5 ms·
The point is that 'merit' is systemically produced. It is a function of money, aspiration, parental ambition, education, culturation, and many other factors. An
by kbenson 12y ago
The point is that 'merit' is systemically produced. It is a function of money, aspiration, parental ambition, education, culturation, and many other factors. Another way to phrase this is 'privilege', though that word is considered some kind of anathema by people who don't like to see their elevated status and capabilities as somehow a function of their environment.
I don't think anyone is really arguing that privilege affects merit, but to say that what makes up merit can be called privilege is to say that they are one and the same, which they are note. Of course access to resources to grow whatever talent you have, and allow you to make the most of your ambition will affect your merit, but to discount talent and ambition entirely by making the conversation entirely about privilege is to error in the other direction.
In modern western societies we attempt to smooth the privilege curve through socializing some aspects of it, such as education, and to differing degrees, health. While obviously not perfect, I would argue that we at least attempt to mitigate the problem by supplementing the biggest differentiators in merit that are based on privilege. Beyond that, what do you suggest? I don't think it's possible to eliminate the benefit of privilege, entire nations have gone to war to try, and the result was not what what I would call a success by that criteria.
Meritocracy has the benefit of shepherding those most capable and qualified into the positions where they can do the most. There may be a system better for the individual and society, but I would need quite a bit of info and evidence before I endorsed it.
>> But that's where the "pretty people" will just call me a racist/sexist "creep" who can't get laid, and intellectual discussion stops.
> Anyone who actually understands the last 20 years of social science, far from 'stopping intellectual discussion' are more likely to recognize that you've simply not found out or understood the issue. Which can, of course, be a sin of racism or sexism, if one is willingly ignorant. But can just be naivete or a Dunning Kruger effect.
Did you really just do that? Did you just respond to someone complaining about how the conversation eventually degrades into the opposition tossing out labels instead of arguments by stating he's either racist, sexist or ignorant?
- sago 12y agoRight. Be careful of making semantic arguments about what words 'really' mean. It isn't very useful for getting to the bottom of what is actually happening. 'Merit' has its own problems, because it connotes 'deserving', and it is a problem to suggest that a rich, Harvard educated white male deserves a job more than a poor, community college educated black female. So language has baggage. But let's say we're talking about 'imminent capability (as opposed to potential capability) and qualifications', then yes, it is an undeniable short-term optimisation to fill roles with these people. The economic argument to take seriously is that, by doing so we propagate privilege, and that in doing so we miss bringing forward people with high potential capability but low social privilege, who would be, in the long term, a better optimised workforce. And that is irrespective of the moral argument, that an economic optimisation at the cost of the opportunity of all is perhaps too high a price to pay. > Did you really just do that? Yes. There's no problem with being ignorant of things we don't know. Every single article on HN is full of stuff that I'm ignorant of. The things I am ignorant of knows no bounds. The poster I responded to seemed unaware that the things he was bringing up have long histories of being discussed and wrestled with in more sophisticated terms. He seemed to think that discussions of such things were 'stopped' because they were not allowed in some way, where actually they are discussed in very great detail and sophisticated by hundreds perhaps thousands of writers. I think it more likely he is ignorant of that, than racist or sexist, though since he bought up the question of being accused of those things, I thought it wise to include those options.
- kbenson 12y agoIt isn't very useful for getting to the bottom of what is actually happening. I disagree. Finding a shared vocabulary can be essential to actual communication. It's far too easy for people to argue a similar or even the same point without that shared reference point. That doesn't really need to be what it "really means" as long as it's meaning in the discussion is well understood. 'Merit' has its own problems, because it connotes 'deserving', and it is a problem to suggest that a rich, Harvard educated white male deserves a job more than a poor, community college educated black female. So language has baggage. That's a problem depending on how you define deserves and what your goal in filling the position is, and even what your eventual goal is (all as an outside observer). Is the goal of getting more participation in certain roles better achieved through artificial insertion of people into those roles, or more focus on earlier stages to make them better fits for those roles so they are naturally chosen at a later stage? That we optimize for imminent capability is obvious. To do otherwise is gambling. Perhaps it could be considered too high a price to pay - if it had not shown over the past few hundred years that it pays great dividends. I think my stance here is that there are other ways to attack the downsides of privilege rather than putting sub-optimal workers in positions. Namely, work to fulfill the potential of those workers that have said potential. I think an argument could be made that the current strategy, which has been in place for at least the last few hundred years in the west, has lead to a higher percentage of people utilizing their talents optimally than ever before, with a higher standard of living for more people than ever before, with a higher survival rate as well. I think it's folly to attack what I see as the fundamental mechanism that's lead to this while there are still other avenues to pursue. There's no problem with being ignorant of things we don't know. The problem is not the being ignorant, the problem is the use of the label ignorant as an argument tactic to cast the opposition's position as unworthy of consideration. Being ignorant has no bearing on whether an argument has merit. You may not want to rehash topics that you think have been well covered before, but in that case, a reference could be included with your statement of your position and where it was informed from, and why you think it's a decided issue (we are far, far from the hard sciences here, so let's not delude ourselves with notions that our opinions are fact). Note: Click on the unique comment link to view that specific comment to reply directly when the topic is hot and reply links are not being shown.