". [1] http://map.gsfc.nasa.gov/universe/uni_shape.html http://map.gsfc.nasa.gov/universe/uni_shape.html
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoWhere's the romance in that?
- Apofis 12y agoI always had a wacky idea that the universe is a loop, in many different respects. Imagine atoms are actually galaxies or even universes. You keep zooming in or out you end up seeing yourself again. Could be the same with time. Which is why there isn't a beginning or an end.
- madaxe_again 12y agoPerhaps the most straightforward, albeit seismic, explanation for this and the recent supermassive black hole is that we've misunderstood either the age of the universe, or the nature of time. The black hole is one thing, but a old yet seemingly ancient metal rich galaxy is another - you only get heavy metals from fusion and time.
- everyone 12y agoWell, super-massive stars can have extremely short lifespans (of only a few million years). Also the heavier elements (gold for instance) only get created (and distributed) during giant supernovae events which are the end result of these giant stars lives.
- ccvannorman 12y ago>we've misunderstood either the age of the universe, or the nature of time. Or both. += [Gravity, energy, conscious observation of the cosmos]. :-]
- nitrogen 12y ago"Energy" as a concept has to be qualified with the type of energy, otherwise it sounds like the kind of nebulous quackery that typically accompanies "conscious observation of the cosmos" woo.
- eloff 12y agoEspecially taken with the recent news of the monster blackhole, also seemingly too developed for it's age, makes me think we might discover that we're wrong about something fundamental like that. It would be an incredibly exciting discovery.
- antognini 12y agoThat explanation is extremely unlikely. Our constraints on the age of the universe are now extremely tight and come from several independent measurements. What these results are more likely telling us is what the very first generation of stars were like. There's currently a great deal of uncertainty about how they form and what they're like. One of the reasons we know so little about them is because no one has actually seen a first generation star. Such a star would be characterized by having no metals at all. Some stars with extremely low amounts of metals have been discovered (something like one millionth the amount of metals in the Sun), but all have a detectable amount of metals in their atmosphere. This means that: (1) there were very few first generation stars, so they are extremely rare; and/or (2) the first generation stars that formed were extremely massive, so they all had very short lifetimes. In addition to these observational uncertainties, there are major theoretical uncertainties about the formation of first generation stars as well. Star formation in general is poorly understood, but it is known that metals are extremely important when forming stars. The reason for this somewhat technical, but makes for an interesting diversion. If you have a gas cloud out in interstellar space, it has some temperature. As the cloud collapses under its own gravity, it heats up. However, according to the virial theorem twice as much gravitational energy is lost as goes into heat -- this means that the other half must be radiated away. But radiative transport in these clouds can be inefficient. If your contracting gas cloud produces a photon, it will pretty soon hit a hydrogen atom, bump it up to the next energy level, and then be re-emitted when the hydrogen atom transitions back down to the ground state. This will happen many, many times and the photon will bounce around the cloud for a long, long time before it can random walk out of the cloud, escape, and cool the cloud down. Remember, until the photon leaves the cloud, the cloud cannot contract. However, if this photon hits a metal, electron will jump up to some high energy level, and then cascade down to the ground state through some complicated path and will emit several low energy photons. These photons will be unable to bump any hydrogen atoms up to the next energy level so they can travel through the cloud unimpeded. Thus metals are extremely important for cooling clouds efficiently. The more metals a cloud has, the more easily it can contract and form stars. A direct consequence of this is that clouds with metals can fragment more easily. This means that a large gas cloud will fragment into many smaller subclouds and form lots of stars in a cluster. In the early universe, however, it's not clear what happened. It may be that without metals clouds just didn't fragment and so the first generation of stars were all truly massive -- maybe hundreds to thousands of solar masses. But this scenario is problematic for a number of reasons -- foremost among them, the gas needs to cool somehow, and the cooling time seems to be too long to form these kinds of stars. There might (probably even must) be some other way to cool these clouds to get them to contract, but what other cooling mechanisms work on clouds without metals is not well understood. Results like this put constraints on how quickly the first generation of stars must have formed, how massive they must have been (at least some of them), and how many of them there must have been.
- ccvannorman 12y agoI feel this is the appropriate place to bring up that we're not all confident that the Big Bang actually happened at all. http://metaresearch.org/cosmology/BB-top-30.asp http://metaresearch.org/cosmology/BB-top-30.asp
- bashinator 12y agoThere are no citations more recent than 2002 in that article.
- nitrogen 12y agoEven if the universe did not expand from a singularity, universal redshift is still a thing, as is the CMB.
- ars 12y agoThe trouble comes because they measured the age using metric-expansion redshift. But if there is something else affecting the redshift - for example a huge galaxy in between with a strong gravitational pull then the galaxy will appear more redshifted than it would otherwise, and is not actually as old as it appears.
- sithu 12y agoI'm by no means a physicist but find topics on the nature of universe deeply fascinating. One thing i've always found frustratingly difficult to grasp though, is the expansion of the universe - but just found this article to be a total eye opener: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metric_expansion_of_space http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metric_expansion_of_space It was counterintuitive to me how we can observe light from objects 12 billion years old, when supposedly things are flying apart faster than the speed of light. Is there an edge of the universe, and what is outside that we are 'expanding into'. If everything is moving apart, why are we going to crash into Andromeda? Why haven't black holes consumed all the mass in the universe by now? If the cosmological principle is true and the universe looks the same in all directions, doesn't that imply that we're either at the center- or that it wraps around and we just can't observe it? Saying it's infinitely large seems like a convenient explanation. The idea of metric expansion of space between gravitationally unbound matter, local groups, and Hubble flow explain a lot. I do still wonder though how accurate our understanding of the universe really is, or if there's some fundamental thing we've missed and have generated theories to fit the observations we're currently capable of making.