4 ms·
Why not? It isn't hard to build machines that are stronger than we are or faster than we are. Even if there is some sort of strange mirror version of Turing's t
by jjoonathan 12y ago
Why not? It isn't hard to build machines that are stronger than we are or faster than we are. Even if there is some sort of strange mirror version of Turing's thesis that prevents us from creating AIs more intelligent than we are, inventing an AI that is equally intelligent but faster would accomplish much the same thing.
Also, bootstrapping is highly effective in countless other contexts within computer science, what do you think will prevent it from being applicable to this problem?
- ars 12y agoSo far every bit of intelligence we have made is all about brute force, none of it is elegant. It works great - definitely. And I grant that given enough speed, and search depth such a machine may come up with ideas. And maybe that's what human level AI will end up being: Just search every possibility till you find the one that works. For everything, including speaking with a person. But it just doesn't have that spark of true intelligence. So I'll qualify my earlier statement, brute force AI might happen. But AI based on elegant intelligence will not. Is there a difference? I think so. For some things it won't matter, but for others it will. Somehow human level intelligence manages to cut through immense search spaces and find the answer (like the game Go) - how does it do that? No one knows. But there is clearly something different about it compared to brute force intelligence.
- baddox 12y agoWhy don't you think an "AI based on elegant intelligence" (according to your own definition) will happen? Do you suppose it's merely a problem of engineering and complexity, i.e. the human race is likely to become extinct before we will figure out how the human brain works? Or do you suppose there is some more fundamental reason why only humans (and perhaps other intelligent organic beings) can exhibit this type of intelligence?
- ars 12y agoBoth (separately though, the two answers are not related even though I put them in one post - I'm allowed to have more than one thought about something). We just don't understand intelligence (not the brain, intelligence) well enough to duplicate it, never mind improve it. And I don't think we ever will because to understand something complex you have to be more complex than that thing, but by definition we can not be more complex than ourself - so understanding our own intelligence will always be beyond us. That's the objective part. The subjective part is that I personally believe that intelligence is not physical. The brain mediates it, but the source is elsewhere. The soul maybe, or that we are really game characters in an MMOG.
- 3beard 12y agoThe source of all real insight is, of course, divinity. True understanding is not generated by the brain but rather received in the Plexus Solaris and then works it's way up to the brain, where it is turned into action, language or memory.
- baddox 12y agoI don't see any clear reason to believe your first claim. Humans can and do create things that are far too complex for any one human to be able to conceive of or comprehend. Most large engineering projects are good examples of this, but also even larger systems like governments and markets. You can certainly argue that even these large systems are less complex than human intelligence, but even if a human can only understand things 1% as complex as his own intelligence, I see no compelling reason to believe that thousands of humans can't develop something more complex than one human's intelligence. As for your second claim, well, I suppose it is subjective, though I would prefer the term "speculative."
- jjoonathan 12y ago> brute force, none of it is elegant Where does the human brain fall on that spectrum? It might take us a few more decades to figure out the details of how it works, but I doubt we'll find elegance so much as a ton of hyperparallel brute force plus a few dirty tricks that evolution kludged together to prevent the whole thing from falling apart (most of the time, anyway). > But there is clearly something different about [elegant intelligence] compared to brute force intelligence. Could you elaborate on what you mean by this distinction and how the human brain does not constitute "brute force"?
- ars 12y agoLook at the game of Go. Humans can play it - it's impossible for a human to brute force it, there is not enough computation available in the brain to brute force it. (Your "hyperparallel brute force" idea.) Yet humans can play it anyway. There is something else there that makes it possible. And the human brain self trains! That's the really amazing part - no one has to think of some clever optimization or algorithm to make it work like you would if you wanted a computer to play "elegantly".
- Padding 12y agoYou use so many words, yet none of them with precise meaning. > none of it is elegant What is "elegant" to you? A biological brain, for all intents and purposes, is a big mess. By comparison an ALU in silicon is much neater. The way we "think" by forming associations and recalling the most striking ones we've formed seems awfully chaotic/arbitrary and unreliable. By comparison the way a search engine works by scoring words and phrases and optimizing for recall and precision seems so much neater. > But it just doesn't have that spark of true intelligence. What is "true intelligence" to you? Perhaps you meant just human intelligence? Perhaps "true ingelligence" is just sufficiently adavanced technology (i.e. "magic")? > Somehow human level intelligence manages to cut through immense search spaces and find the answer (like the game Go) - how does it do that? Except of course when it doesn't, right? Isn't that why we're looking at AI? It's not really our own mertit, but we already know how to create more humans with human-level intelligence. It's neither afully efficient nor awfully reliable, but seems to work well enough for "practical purposes". The allure of AI is being able create something more than that. Requiring it to make the same mistakes as humans and to work in similarly unpredictable ways in order to appear genuine then seem like the wrong goals.