5 ms·
The fact that they don't want to tell you where the speed cameras are tells me that this is a kickback scheme. If it's about public safety, you WANT people to
by bsder 12y ago
The fact that they don't want to tell you where the speed cameras are tells me that this is a kickback scheme.
If it's about public safety, you WANT people to know that the cameras are there.
- leereeves 12y agoIf you tell people where the cameras are, you've also told them where the cameras AREN'T. Ideally, for public safety, you'd want people to always think "there might a camera here".
- rhizome 12y agoYou and Jeremy Bentham both.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jvm 12y ago> kickback scheme How could enforcing the law be a kickback scheme? Don't want a ticket? Don't speed! As a pedestrian I would personally prefer that drivers always feel they are in danger of getting a ticket, so drivers always have an incentive to follow the law.
- CamperBob2 12y agoAs a pedestrian I would personally prefer that drivers were looking out for me, not fixating on their speedometers.
- rullgrus 12y agoAround where I live there is a road where the limit changes from 70 km/h to 50 km/h due to a pedestrian crossing. They also placed a speed camera just after the crossing. When driving there I always find my self checking and double checking my vehicle speed and not paying full attention to the crossing. But in this specific case I guess that the "forced" speed reduction due to the camera is a bigger benefit (fewer accidents and less serious if they do happen) than the distraction caused by it.
- nulltype 12y agoWell what if the people enforcing this particular law do so only because they are getting some percentage of the ticket fee? It could lead to, for instance, inappropriately low speed limits and an inordinate amount of police work on traffic violations instead of things that are more dangerous but make less money.
- jvm 12y agoI completely agree with the sentiment, those are all valid concerns. But in the context of New York City I strongly believe the dangers to pedestrians are paramount. > inappropriately low speed limits It's hard to imagine speed limits too low for a pedestrian intensive area like lower Manhattan. According to this fact sheet [1], "In the City of London, the rate of crash-related deaths and serious injuries within 20-mph residential zones dropped by 42 percent." ... probably worth it in an area where pedestrians greatly outnumber drivers. > inordinate amount of police work on traffic violations instead of things that are more dangerous I'm not sure there's anything in the city right now more dangerous to the average citizen than unsafe driving, given that there are on average 4,250 permanently-debilitating injuries from traffic injuries due to traffic injuries each year in the city. [1] [1] http://www.transalt.org/about/facts http://www.transalt.org/about/facts
- nulltype 12y agohttp://www.nyc.gov/html/doh/downloads/pdf/vs/vs-mortality-2012.pdf http://www.nyc.gov/html/doh/downloads/pdf/vs/vs-mortality-20... If I'm reading this correctly, homicide still kills more people than traffic accidents. So while the injury rate may be higher for traffic, death rate still seems to be biased toward homicide. As for how to make the traffic better, your source indicates 1/4 of fatalities are from drivers failing to yield right of way. One idea is that if intersections in cities had turn arrows and different parts of the cycle for turning cars and pedestrians, that could reduce that significantly. Doing an analysis of why people get hit even though they're in the crosswalk or whatever might be informative here rather than just going straight for speed limit or installing airbags on the fronts of cars. Of course, I think the real solution is not better traffic laws, but self-driving cars. People are fundamentally poorly suited to driving cars and only a machine can do a consistent job without getting bored or impatient. Once we have a decent number of self driving cars, any ways to improve pedestrian safety will probably look totally different. It might save a lot of lives to focus less on new traffic laws and more on making autonomous cars a reality (the legal side of that seems to be progressing very slowly).
- TeMPOraL 12y agoAs other commenters wrote, you want drivers to always follow the speed limits. Moreover, I can tell you how things look when drivers know where cameras are placed. In Poland, we have an actual Android app that will tell you not only where stationary cameras are but also where the police currently is monitoring the traffic. It's a hit among drivers, and people use it to look like law-abiding citizens next to a camera, while not giving a fuck about road safety and speeding like crazy the moment they're sure they're not being monitored. Seriously, the more drivers I know, the more I want linear speed tracking and ALPRs to be deployed everywhere, on every single damn road.
- mytochar 12y agoBefore we get speed cameras, I would rather have: * always use blinker when turning / change lanes cameras * turn your lights on: * 30 minutes from dusk / dawn * when it's raining cameras * bikers without safety lights cameras * runners without reflective gear yet running in the road at night cameras * hand-held cellphone while driving and not stopped cameras * tailgating cameras Speeding is the least of my worries about the road.
- jrockway 12y agoIf you were driving slower, you probably wouldn't hit as many pedestrians regardless of whether or not they're wearing reflective gear. The reality is: a runner hits someone, two people are annoyed. A car hits someone, one person is dead. Cyclists are somewhere in the middle.
- mytochar 12y ago30 is still a very painful accident for a pedestrian; but, yes, ideally there'd be less pedestrian incidents... [1, random thought footnote] That said, most of the things I was suggesting had more to do with highway situations, where I imagine most of the speed cameras would be situated. I was mainly ranting about things that I see almost every single time that I go driving, if not every single time I go driving, that erks me as a safety hazard that seems more dangerous than speeding (where speeding is defined as above the posted limit, but within a modest delta of other adjacent cars on the highway) [1, random thought footnote] Unless we had some sort of ironic situation where since cars are going slower, pedestrians become more presumptuous about their powers and the car's stopping abilities / driver's attentiveness and it'd result in more accidents. Who knows