2 ms·
Flipping that argument: Do American universities routinely discriminate against African Americans and Latinos as a consequence of reliance on standardized test
by leereeves 12y ago
Flipping that argument:
Do American universities routinely discriminate against African Americans and Latinos as a consequence of reliance on standardized tests and curricula on which they are known to receive lower scores?
Adjustment for the bias in these measures might correct for discrimination, not create it.
- SiVal 12y agoThe purpose of admissions testing for almost any organization (businesses for prospective employees, military for recruits, schools for students, basketball teams for players) is to find those who are most likely to succeed at what they will have to do if admitted. The only question is whether these measures are good or bad at predicting who is likely to succeed. In the university case, that means do well in classes and graduate. If they are bad predictors, they need to be replaced with good predictors. If they are good predictors, the problem for groups who are "known to receive lower scores" is not the measurement. The fact that Massachusetts routinely receives lower temperature scores than Florida is not evidence that thermometers are bad.
- leereeves 12y agoA college's ultimate goal isn't for their students to get good grades and test well. A college's promise is to prepare students for life, and at present that means life in a diverse world. Success beyond academia may be predicted well by SATs and high school grades in some fields, but certainly not all.