4 ms·
Price discrimination only works if people can't easily identity that discrimination is in play. Otherwise, there will be backlash, which is what has been happen
by minimaxir 12y ago
Price discrimination only works if people can't easily identity that discrimination is in play. Otherwise, there will be backlash, which is what has been happening on Twitter this morning.
It's also worth nothing that price discrimination really doesn't work if it can easily be gamed. Many people create secondary Facebook profiles for Tinder; this implementation just ensures that there will be a lot more "27 year olds" on the service.
- benihana 12y ago>this implementation just ensures that there will be a lot more "27 year olds" on the service. which ultimately hurts the service as nobody will be able to know who is 27 and who is older than 27
- bazookajoes 12y agoI predict that people will put their real age in their bios. Many older people already do this today.
- MangoDiesel 12y agoYes exactly. This is a really badly designed implementation of a pricing tier strategy. It also seems likely that by incentivizing users to lie about their age, Tinder will create an entire zone of fake ages between something like 25-27, where users do not want to be grouped in with all of the "27 year olds" so they go year(s) lower. Thus, eliminating user trust for ages of anyone at numbers approaching 27.
- baddox 12y ago> Price discrimination only works if people can't easily identity that discrimination is in play. While this specific pricing model seems odd to me, I don't think I agree with your general claim. I think everyone understands the iPhone product line, with different prices for different amounts of storage space. As far as I know, that works really well for Apple, yet it would be difficult to have a more blatant example of price discrimination. edit: There are several people claiming that price discrimination requires the products to be completely identical. I maintain that is not how the term is used in economics. I replied with more detail here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9135084 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9135084
- mmastrac 12y agoI think what he means is charging different prices for different users for the same product.
- bazookajoes 12y agoI wonder if it matters that Tinder is a service not a product. In MS Office it is possible for two people to have the same user experience. But on Tinder the people that you interact with are the product. Legally this distinction is probably irrelevant.
- baddox 12y ago"Price discrimination" is widely used to refer to identical or nearly identical products whose cost of production is nearly identical despite being offered at significantly different prices.
- dragonwriter 12y ago"Price discrimination" means charging different users different prices for the same product/service. Apple charging different prices for different amounts of storage space is not price discrimination.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- baddox 12y ago"Price discrimination" is widely used to refer to identical or nearly identical products whose cost of production is nearly identical despite being offered at significantly different prices.
- czr80 12y agoPrice discrimination is when a business charges different prices to different groups of consumers for the same product or service. Charging different prices for similar goods is not pure price discrimination.
- hsod 12y agoMovie theaters very clearly show the different prices for different groups (students, seniors, etc.) and no one seems to mind. Same with zoos, museums, etc.
- AdrianRossouw 12y agodon't those also require the presentation of a valid student id, or some form of senior citizen id ?
- hsod 12y agostudent ID-- yes. senior citizen ID is probably just a drivers license with a DOB on it. not sure if you were agreeing or disagreeing with my point?
- duaneb 12y agoAlso, people are generally better with price CUTS for those perceived as disadvantaged, e.g. the elderly, students, etc. People are also GENERALLY ok with short-lived extra fees for the young and/or provably risky: think credit cards, rental cars, hotel rooms(?). I don't think I've ever seen a case of a price HIKE, though; stereotypically I imagine a grumpy group of older people.