8 ms·
Speed Cameras and the City
- CamperBob2 12y agoSounds like an exercise in ignoring confounding variables.
- djf1 12y agoCould you elaborate? Which confounding variables?
- CamperBob2 12y agoEverything else that changed over the course of the study period. Speed limits might have been lowered, enforcement patterns might have been revised, the congestion charges might have changed, the weather might have been different. It would be more helpful to see a graph showing historical trends stretching back at least ten or twelve years, just to give us an idea of the standard deviation.
- Animats 12y agoIt would be a useful project to instrument a few Manhattan intersections with camera coverage from above, track all the vehicles and pedestrians, see what happens and what happened before each accident and near-miss.
- jrockway 12y agoIf anything, this data shows how egregious speeding in NYC is. The cameras can only issue tickets if you're driving 10mph above the speed limit. Until recently this was 40mph. Now it's 35. 35 is way too fast for city driving, so even if there are concerns that this is just a money grab (only for the city; no private companies get a percentage of the tickets), it's still worth doing. If all cars were going 25mph at all times, there would be a lot less people dying in traffic. Cycling would also be a lot more pleasant.
- pmorici 12y agoAre you sure, no private companies are getting a cut of ticket money? I couldn't find any information on that page either way and it is very common for governments to cut deals with private companies to let them setup cameras din return for a cut of the revenue which gives them zero incentive for the tickets to be accurate.
- jrockway 12y agoMy source is this official FAQ: http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/2014-10-speed-camera-faq.pdf http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/2014-10-speed-came...
- mytochar 12y ago"city driving" Then we get into the argument of what constitutes city driving and that gets fun. What's a city. Is a road connecting two roads a city road? What if it has side-walks or a bike lane? What about the small town that has a bike lane, too? We'd have to see a case-by-case basis of the speed limit in a given location to give an appropriate speed limit for an area. .. I wrote that, but now I'm thinking that if we had a reasonable, almost static speed limit for driving inside a city, then that would be one less thing the driver has to think about while driving in the city, so that would be good. Some sort of testing would be needed to decide on an appropriate speed, but I imagine somewhere between 25 and 35 would prove to be a good speed.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> We'd have to see a case-by-case basis of the speed limit in a given location to give an appropriate speed limit for an area. Doesn't matter. Just have a speed limit and make people obey it, and then let the traffic engineers run simulations and adjust those limits to maximize flow and minimize accident rates. But when people have a habitual disregard of speed limits[0], determining the optimal value of those limits is nigh impossible. [0] - I don't know what's the driving culture in the US, but in Poland - where I live - most drivers show total disregard for speed limits and driving rules. They think they're the smartest, and that no accident can happen to them.
- mytochar 12y agoSo I find this interesting; and, I'm glad they provided at least this statistic: Vehicle crashes near cameras declined 3.9% Crashes with injuries near cameras declined 13.4% If that's the case, I'm pleased. That's a noticeable decline. I wonder what else could be done to safely reduce the number of crashes, while still allowing drivers the freedom to drive. Another interesting piece: Referring to 'The Busy Crossing', "This is the kind of location one might expect for a speed camera. They target busy crossings near some of the city's most dangerous boulevards. These cameras are more common than the "speed traps" but they issue far fewer tickets." I imagine knowing that there is a speed camera near a given light reduces the amount of people willing to test that. When it comes to traffic lights and busy crossings, I think this is a good thing; and not having very many tickets there should by no means be indicative of the systems failing. In fact, I would argue they might be working. You'd have to do a blind test of some sort with unmarked cameras (that don't give out tickets either) at other locations; but ... that's most likely illegal. (IANAL) And then regarding this: "Almost half of the city's speed cameras are mobile — mounted on NYPD vehicles, they watch different spots for a day or two. Officials won't say how those spots are picked, though school principals and community groups can make requests. The mobile cameras each issue just a few tickets a day; as a group they issue only 11.5% of all tickets." That's to be expected. It's a camera mounted to a police vehicle. People tend to act more civil on the road and more accurate to the rules when there's a police officer around. Personally, I'd love to find out the statistics around red-light cameras, as well. I imagine they might be even more useful in quelling negative activity (though they probably won't bring in as much money as speeding cameras)
- ezzaf 12y agoThere's a study on red light cameras in Chicago that shows some interesting data about what affects they have on driving behaviour and accident rates http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/watchdog/redlight/ct-red-light-camera-safety-met-20141219-story.html#page=1 http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/watchdog/redlight/ct-red-...
- np422 12y agoOr perhaps it's just the old phrase "Lies, damned lies, and statistics" that is appropriate once again? Veritasium explains it better than me. Please watch https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1tSqSMOyNFE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1tSqSMOyNFE
- bsder 12y agoThe fact that they don't want to tell you where the speed cameras are tells me that this is a kickback scheme. If it's about public safety, you WANT people to know that the cameras are there.
- leereeves 12y agoIf you tell people where the cameras are, you've also told them where the cameras AREN'T. Ideally, for public safety, you'd want people to always think "there might a camera here".
