8 ms·
I work in info sec, and in one of the "Who's Hiring" posts a few months ago (do we still do those? I haven't seen one in a while) I asked "why are startups neve
by freehunter 12y ago
I work in info sec, and in one of the "Who's Hiring" posts a few months ago (do we still do those? I haven't seen one in a while) I asked "why are startups never hiring security guys?", because I never see a security engineer position open in those topics. I never got a response. To me that indicates the response is "we don't".
Listen, guys. I don't care how small you are. If you are handling PII or credit card data or anything that, if leaked, would harm your business or your customers, you need a security guy. Not a programmer who knows some security stuff. Not a manager who checks off the online PCI self-assessment. Not "we outsource to an MSSP". At least one security guy, full time. Make sure that everything you do is run past that person. If you're so busy that you can't run everything past that person, hire another.
It's not a joke. Stop fucking ruining people's lives. It's 2015, four years past "the year of the breach" [1]. Get with the program. It's not okay to have a breach. It's not. It doesn't matter how much money you saved from not having a security guy or the tools they need. Get someone who knows what they're talking about and listen to them.
[1] http://news.softpedia.com/news/IBM-2011-is-The-Year-of-the-Security-Breach-224465.shtml http://news.softpedia.com/news/IBM-2011-is-The-Year-of-the-S...
- damian2000 12y agoAgreed, but these guys aren't small, they're fucking huge, so they really don't have an excuse. They possibly still have the startup culture of growing quickly and worrying about the details (e.g. security) later.
- imnewhere 12y agoI mostly agree, but the calculation is different for different businesses. The costs of engineering time and hiring a security professional may be much more expensive than the lost business due to breaches. In this particular case they likely have enough resources to have made it happen, but it remains to be seen whether this will actually cost them much if anything.
- freehunter 12y agoThat was the case with Home Depot. They made the determination that the cost of implementing proper security would be more than the cost of cleaning up the breach. However, this is just offloading the negative externalities onto the banks and the customers. That's just shitty. I'm not one to call for government regulation that easily, but this is exactly why we have a federal government. To make sure the citizens are being protected. That's why the FCC declared ISPs to be utilities. To stop them from abusing the customers. That's why the EPA has regulations on chemical and oil spills. If Home Depot got fined $100m for their breach, what would the cost look like then? The cost of security is more than the impact of the lost business. That needs to be fixed, because until it is, we will continue to have breaches that make our lives terrible.
- jjoonathan 12y ago> It's not okay to have a breach. It's not. It doesn't matter how much money you saved... If only this were true, they would be hiring security people. Nothing is going to change until companies are held accountable for the damages caused by negligence. If someone in the infosec field wants to make a difference, I'd reckon their best bet is lobbying to make this happen.
- 2arrs2ells 12y agoWe're hiring security engineers at Clever: https://clever.com/about/jobs#engineer-full-stack-security https://clever.com/about/jobs#engineer-full-stack-security
- ForHackernews 12y agoThat's good! You guys probably have tons of personal data from students who didn't choose to use your service anyway, but their school made that choice for them. Be careful with it!
- jjoonathan 12y agoI think it's safe to say "thank you" on behalf of the students and teachers who won't ever know that you went the extra mile.
- arkem 12y agoFrom first hand experience I can tell you that Uber was recruiting to start their information security program at least 18 months ago and when I spoke to their software engineers and SREs they had a decent understanding of modern security issues. In the 18 months since I assume they have assembled a decent security team and while most likely Uber dropped the ball here at least they recognized the need for security before they got burnt.
- forrestthewoods 12y ago"Stop fucking ruining people's lives" Serious, legit question here. How many lives will be ruined by this breach of 50k? How many lives were ruined when 40 million CCs and 70 million accounts (address, phone number , etc) were stolen in the Target breach? Ruin seems like an awfully strong word here. I hesitate to say that because I don't want to downplay the importance of security. But to take security seriously I think we also have to be non-hyperbolic about the consequences of not doing so.
- imnewhere 12y agoI think you're going to need to define what a ruined life is. I doubt getting a replacement credit card in the mail will ruin someone's life under most definitions.
- forrestthewoods 12y agoOne time I got an e-mail from Amex saying my account may have been compromised and to click a link. Fearing a phishing attempt I went direct to their website and logged in. A big red banner said to contact them ASAP. I called a number they gave. They asked if I ordered plane tickets for Turkey. I said no. They said ok, no worries, they auto-blocked the purchase. We went through my history to make sure everything else was correct, it was. The card was cancelled and they mailed a new one overnight. It was under 22 hours from e-mail to new card in hand. I was very impressed. My sister has info stolen from a fake pad at a gas station. It was a debit card. She got all of her money back but it took close to 6 weeks to fully resolve. If you live paycheck to paycheck, and at the time she wasn't too far off, that can be a very difficult situation. It worked out in the end but it was definitely painful for her. By and large these are not "ruined life" events. Identity theft and fraud are, unfortunately, common and mainstream enough that hitting "ruined life" level is exceptionally difficult. Back in the 90s when the average person didn't know those terms it might have been more common. But now it's just something that everyone, individuals and corporations, have to deal with.
- walterbell 12y agoIt can be logistically inconvenient when traveling internationally, a few thousand miles and a few days of shipment delay away from your bank.
