3 ms·
I'm sorry I can't convince you, but I've done both, and I know that insights are given in both realms, doing things by hand, and using the computer. To throw a
by RiderOfGiraffes 17y ago
I'm sorry I can't convince you, but I've done both, and I know that insights are given in both realms, doing things by hand, and using the computer. To throw away one is to lose an advantage.
The point of doing the expansion of (x+1)^8 (to continue the example) is not to get the answer, but to see the patterns building. You say you can do it easily enough by using Pascal's triangle, but finding that insight alone is worth the time.
Just last week I saw someone differentiate x^(1/2) by using a calculator to convert 1/2 to a decimal, putting it at the front, then carefulyl subtracting 1 from it, and getting 0.5 x^(-0.5). Right answer. Then they did the same for x^(1/3) and got 0.334 x^(-0.667) and got full marks. Follow the process by rote, and don't think.
I know I'm fighting a losing battle, because "Get the computer to do it" is too easy. What is lost is hard to see, and once it's gone it's impossible to regain. I wish I'd learned a langauge when I was 15 or younger, instead of now when I'm nearly 50. I'm constantly surprised that I can get answers to questions far, far faster than my colleagues and employees using techniques I learned when I was 12. I'm not using experience or any great gift, I'm using what everyone was taught in school at that time.
It's still useful. Perhaps I should be grateful that these skills are disappearing because I'm certainly never out of work.