5 ms·
If anything, this data shows how egregious speeding in NYC is. The cameras can only issue tickets if you're driving 10mph above the speed limit. Until recentl
by jrockway 12y ago
If anything, this data shows how egregious speeding in NYC is. The cameras can only issue tickets if you're driving 10mph above the speed limit. Until recently this was 40mph. Now it's 35.
35 is way too fast for city driving, so even if there are concerns that this is just a money grab (only for the city; no private companies get a percentage of the tickets), it's still worth doing.
If all cars were going 25mph at all times, there would be a lot less people dying in traffic. Cycling would also be a lot more pleasant.
- pmorici 12y agoAre you sure, no private companies are getting a cut of ticket money? I couldn't find any information on that page either way and it is very common for governments to cut deals with private companies to let them setup cameras din return for a cut of the revenue which gives them zero incentive for the tickets to be accurate.
- jrockway 12y agoMy source is this official FAQ: http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/2014-10-speed-camera-faq.pdf http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/2014-10-speed-came...
- mytochar 12y ago"city driving" Then we get into the argument of what constitutes city driving and that gets fun. What's a city. Is a road connecting two roads a city road? What if it has side-walks or a bike lane? What about the small town that has a bike lane, too? We'd have to see a case-by-case basis of the speed limit in a given location to give an appropriate speed limit for an area. .. I wrote that, but now I'm thinking that if we had a reasonable, almost static speed limit for driving inside a city, then that would be one less thing the driver has to think about while driving in the city, so that would be good. Some sort of testing would be needed to decide on an appropriate speed, but I imagine somewhere between 25 and 35 would prove to be a good speed.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> We'd have to see a case-by-case basis of the speed limit in a given location to give an appropriate speed limit for an area. Doesn't matter. Just have a speed limit and make people obey it, and then let the traffic engineers run simulations and adjust those limits to maximize flow and minimize accident rates. But when people have a habitual disregard of speed limits[0], determining the optimal value of those limits is nigh impossible. [0] - I don't know what's the driving culture in the US, but in Poland - where I live - most drivers show total disregard for speed limits and driving rules. They think they're the smartest, and that no accident can happen to them.
- mytochar 12y ago"let the traffic engineers run simulations and adjust those limits to maximize flow and minimize accident rates" Wasn't there a discussion about how it's hard to raise a speed limit in an area? If the safe / max flow speed turns out to be higher than it currently is, I suspect it would be hard to get it raised. I am in great support of this idea, though.. I'd also like more aggressive variable speed limits instead of "60 all the time, between bone-dry land and torrential rain"
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI don't recall that discussion, but it would be great if you or someone else could post a link to it.
- jrockway 12y agoThe argument is pretty easy in New York: city driving is driving within the city limits, which are largely defined by islands. Exceptions are made for fully-grade separated highways.
- revelation 12y ago10mph over to even trigger the thing? That's a cool 150$ in the Netherlands. 20 over and you possibly won't be driving for a while.
- thrownaway2424 12y agoIt's quite impossible to lose your license here in the usa. Most people think their license was given to them personally by God.
- cmurf 12y agoPart of manifest destiny.
- jedrek 12y agoAbout 150 pedestrians are killed in NYE annually, that's one every other day in a city where relatively few people own cars.
- cpwright 12y agoBut one of the types of cameras generating the most revenue is on the exit ramp from a highway. They have cameras that will clock you before you're in a "city street" proper.
- nulltype 12y agoIf they were going 5mph at all times, there would be even less people dying in traffic. Unless you count wasting their time waiting in 5mph traffic.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoIf the parent had said 15 or 20 mph instead of 25, there wouldn't be a significant difference in traffic deaths. If you get hit by a car at 15mph, you are highly unlikely to die. You may break a bone, but you won't be dead. Of course, that excludes freak accidents -- you could fall onto a spike or something. But freak accidents are possible whether the car is going 5mph or 15.
- bsder 12y ago> If anything, this data shows how egregious speeding in NYC is. Who says? You? What's the percentage of drivers violating the speed limit? Maybe that limit IS too low. A speed limit is supposed to be set such that 85-90% of the drivers obey it naturally.
- cmurf 12y agoThis is complete bullshit. Do you live in NYC?? No, of course you don't, which is why you have no f'n idea WTF you're talking about. I do, and especially Manhattan is dangerous for pedestrians and cyclists alike. People get hit all the time. The singular thing that keeps speeds sane is all the traffic. So when there's little traffic on a single lane side street, let alone the avenues, it's taxis and Escalades busting 40+ always. This town is adult Disney Land, and as such every vehicle should have a tracker, charging tax by the f'n mile and minute, and tracking speed and charge disproportionately for speeding - 5mph over leeway and after that it's $500 automatic account fine per mph over that. Dicks. This city is a f'n goddamn shithole mainly because of all the insane amounts of traffic. God I love this town... but it is a shithole and cars are far far far more dangerous than anything else around here. Except maybe falling cranes. And the police. OK that's not fair, I'm white I have no room to complain.
- bsder 12y ago> So when there's little traffic on a single lane side street, let alone the avenues, it's taxis and Escalades busting 40+ always. While the taxis are a separate kettle of fish, the existence of off-hours speeding by local traffic f'n tells me that your own f'n neighbors do not agree with you. I suggest you f'n take it up with them. In spite of what you think, speed cameras will only be a temporary solution if people do not think the speed limit is fair. This happened in California with red light cameras. Once enough people knew someone who got busted and thought it was unfair, there was enough political will to scrap them altogether even though there really were intersections that desperately needed them. This also happened in Pittsburgh with parking boots. Once the city got the biggest scofflaws, they didn't have the usage they expected. So, they started using them for even first time offenders. Well, people didn't find that very fair, so cottage businesses to acetylene torch the boot off sprung up and cost the city a lot since they now had to buy a new boot every time one got torched. Very quickly, the city figured out that over-use of that enforcement tool cost more than it helped. Enforcement does not create compliance. Enforcement is simply an adjunct to something that most people are complying with already. If you want people to slow down, you have to engineer the road so that they want to slow down. Speed humps, roundabouts, curb extensions, etc. are all tools to make that work.
- cmurf 12y agoRight and what else can you do? Use harsh language? To a New Yorker that's like praying to the Greek gods, it only makes us more powerful. 35 is too high, 30 is too high, 25 is too high. There are so many people cycling now in the past few years alone, it's just crazy having bikes and cars at such different relative speeds. The speed limit probably should be 20mph considering the vast majority are pedestrians and bikers at least in Manhattan (most people take trains but ultimately they are all also pedestrians too).