5 ms·
If Google really wants to become a MVNO, then I don't understand why they haven't bought Republic Wireless yet. They had a chance at becoming the most verticall
by wtallis 12y ago
If Google really wants to become a MVNO, then I don't understand why they haven't bought Republic Wireless yet. They had a chance at becoming the most vertically integrated carrier when they owned Motorola Mobility, and they've already got a relationship with Republic's parent company providing the back-end for Google Voice.
- taeric 12y agoI will add to this that Republic Wireless has been a mostly awesome experience. I am not even convinced the bad points have been their fault. Just some times when the bloody phone will not actually make a call for me. (I should note I log a ridiculously low number of hours on voice calls.)
- ohsnap 12y agoGoogle is more interested in solving the bandwidth cap problem. They want to deploy high speed municipal wifi to solve this. Unlike Republic, they are not looking to cut your monthly bill - Google wants people to consume more data, not less. Republic is more focused on cutting costs by providing a more efficient (but basic) service... which is a very different business.
- wtallis 12y agoThere's still a ton of overlap in using WiFi to work around the limitations of cellular. Google won't want their customers using large amounts of cellular data any more than Republic does, because they'll have to face the same cost structure as a MVNO. Google's got a lot more money to throw around than Republic, but they're not going to spend it on subsidizing cellular data costs. They're going to use it on making WiFi offloading more broadly available, and thus they'll be every bit as focused on offloading as Republic. (And Google's in a great position to make sure that the WiFi that gets deployed actually works well enough to reliably support VoIP, which has been the biggest problem Republic faces.)
- ohsnap 12y agoYup huge technology overlap in offloading but I don't think Google really needs Republic's help there. But your right both are focused on making offloading as reliable and seamless as possible. Personally I think an independent Republic is the most interesting business because they have a lot of room to really drive prices down, something they couldn't do within Google.
- diafygi 12y agoWhat about pCells[1]? DIDO seemed like a really clever way around bandwidth sharing[2], but I haven't heard anything about it since mid-2014. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wGAnDQEQJ_s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wGAnDQEQJ_s [2]: http://www.rearden.com/DIDO/DIDO_White_Paper_110727.pdf http://www.rearden.com/DIDO/DIDO_White_Paper_110727.pdf
- martin1975 12y agoForget MVNO - I think they want to lay infrastructure. The likes of Verizon and ATT cannot be brought down and/or competed against by becoming their MVNO-bitch. Anyone has any calculations on what it costs to deploy brand new LTE infrastructure to cover like 80-90% of the population in the USA (i.e. major metro areas + suburbia around it)? Google could probably swing that.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoPersonally, I have two problems with Republic Wireless: no ability to bring your own device (I'm never buying a device from a carrier again), and an attempt to guilt-trip the customer into not using data (either you're unlimited or you're not, don't tell me I have unlimited data if you're going to gripe when I use it).
- wtallis 12y agoGoogle can and probably eventually will solve the bring-your-own-device problem by making WiFi-to-cellular call handover part of the default Android stack. Until they do, anyone else has to make the modifications themselves, which is about as time consuming as bringing a whole new phone to market. The discouraging of cellular data use is something that all MVNOs have to do because they don't have enough leverage against the major carriers to get reasonable pricing. Google's got part of a solution by being an ISP that can deploy WiFi (and perhaps some cellular service on suboptimal spectrum) to the kind of places that suffer from the most congestion on the cellular networks. The rest is just a consequence of the market being controlled by an oligopoly, and it's not the little guys you should be blaming.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoI'm not blaming the MVNOs for discouraging data use. I'm blaming them for advertising "unlimited data". If you have unlimited data, great. If not, don't claim you do.
- wtallis 12y agoWell, Republic doesn't have a hard limit on data usage except when roaming (which most MVNOs don't offer at all). Republic will throttle your speed after 5GB but won't cut you off or charge you extra. The only difference between this and what the major carriers that charge 2-3x do is that Republic's threshold is lower and more publicized.