3 ms·
But I think it is important to emphasize that this is not really about encryption. MEGA.nz would, of course, want us all to think that it is... Well, the part
by mike_hearn 12y ago
But I think it is important to emphasize that this is not really about encryption. MEGA.nz would, of course, want us all to think that it is...
Well, the part about encryption is in quotes and attributed to PayPal.
It seems pretty clear to me - they're saying that due to Dotcom's history and the fact that he can't prove it's NOT piracy, because of the encryption, means they can't touch him.
That's a very bad precedent, terrible actually. Your service is encrypted. Someone claims it MUST be used primarily for bad stuff. You cannot prove your innocence because it's encrypted. Therefore, no payment processing for you.
It's the definition of guilty until proven innocent.
That said, I agree that given Mega's past, it seems likely there's a lot of piracy on there. And I hate piracy. But even so, this sort of thing cannot stand. ISPs make lots of money off piracy too. They shouldn't be cut off from Visa or MasterCard either.
- pdabbadabba 12y agoI think its fairly clear that real story is simply that PayPal didn't want to jeopardize its relationships with Visa and MasterCard, and was only trying to explain in good faith why PayPal and MEGA.nz are in this position. > Visa and MasterCard then pressured PayPal to cease providing payment services to MEGA. As you observed, from a practical perspective it's a real problem for these types of services that they can't do much to rebut accusations of piracy, making it particularly important to behave as a "good corporate citizen" in other ways. And while Visa and MasterCard are free (I would think) to do business, or not, with anyone they choose for any reason, the Chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, on the other hand, should be expected to act on more solid information that some industry report before he tries to shut down someone's business. In any event, MEGA.nz is clearly trying to claim they they were targeted because they provide end-to-end encryption. This is false. They were targeted because they are widely viewed as promoting copyright infringement. That they offer end-to-end encryption really plays only a tangential role in these accusations.
- themartorana 12y agoIt's quite easy to declare that anyone claiming to need end-to-end encryption has something to hide. The NSA, and by extension pretty much any agency of the US government won't stand for being truly locked out of a person's online activities, and can put extreme pressure on a foreign company through US companies, through government reach - in this case through a Senator. And that's all that needs to be said to put one company with extreme security out of business through the use of other companies is "they're pirates, or they'd show us their files." Won't someone think of the children and whatnot. Wasn't it nice, pre-Snowden, when you could read the above paragraphs and think "that's a crazy conspiracy theory..."
- powertower 12y ago> but PayPal has advised that MEGA's "unique encryption model" presents an insurmountable difficulty. > Well, the part about encryption is in quotes and attributed to PayPal. Putting 3 words in quotes, attributing them to someone, not providing the full communication (i.e., without context), and generating a sweeping conclusion from all that, is a clear sign that someone is producing a false narrative. People that have the truth on their side don't need to do that. > ISPs make lots of money off piracy too. They shouldn't be cut off from Visa or MasterCard either. I seriously doubt that people sign up with their ISP so they can pirate vs. getting a general internet connection to browse Facebook. But that's a moot point since ISPs, fiber carriers, etc, just provide connections and transit, they don't generally host anything. Complaining about ISPs making a profit from piracy is like complaining about highways and roads making a profit from people that commit crimes and use cars. It does not make sense. I have no idea how bad the piracy is via Mega, but considering their previous business was driven by piracy, outright promoted and rewarded piracy, and generated 400MM from piracy, I think it's wise to take everything said and done with some salt.
- sarciszewski 12y ago> I seriously doubt that people sign up with their ISP so they can pirate "Thanks for fixing up my computer/Internet, now can you show me how to get the free HBO TV shows?" quoth several people I've helped before.