- rhizome 12y agoYou and Jeremy Bentham both.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jvm 12y ago> kickback scheme How could enforcing the law be a kickback scheme? Don't want a ticket? Don't speed! As a pedestrian I would personally prefer that drivers always feel they are in danger of getting a ticket, so drivers always have an incentive to follow the law.
- CamperBob2 12y agoAs a pedestrian I would personally prefer that drivers were looking out for me, not fixating on their speedometers.
- rullgrus 12y agoAround where I live there is a road where the limit changes from 70 km/h to 50 km/h due to a pedestrian crossing. They also placed a speed camera just after the crossing. When driving there I always find my self checking and double checking my vehicle speed and not paying full attention to the crossing. But in this specific case I guess that the "forced" speed reduction due to the camera is a bigger benefit (fewer accidents and less serious if they do happen) than the distraction caused by it.
- fiatmoney 12y agoA kinder, gentler, more bureaucratic form of highway banditry.
- marincounty 12y agoI won't get into the efficacy/need for ticket cameras, but I will share something I have thought about for a long time. A poor-middle class guy gets a ticket, and it can affect their ability to pay rent. A rich guy get's a ticket and he tells his wife over dinner. How about tying your first ticket(reasonable mistake--like a California stop, etc.) to income, but only every 5 years. If poor person get's another ticket in five years all fees go back to normal levels? There would be upper limits on ticket price, so millionaires wouldn't be gouged too much. I think they tried this in Switzerland, but the law didn't have upper limits for the wealthy? Some guy got a $100,000 ticket--which is crazy! A $500 ticket can really cause pain for students and the poor? I have thought about this since I was sixteen?
- nulltype 12y agoI'm not sure that ticket is crazy. Having fixed price tickets disproportionally punishes the poor. Having them based on income seems much more fair. $500 may be worth more to someone who can barely afford gas for their car to get to their minimum wage job than $100,000 is to a guy who can't decide which yacht to buy.
- cmurf 12y agoThe fine ought to float to make the person reconsider their behavior. If that's $100 for a cabbie and $10000 for a hedge fund manager, then great. The problem is, the income disparity in the city is immense. When I lived in Boulder, we had a 3-4 month period in the winter where water usage was the "base usage" for the rest of the year and if you went over that, i.e. in the summer, you got nailed a higher rate for water consumption. So it was a got scaled system, whether you were a single person or a family, you were paying an affordable base rate always and including in the summer, but if you watered your lawn, you paid a much higher rate for the overage above base. So what you'd need to avoid having to invent a new layer of bureaucracy to NYC is something like that. "Zones" based on your NYC income tax for example (yes NYC has city income tax) to base your traffic fines on. So, it'd be a course granularity, not exactly fair within each zone, but overall it'd make everyone "wince" and change their stupid behavior that risks others' lives unfairly. The speeding thing gets my goat, but running red lights is like - you should lose all your registered cars, your license, and get massively fined. You run red lights you should stop driving. Idiots.
- thrownaway2424 12y agoRelated analysis of this analysis. http://www.streetsblog.org/2015/02/25/nyc-speed-cameras-are-making-streets-safer-time-to-stop-holding-back/ http://www.streetsblog.org/2015/02/25/nyc-speed-cameras-are-...
- superuser2 12y agoIf you are going for full enforcement of traffic laws, distraction/intoxication would seem many times more important than speed. Why do bars have parking lots? Why doesn't first-offense drunk driving destroy your life like drug possession? Why does it remain socially acceptable to text and drive? Why do photos clearly taken while driving on the freeway gather tens of thousands of upvotes on Reddit and not criminal prosecution?
- TeMPOraL 12y agoForgive me for answering your rethorical questions ;). > If you are going for full enforcement of traffic laws, distraction/intoxication would seem many times more important than speed. Can't provide a citation right now, but I recall that apparently most accidents are caused by distraction and/or speeding, often during the day, and not by drunk-driving. > Why do bars have parking lots? Because it's apparently not banned, and even if it was, someone would stand to make money by providing said lot next to a bar. > Why doesn't first-offense drunk driving destroy your life like drug possession? I don't know, but I very much feel this should be reversed. > Why does it remain socially acceptable to text and drive? People don't expect to get in an accident + well, no offense, but most of the drivers I know behave like entitled assholes when it comes to driving-related things. "Speed limits are stupid, and no accident could ever happen to me.". > Why do photos clearly taken while driving on the freeway gather tens of thousands of upvotes on Reddit and not criminal prosecution? I guess it has to do with the fact that it's hard to take a picture posted on the Internet and turn it into a lawsuit. And to clarify - you're right asking those questions. IMO traffic laws should be enforced much, much more decisively.
- WalterBright 12y agoI don't believe we are made safer by crushing anyone who makes a mistake or has a temporary lapse in judgment. We all make those. There are better ways to improve safety - we've already come a long way.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoTemporary lapses in judgement are fine - what I hate is the attitude of disregard towards safety and law. Fortunately, it seems that the whole discussion will soon become moot thanks to self-driving cars.