3 ms·
hang on, but where are you drawing the lines between "merit due to innate skill/aptitude" and "merit due to favourable environmental factors"? Because similarl
by marcus_holmes 12y ago
hang on, but where are you drawing the lines between "merit due to innate skill/aptitude" and "merit due to favourable environmental factors"?
Because similarly if you define merit as "anything that causes one person to do better in the tech industry than another" then the tech industry is tautologically a meritocracy - water is wet.
Until and unless we can unpack merit and privilege in the manner that Sago is attempting then we will continue to misunderstand our problem and continue to let the best programmers become nurses because of that misunderstanding.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoI'm defining "merit" as the ability to get the job done and make the company money. For example, I'm trying to hire a data scientist/data oriented generalist. Knowledge of statistics and aptitude for learning contributes to merit, as does the ability to write scalable and deployable code. Sex appeal does not contribute to merit, nor does being a nerdy-but-attractive hipster. Does that clarify? Note that Sago's definition, "probabilistic causes of non-equal representation", quite deliberately doesn't unpack anything. All it does is apply the label "privilege" to the cause, whether that cause is explicit deliberate racism (to take one extreme) or completely biological factors with entirely unbiased decisions (to take another).
- sago 12y agoYou do like ignoring that I actually gave a list, don't you: money, aspiration, parental ambition, education, culturation, in-group bias, and many other factors (note, many was not intended to be exclusive) that you continue to think my point was to apply the label "privilege" seems obtuse, bordering on the willfully ignorant, since I've explicitly said that was not the point at all, and that the label is irrelevant.