7 ms·
How does it fare against Unity? My understanding, from previous versions, is that Unity offered a lot more tooling than Unreal. Also, Unreal's SDK demanded a l
by outworlder 12y ago
How does it fare against Unity?
My understanding, from previous versions, is that Unity offered a lot more tooling than Unreal. Also, Unreal's SDK demanded a lot of C++ code, which can be unappealing for small studios compared to Unity's Mono and several possible (managed) language choices.
However, Unreal appears to be much more capable, and better performing.
Also, is Crytek still competitive? It used to be competitive with Epic's offering, but was Windows-only.
EDIT: Unreal does have a comparison page for Unity developers: https://docs.unrealengine.com/latest/INT/GettingStarted/FromUnity/index.html https://docs.unrealengine.com/latest/INT/GettingStarted/From...
- lfowles 12y agoCheck out some videos on the UE4 Blueprints system (flowchart programming). I'm pretty impressed at the product they created there, IIRC there are some games made on Blueprints alone. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JFZCp4xsPmo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JFZCp4xsPmo : Unreal Engine 4 Blueprints in Solus (1h)
- rplnt 12y agoI believe Crytek stepped down from the "indie" scene.
- outworlder 12y agoThat's unfortunate. I love the way their engine renders water and had ideas for it.
- lentil_soup 12y agoYou can actually license the engine royalty-free for $9.90/month through Steam (http://www.cryengine.com/get-cryengine http://www.cryengine.com/get-cryengine)
- archagon 12y agoMy understanding is that Crytek is in some financial trouble. It would be unwise to rely on them for future support.
- pestaa 12y agoCrytek claims otherwise in an IGN article from last year[0], although the circumstances are quite suspicious. How could a company so successful not turn profit? [0]: http://www.ign.com/articles/2014/06/24/crytek-reportedly-in-financial-trouble http://www.ign.com/articles/2014/06/24/crytek-reportedly-in-...
- higherpurpose 12y agoI think Crytek's graphics look quite a bit better and more realistic then Unreal 4, but I don't know if the tools are just as good. Also not sure if Cryengine is competitive from a performance point of view (could be a trade-off with the better graphics).
- imaginenore 12y agoUnreal Engine 4 is capable of producing VERY realistic environments. Check this out: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y6PQ19BEE24&t=15s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y6PQ19BEE24&t=15s
- neckro23 12y agoIf you prebake the lighting and use ridiculously high-rez textures, you can make any 3D engine look like that. Static geometry is cheap.
- arikrak 12y agoIf you don't need the C++ performance, my guess is it makes more sense to go with Unity and use their C# version.
- pjmlp 12y agoActually Unity will be compiling C# to native code via IL2CPP to avoid paying royalties[0] for more recent Xamarin versions. [0] At least that is how I read the whole situation
- brandonwamboldt 12y agoIt's not as clear cut. You can use C# with Unreal Engine if you prefer, and Unreal Engine offers a lot that Unity doesn't (e.g. Blueprints). I recommend everyone interested in the two try both. I personally prefer Unreal Engine, but everyone is different. Unreal Engine is also moving quite quickly, adding new features, marketplace content, improving the UI, etc.
- nowarninglabel 12y agoI've been trying to decide which to cut my teeth on, to build a prototype MMORPG. I'm comfortable with C++, though my colleague won't be. Any suggestion on which engine/toolkit would be better for that type of build? Graphics quality is not a big concern, mostly just want to use the tool that have the best chance of becoming proficient with.
- brandonwamboldt 12y agoI don't think either engine is well suited for an MMO to be honest. You are probably better off looking at something like the HeroEngine. Unreal Engine's built in networking systems are suitable for 64 players, maybe 128 tops. It's replaceable, but I wouldn't recommend delving into that. I will say this though, if you have 1 C++ programmer with UE4, they can create functionality not builtin to the engine and expose it via Blueprint (the visual scripting language) for non-programmers to use. Blueprint is a fantastic and very easy to use tool. Take a look at the forums to see the incredible things people have built with ZERO programming knowledge.
- deelowe 12y agoIt's hard to compare unity and unreal. To answer the question about c++, with UE4, the blueprint system removes almost all of that. Entire games can be written in their visual programming language. I also think there are ways to use c# (https://mono-ue.github.io/ https://mono-ue.github.io/), if you prefer that as well. C++ is needed if you want to extend the native classes. Regarding the editor, unreal is pretty amazing. It really shines in the tools department. Check out the landscape editor, materials editor, and animation tools on youtube. Pretty fantastic stuff. The game engine itself is better than unity in almost every way with a few big exceptions: 1) multiplayer map size. unity can pretty easily support large online worlds 2) support for mobile/tablets. unity is the dominant platform on those devices. 3) community support. unity has a much larger community, better documentation, and a much more populous online store (though unreal is catching up)
- outworlder 12y agoI was thinking about something like Lua. Now, the multiplayer map size limitation seems odd nowadays.
