5 ms·
Schiit Happened, 2015 Chapter 4: Bridging the Gap
- legulere 12y ago> Why not just say, “Well, I understand that these guys are trying to offer higher resolution music, and some people may hear a difference, but I don’t, let’s move on to the latest Android phone.” Because they simply can't. This has been tested so often. So far no human being was found that can hear the difference. HiFi seems pretty rotten to me. There are lots of points where today the cheapest option is just as good as ones for thousands of dollars (cables being the best example). HiFi people spend thousands on voodoo, yet spending money on products that have a bigger focus on design is seen as a waste of money. The only thing that really separates HiFi from consumer audio is speaker size
- jkot 12y agoI only do headphones. I can recognize 160kbps mp3 from 320kbps. Decent headphone setup is around $500, with performance of a few milliwatts. Now scale power 1000x, I bet price will go up as well. Probably exponentially.
- signa11 12y ago> Decent headphone setup is around $500 may you please suggest a couple in that range ? i currently have a b&w p5, which i am thinking of upgrading...
- jkot 12y agoIt is not just headphones, but also amplifier and DA. My stuff is 10 years old, so I am probably not best adviser. And I have more sets, one is bit more pricey. Anyway for daily beating at office I would recommend DT 770 PRO, 80 Ohms. In my opinion best closed studio headphones for reasonable price. Mine are ten years old now. I believe in-ear demages hearing. I also dont like active noise cancellation. Also check some foldable options if you travel a lot. You will also need USB soundcard with headphones amplifier. Some devices combine both. I have EMU Tracker Pre USB 2.0, but thats no longer sold. Not sure what today market is, but this seems to have good reviews: http://www.amazon.com/FiiO-E10-USB-Headphone-Amplifier/dp/B005VO7LG6/ http://www.amazon.com/FiiO-E10-USB-Headphone-Amplifier/dp/B0...
- dublinben 12y agoAn expensive USB soundcard and amplifier are absolutely not necessary. The built-in audio of a Macbook Pro (this is HN we're talking about) is more than good enough.
- jkot 12y agoBullshit. Thats are 80 ohm professional studio headphones. Wasted money without amplifier. Even novice can pickup difference in 10 minutes.
- dublinben 12y agoYou don't need to buy 80 ohm professional studio headphones to get good sound quality.
- frou_dh 12y agoI have experience using several good headphones (K701, HD650) amped and unamped in the past. At the moment, I happily use a set of 250 Ohm 770s straight out of a MBP. Sounds fantastic. Does this trigger you?
- jkot 12y agoI do it sometimes as well, I would not call sound fantastic, but its ok for movies and remastered (flat) music. But so does $120 Major. I just think it is really bad advice. Why buy expensive headphones optimised for amps without amp? Just waste of money.
- frou_dh 12y agoWaste of money is something that makes marginal gain. BadPhones -> GoodPhones is a much greater step than UnampedGoodPhones -> AmpedGoodPhones. --- (of course there's always an amp, Unamped just means no beefy one)
- 12y ago
- msh 12y agoHere is a few options: http://www.marco.org/headphones-closed-portable http://www.marco.org/headphones-closed-portable
- timc3 12y agoI think he might actually have a hearing problem, or badly setup equipment and his music taste is extremely narrow. The experience that he perceives in headphones he has reviewed I certainly haven’t experienced and is not the general response I hear on reviews. i.e. NAD HP50 does not have a weak treble or mediocre detail. Go and listen to headphones with your own music and make up your own mind.
- gcv 12y agoSennbeiser HD600 or HD650 (very similar sound), AKG K7XX, Hifiman HE400. All open. Many other nice open headphones on the market, but those are best bang per buck. For closed, most are not good except the Beyerdynamic DT770 (and the far pricier Fostex TH900). You may consider an external DAC and amplifier if you listen to a laptop — this will help with case noise and power. Beware, however: this is where you get close to snake oil products. Most amps do not make a difference, and a lot depends on your source. An iPhone is an excellent source for most headphones, for example (including all of the above). A reasonable DAC-amp combo is the O2+ODAC, and it is DIY if you can solder. The Schiit stuff in the link above is pretty meh, even though it is often recommended (crappy volume pot in the cheaper units).
- slantedview 12y agoI'd second the AKG K7XX and the Hifiman HE400. Both great headphones for the cost.
- DiabloD3 12y agoI don't recommend the HE-400, but the HE-400i instead. The HE-400 has the old Hifiman headband, the old pads, and the old cable, and suffers from a boomy bass issue. Replacing the pads and cables (absolutely required, new pads fix boomy bass issue some but not all, old cable breaks easily) raise the cost to be almost as much as the HE-400i, and you can't ever fix the headband issue. The HD650/HD650 and AKG K701/Q701/Kxx/K712 family however I do agree with. Also, the DT770 isn't fully closed, its semi-open. The DT990 also isn't fully open, its semi-open. They are merely closer to each end of the spectrum, with DT880 in the middle of semi-open, but they're ALL semi-open. Disclosure: Former DT880/600 Premium owner, current HE-400i owner.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- legulere 12y ago> I can recognize 160kbps mp3 from 320kbps This something that is possible. However I wonder if you really tested it, or if you just think that you can hear the difference. Often people in HiFI claim that they can hear a difference when in reality they can't. > Now scale power 1000x, I bet price will go up as well. Probably exponentially. As you go up with power you can often use techniques that are cheaper per watt in electrical engineering. Also size restrictions that you have with headphones fall away. I don't know why people always believe everything to be exponential. Anyway - with "normal HiFi" you have different problems than with headphones.
