4 ms·
I really wish people would quit posting Xiph links as if it proves things. What we DO know is that our ears no not work anyway like how we represent audio in P
by DiabloD3 12y ago
I really wish people would quit posting Xiph links as if it proves things.
What we DO know is that our ears no not work anyway like how we represent audio in PCM form. We know that they are highly sensitive in some frequency ranges, and that sensitivity includes higher temporal impulse precision than is required, such as the 300-3khz band used for human speech.
As in, for some frequency bands, our "sampling rate" (if such a thing could be applied apples to apples in human hearing) is higher than in others. I suspect this may be related to our ability to localize 3D perfectly sound with only two ears.
Not only that, but also in some frequency bands, we can detect finer differences in sound level than 16 bit can describe.
So no, 16 bit/44.1khz probably is not sufficient.
Also, you bring up lossy encoding which has no place in this discussion. If you want to discuss how lossy codecs exploit the flaws in hearing to compress audio better, talk about codecs that use wavelets and are highly effective at what they do due to a finely tuned psychoacoustic model, such as exploiting that our "sampling rate" and "bit depth" are non-linear across frequency bands.
- korethr 12y agoA reason (probably one of the main ones, IMO) people post Xiph links is because they contain very well reasoned arguments, backed up evidence (i.e the math of how digital audio works, or in the case of the the video linked in the parent, actual meassurement). When seeing arguments on why 16-bit/44.1kHz is insufficient, I more often see faualty reasoning and a lack of evidence to support the arguments being made. You are correct in that human hearing is highly sensitive in the 300-3kHz band, and that sensitivities to minute timing and phase differences between the ears helps us accurately localize sound with only two ears. But I fail to see how that is relevant to whether or not 16-bit/44.kHz digital audio being enough to reproduce sound without audible distortion. Are you aware of some evidence that shows how 16-bit/44.1Khz is insufficent? I would be very interested to see it.
- DiabloD3 12y agoThere isn't enough research being done on that frontier yet. We know the 300-3khz has a "higher sampling rate" than 44.1khz, but we don't know how high. However, I'm actually happy with properly mastered 16/44.1 on a proper DAC that has THD and noise levels below what is required for 16 bit (which I can get for $100 in an external DAC, for $150 with multiple inputs, from Schiit). The big issue is, they don't properly master them, and releasing the HD versions seems to lessen the impact of an improper master (such as we can hear finer steps in volume than 16 bit can do when all the samples have a smaller dynamic range, but we can't if they had mastered everything with 12+ bits of dynamic range like the creators of CDs had intended). Honestly, if CDs had chosen 20/48 instead of 16/44.1, most of this bullshit would have never happened. tl;dr I'm a bigger proponent of increased bitdepth over sampling rate, but I'm happy if I get both to get just one.