- cma 12y agoMostly to do with floating point precision, the devs of Star Citizen ran into the same issue with Cry Engine when they tried to make things space-scale, and ended up initially stuck with small battle-arena maps. UE4 can re-origin things for a single player moving through a large world to maintain physics precision, etc. but it doesn't currently work with multiple people and their server model.
- outworlder 12y agoSo, basically what Kerbal Space Program does. Which also doesn't work well with multiple people.
- deelowe 12y agoThat said, keep in mind that you can get roughly a maximum of 20 sq km with the default landscape tool (not sure about performance at that scale). I believe there's also some hard coded limits around the number of simultaneous players (16?), though it seems fairly easy to work around. Again, not sure about performance.
- malkia 12y agoCan you even compare them :) Evaluation of software, be it library, framework, sdk or a whole engine+tools is much much harder than writing actual software, especially when royalties, copyright and other legal issues are involved. In reality there is no way of knowing what would do your best, so you can look at specific bad parts and take that into decision making, for example, for what I've heard (and possibly it could be wrong): - Unity is not really good when lots of people have to edit the same files, merging is not really good, and the server option does not really cut it. (For example Quake's engine .map text files are not so bad to merge in cvs/svn/p4/etc.) - Unreal had always had the bad "fame" of 30-only fps game, while this is okay for certain shooters, or 3rd person games, it would've never worked for "Call of Duty" where the brand was simply established with 60fps. To some people this might sound a bit pedantic, but 60fps matters! (And >60fps does not really, unless you need to swap frames for a 3D VR device of sort) That to be said both engines surely have really good parts. From little I've explored in Unity, what got me first was the ability to extend the editor while it's running - I could add menus with functionality while it was running - this is super cool. Unreal on the other side is well known engine with lots of people from the AAA game industry familiar with it, and while the editor might seem completely foreign to people starting in the game industry, it's pretty well known by many others (I guess they don't advertise it much). The hidden gem of Unreal for me, was it's internal UI system, which could be used as a separate project - it has docking, controls, etc. - it might be a good replacement for Qt, MFC, wxWidgets, etc.
- alok-g 12y agoThanks for a great review of both. I am confused, so is Unreal unable to do 60 Hz? Do you have any experience with the UI system or know about any projects using it? I wonder what Gotchas or limitations may exist.
- k00pa 12y agoI have never heard about this "fame", yet I cannot think about game that is 30-only fps? I can think a lot of games that are ue1-4 that are not bound by fps limits at all. Editor in UE4 is streamlined from what UE3 was. Its now quite easy in the end.
- kriro 12y agoThe graphic of the comparison page is a bit unfortunate from Unreal's POV. I get that they want the arrows to indicate "move to" as in move from Unity to Unreal. Can't help but interpret it as Unity >>> Unreal though which is probably not what they intended. I really like this easy 5% above X model. Seems fair enough.
- Arelius 12y agoI'm actually super curious as to why you have that opinion, UnrealEngine has been around longer, and has always had significantly more in the way of production quality tools and features. There are certainly differences, especially when you get down into the details, but two large features Unreal has had for 10 years, shader graph tools, and animation blend trees, are either new and still painful in Unity (mechanim) or only existent as a third-party add-on (shaderforge)
- feyzee 12y agoCryENGINE is now available as Software as a Service model. $10 a month and no royalties
- ttctciyf 12y agoFor some developers, source access must be a huge deal over Unity free version - if you want to roll your own entity system or do a native plug... WAIT! unity 5 is now out, including all features in the unity engine for free (including native plugins), with no subscription, and entirely invalidating the premise of this comment.
- netinstructions 12y agoSomething that I look for when comparing tools/frameworks are the number of Stackoverflow questions and answers. http://www.arepeopletalkingaboutit.com/tags/unity3d,unreal-engine4,unreal-development-kit,unrealscript http://www.arepeopletalkingaboutit.com/tags/unity3d,unreal-e... offers a quick visualization. I may have missed a few tags, but it looks like there's a very large amount of people talking about Unity3d on Stackoverflow relative to Unreal. No wonder they want to open it up to the masses. Of course that can be interpreted many ways (Are there active email lists? Are there active forums elsewhere?) and raises other questions (What's the best way to learn a tool/technology?) but it's at least one useful metric for checking in on my FOMO.