- jkot 12y agoLets put it other way. I never experienced speakers, which give similar sound details as headphones.
- dublinben 12y agoHave you ever experienced headphones which give proper soundstage as speakers?
- SoapSeller 12y agoI did, with the AKG K1000[0](They are very uncomfortable, btw). The problem with soundstage is that most recordings are made for speakers. Binaural recordings + headphones results in much better and much more realistic soundstage. With the shifting listing habits and the raise of digital distribution(which make it much easier to provide multiple mixes of the same recording) I was expecting to see more and more binaural recordings. Sadly it doesn't happen(yet?). [0] http://www.akg.com/pro/p/k1000 http://www.akg.com/pro/p/k1000.
- throwawayaway 12y agoyes i've really tested it, it's trivial to test, foobar2000 has an aba plugin, high hats and cymbals are smeared quite noticably by mp3 compression. 320 is the least bad. i think with sufficient volume you could probably hear the difference between wav and 320 too, but i haven't tested this.
- auxym 12y agoI won't dispute the fact that you can distinguish, 160k vs 320k. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt, I'm ready to believe people can hear artifacts at 160k even with the best encoders, especially if these people are trained for these artifacts, have a good headphone setup, and are listening to particular problematic passages (higher frequencies, transients, etc). However, just for information, there is a lot more to lossy audio compression than just bitrate. A song encoded with modern LAME with VBR at around 64k or 96k possibly sounds better than the same song encoded with a napster-era encoder at 192 CBR. Modern formats such as AAC or Vorbis are even more performant than LAME. I don't have hard data to back it up, but I think 99% of people would not differentiate between lossless and and lossy with a mid high quality setting (lame at v3-ish, whatever the equivalent is in the best aac encoder these days), even on a great headphone setup. Maybe if they were specifically looking for artifacts in particuliar problem samples.
- ploxiln 12y agoTotally believable. mp3 at 160kbps vs something better, can make a real difference. Headphones and DACs can make a real difference. 96KHz sample rate for playback? Anything which adds extra shielding and filtering on top of a to-spec $20 ethernet cable? Nope, that can't help.
- JohnBooty 12y ago> HiFi seems pretty rotten to me. Yes to everything you said. I simultaneously feel guilty about, and take solace in, the fact that a lot of the insanely overpriced snake-oil crap at the high end is effectively subsidizing the really good "prosumer" stuff. (Example: Audioquest, maker of $1,000+ audio cables, also makes a very solid little USB amp&DAC called the Dragonfly that costs just over $100. I'm not suggesting that they're selling these at a loss or anything, but I'm sure that product lines like $1,000+ audio cables give them some freedom to try products like the Dragonfly...)
- DiabloD3 12y agoYeah, but I can also buy a combined DAC+amp from Schiit called the Fulla, and I'm buying it directly from an American company that manufactures and assembles their devices in America, built using all American parts except for the ALPS (Japanese) volume pots.
- microcolonel 12y agoYay nationalism.
- rayiner 12y agoMore like supporting your neighbors, people who speak your language, people who share your values, people whose kids your kids might grow up to marry.
- microcolonel 12y agoWhat about all the people who never got a chance to speak your language, don't quite share your values, or who your kids will have to take a slightly longer flight to marry? Frankly I feel a lot closer to people on the other side of the globe than many of the people in my own neighbourhood, city, or country. I don't see why hi-fi made by mormons is any better than hi-fi made by muslums.
- ploxiln 12y agoHe compares audio playback quality to food nutrition. It's true, nutrition is far from fully understood. Audio playback as heard by human ears is perhaps not 100% understood, but it's much much closer. A human being does not need more than 44.1 KHz audio playback. If anyone claims you need a higher sample rate for audio that sounds better, they're lying (whether they realize it or not). More than 16 bits per sample just lowers the noise floor, and at 16 bits, it's pretty damn low. For playback, you really won't need more. Again, if someone professes the subtle string quartets and powerful metal jams you can only get with more bits per sample, they're lying. It is true that better headphones will make a real difference, it is true that you can (barely) do noticeably better than 160kbps mp3 (for stereo). But audio engineers understand enough about how the human ear really works to know that more than about 44 KHz or more than about 16 bits per sample truly does not help for final audio playback. All that to say, this two facts are not like nutrition, and they're not a matter of "some people may hear a difference, but I don't". Selling something as better for playback because of 96KHz / 24bit audio is preying on human weaknesses of judgement, when we know scientifically that these specific two things don't help. It's been posted a bunch, but this is a really great demonstration of digital audio fundamentals https://wiki.xiph.org/Videos/Digital_Show_and_Tell https://wiki.xiph.org/Videos/Digital_Show_and_Tell
- DiabloD3 12y agoI really wish people would quit posting Xiph links as if it proves things. What we DO know is that our ears no not work anyway like how we represent audio in PCM form. We know that they are highly sensitive in some frequency ranges, and that sensitivity includes higher temporal impulse precision than is required, such as the 300-3khz band used for human speech. As in, for some frequency bands, our "sampling rate" (if such a thing could be applied apples to apples in human hearing) is higher than in others. I suspect this may be related to our ability to localize 3D perfectly sound with only two ears. Not only that, but also in some frequency bands, we can detect finer differences in sound level than 16 bit can describe. So no, 16 bit/44.1khz probably is not sufficient. Also, you bring up lossy encoding which has no place in this discussion. If you want to discuss how lossy codecs exploit the flaws in hearing to compress audio better, talk about codecs that use wavelets and are highly effective at what they do due to a finely tuned psychoacoustic model, such as exploiting that our "sampling rate" and "bit depth" are non-linear across frequency bands.