3 ms·
> Focusing on one part of the IQ test, the Raven's Progressive Matrices, they found that on average intelligence has risen the equivalent of 20 IQ points since
by gwern 12y ago
> Focusing on one part of the IQ test, the Raven's Progressive Matrices, they found that on average intelligence has risen the equivalent of 20 IQ points since 1950. IQ tests are designed to ensure that the average result is always 100, so this is a significant jump.
The problem is, that's about the only part that has risen. The limited number of subtests showing the gains has long been one of the big question marks about how the Flynn effect could possibly be about the underlying intelligence rather than an artifact (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect).
> This is a puzzle not just for the US, but for all countries demonstrating the Flynn Effect. "Does it make sense," Flynn wrote in one paper, "to assume that at one time almost 40% of Dutch men lacked the capacity to understand soccer, their most favoured national sport?"
This sort of point comes up often, but it's not a good point to make. The people discussing IQ tests typically have lived in a tight bubble their entire lives and have not meaningfully interacted with the general population. They typically have even less interaction with the populations of poor countries who might be comparable to long ago. For example, just today I was reading a Wired article which remarks offhand that "In some areas of the country, up to 40 percent of children under 5 are affected. The effects are mental as well as physical. A 2008 study by the National Intelligence Council found that a quarter of North Korean military conscripts are disqualified for cognitive disabilities". Flynn asks whether it's possible for a quarter of Dutch men at some point to not be able to follow soccer well; I ask whether it's possible for a quarter of North Korean men to be rejected by the notoriously voracious NK military because they are too stupid or mentally broken. The latter seems to be true, however...
- TrainedMonkey 12y agoMy personal opinion is that Flynn effect is a combination of factors that aid developing of brain: 1. Better nutrition and medical care. 2. Teaching abstract concepts such as predicate logic early on. 3. Increasing complexity of the world in terms of information streams. 4. Urbanization of population. 4. Mandatory schooling and various programs aimed at increasing graduation rate, which is proxy for total amount of time an average child is schooled [0]. I was writing out long and detailed argument based on clustering of scholars and their presence in ancient civilizations, but after realizing amount of details such argument would need to stand I gave up. My argument was along the lines of: presence of clusters of extraordinary scholars in ancient civilizations show that prospering economy[1], knowledge communication, and education play crucial role in preparing those scholars. [0] Now thinking about it - I think there should be strong correlation between average time children are schooled and standardized test scores. Probably also has additional wide variety of rippling effects including better economic growth. [1] An economy that is capable of bearing load of academia.
- scholia 12y ago> I think there should be strong correlation between average time children are schooled and standardized test scores. Surely the simpler explanation is that the tests don't really measure "pure" intelligence, and the results are affected by all sorts of social features, including a general familiarity with IQ tests. Time-in-school is part of that.
- MaysonL 12y agoRe clustering of scholars, prosperity is probably important, but Bloom's two sigma problem[0] probably contributes also. Would Aristotle have been anywhere near as profound without Socrates and Plato as predecessors? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloom%27s_2_Sigma_Problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloom%27s_2_Sigma_Problem
- TrainedMonkey 12y agoThat was part of my point, would kids today perform better without benefit of all the scholar achievements before them? I was arguing that academic development of a society is part of the reason for Flynn effect.