2 ms·
Yglesias says, "People figure that whatever political problems it might have will prove transient — just as happened before." This is way too dismissive of wha
by snowwrestler 12y ago
Yglesias says, "People figure that whatever political problems it might have will prove transient — just as happened before."
This is way too dismissive of what's actually happened in American history. The word "transient" implies that the political problems eventually went away, and American democracy kept on going.
But what actually happened is that each political problem was addressed by changing our government--either through Constitution amendment, through federal legislation, or through the creation of new court precedent.
So the American government of today would not look very familiar to the people who wrote the Constitution. If they were alive today, they would think that what they created has already been replaced. We'll feel the same way 100 years from now...big deal. People always feel out of place as they age.
The fundamental benefit of the American system of government is that it can be changed in a wide variety of ways without violence.
- jadell 12y agoI think the author's point is not that those "wide variety of ways" don't exist, but that they are currently being broken/circumvented. The standing gentlemen's agreements to not play the game a certain way are being thrown out. Each side is using tactics that, while legal, were historically frowned upon precisely because it was understood that they would lead to the sort of gridlock we're currently experiencing. These are tactics that were understood to only be used as a last resort, but have become SOP.