3 ms·
> "This movie has so many cliches in it," a boy said (...) My son told him, "This movie was made in 1986. It invented all the cliches." The first boy was right
by acqq 12y ago
> "This movie has so many cliches in it," a boy said (...) My son told him, "This movie was made in 1986. It invented all the cliches."
The first boy was right. It felt full of cliches even then. I watched it in eighties as soon as it was distributed to my place and I all the time I had that feeling of "boring 'we're the marines' movie." And I still can't understand why would anybody consider Aliens an interesting movie. The first Alien is however something else. And I was always amazed to later watch "The Dark Star" made before the Alien and find it (among the other things) an Alien parody made before the Alien(!) It's really so thanks to Dan O Bannon. Now that's something. Aliens... not even worth mentioning.
Watch Alien, watch The Dark Star. Forget the boring Aliens.
Disclaimer: I'm old enough that I've watched the Star Wars in seventies in my movie theatre. And Mad Max. And and and.. Of course Aliens were already cliches and cliches.
- psychometry 12y agoPart of the problem is James Cameron reusing the same themes and tropes in all of his movies. The Abyss and Avatar are pretty similar to Aliens thematically.
- acqq 12y agoCameron made some really outstanding movies, but I at least don't count Aliens among them. The Abyss was more than amazing for me.
- nycticorax 12y agoThe Abyss and Avatar were both made after Aliens. How can Cameron reusing themes from Aliens in those movies be a criticism of Aliens?
- psychometry 12y agoRead the article. The younger viewers complained about cliches in Aliens, probably from seeing the same cliches reused in movies they've already seen, like Avatar.
- mathgenius 12y agoI'm old enough that I saw Aliens in the theatre, with my Dad. I remember he had a similar perspective to you. His comment was how the original alien was smarter than than the crew, but in the second movie the aliens are just dumb animals. This may be true, but for me the second movie is one of my all-time favourites.
- pyre 12y ago> His comment was how the original alien was smarter than than the crew, but in the second movie the aliens are just dumb animals. In the first movie, there was only one Alien and it acted more like a lone hunter. In the second movie, there were lots of aliens and they acted like a hive. I think that it's possible for both of these to be consistent with each other.
- outworlder 12y agoDon't forget the instances where they display intelligent behavior. Such as turning off the power, operating elevators, the alien queen telling the drones to back off.
- mathgenius 12y agoI don't think operating an elevator (etc.) compares to hunting down and decimating the entire crew (almost) one by one. Such behavior is so far more advanced than anything we see in the second movie. There is a real sense that the alien is just plain smarter than everyone in the crew, and in the end ripley just has to run for it. None of this happens in the second movie, where it's just a slaughter fest.
- nycticorax 12y agoPerhaps you'd care to elaborate on exactly what the cliches were? Cameron intended to make the early parts with the colonial marines feel like a Vietnam movie, where you worry that the soldiers' lack of discipline and seriousness is going to lead to tears. I'm not sure I'd call that a cliche. Honestly, I think the sound the pulse rifles make is sufficient to earn Aliens a place in cinema history.
- abruzzi 12y agoI'm not sure I'd call them cliches, but the kind of one dimensional portrayal of the various marine characters. For example the Bill Paxton character--he starts the film the most outwardly bloviating and macho, and becomes the most (annoying) scared. It was played to 11 which made it feel very shallow to me. The company man was also a pretty one dimensional character. I also felt the mothering at the beginning and with Newt kind of cliched. I was very glad both Hicks and Newt were killed off for Alien 3, which in its directors cut version, I liked much better than 2. I guess not liking Aliens much puts me well in the minority.