- sbov 12y agoI generally agree with the main thrust of your argument, but this seems way over the top. I don't know if every brick and mortar business in the world can afford to hire a dedicated security engineer. Should they all just close shop? And if we're going by Wikipedia's definition of PII, probably at least 50% of the websites in the world. Including this one. Maybe you don't mean all that, but if I am to take what you posted at face value, it seems insanely irrational.
- imnewhere 12y agoYes, and basic information security involves weighing the cost of security breaches vs the cost of implementing security measures.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoTrue, but the calculations companies do don't include huge negative externalities they're causing, and this needs to be corrected.
- freehunter 12y agoI didn't just say PII, I said "PII or credit card data or anything that, if leaked, would harm your business or your customers". If you're not prepared to securely handle PII, you shouldn't be collecting it. Talking about B&M, does Guitar Center or Great Clips really need my phone number? No, they don't. So I don't give it to them. They keep this data because they want it, not because they need it. Insanely irrational? If you are comfortable handing your information to companies who do nothing more than the bare minimum to make sure it's safe, that's insanely irrational. I get tired of companies giving my information away. I really do. There's no excuse for it. Security is by no means a solved problem, nor is it possible to solve at this point. But how often do you hear that the company wasn't hashing, wasn't encrypting, wasn't paying attention to their security tools? Damn near every time. Things like this very, very rarely happen to companies who take security seriously.
- sbov 12y agoYou keep bringing up huge examples. Millions of credit cards leaked. Guitar center, a company that has 260 locations across the United States. Great clips has over 3,000 locations. Anthem, a company with multiple billions of dollars in revenue that handles extremely sensitive information for millions of people. I remember as a kid, there was a family owned comic book shop I would visit. I would let them know what comics I'm interested in, and they would call me if they got something in that they thought I would be interested in. So they had good reason to have our phone number. It was probably even stored really insecurely (on a piece of paper). But it was the early 90's. And if someone stole it it might have included 200 phone numbers. I buy magic the gathering cards from small card shops across the country. They need my address to ship it. Since most of these single store businesses are fairly low tech, I doubt they do too much to protect it. Also, your initial statement also said handle, not collect. Most brick and mortar stores handle credit card data, although they don't collect it. There's even been instances of thieves affixing devices to ATMs and credit card machines that will scan your card data as you slide or insert it. You can collect PII by hosting a static webpage (ip addresses). Leaking that PII can cause harm to users (DDOS). This may seem made up but people who make a living off live streaming are fairly regularly DDOS'd by malicious viewers who figure out their IP. More generally, any leak of data, whether it includes PII or not, will harm a company's reputation. This is why I called your post insanely irrational. It's all black and white: hire a dedicated security engineer, or you're doing it wrong. Regardless of size. The majority of businesses in the country would go out of business if they had to abide by your rules.
- Rapzid 12y agoJust like they all need a dedicated network engineer, or a dedicated storage engineer, or a dedicated "whatever" engineer? Losing data is unacceptable too right? I'm not saying security people are not necessary, but there are a lot of not dedicated "whatevers" that can handle "whatever" sufficiently. Coupled with security audits, which in my experience leave a LOT to be desired speaking as a not dedicated "security" engineer(I know of a few areas where I'd like to shore up but they never come up on security audits, hmmm), this is often sufficient. Besides, don't you figure Target, Home Depo, EA, and Sony had dedicated security people? Again, this is not arguing against security guys.. It's just this post reads a bit like "Well, if they were only hiring people like me maybe this wouldn't have happened".
- nodata 12y agoSo what's your point here? Rather than hire a security guy/gal, we should all do... what?
- sfeng 12y agoWe should understand that a startup doesn't have the resources of a fully fledged company. That said, Uber has literally billions in resources, they should have done better.
- roel_v 12y agoThis is bullshit. If your organisation can't protect their customers data, it shouldn't exist. Enough of this "I need special treatment because I'm just two dropouts working from a Starbucks'.
- logicallee 12y agoNo, with all due respect, you're bullshit. Hacking my app is illegal. You're saying I shouldn't write a web app in the first place, just because I'm some guy and barely know the framework I'm using. Well, maybe you should go live in Somalia if you don't like a code of laws. I can't do security right. I can do a web app poorly, or nothing at all. You're saying, give the world nothing. I'm saying, sod off. I've had enough of perfectionists like you keeping people from making stuff.
- ams6110 12y agoAnthem had security guys.
- faitswulff 12y agoMatasano security is almost always hiring. Here's their post from this month: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8980464 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8980464
- Kalium 12y agoMy POV is kind of limited, but I believe there's a strong argument to be made that security consulting is not an adequate substitute for in-house security. The largest problem that comes to mind is that hiring consultants can lead executives to think they've outsourced security and can not worry about it.
- wglb 12y agoIt's good practice to do both.
- tptacek 12y agoMatasano (now NCC Group) is always hiring. :)
- joeblau 12y agoI totally agree. I used to work in Info-sec back in D.C. before I moved out to San Francisco and I would always joke with my D.C. buddies that San Francisco cares about product first, security later. Most people in SF are so wrapped up around which framework is the coolest hottest thing and have no idea about anything related to security until it's too late. I would always complain about being 2-5 years behind in terms of technology stacks when I lived in D.C., but we were always a lot more careful about deployment decisions and extremely serious about data security. That mentality is ingrained in me until today so I always think about security. Unfortunately; it's not in the minds of a lot of people. I don't think these breaches are going to stop until something really serious happens or until there are some serious negative legal consequences for data breaches. Sadly, it's up to consumers to try and sort out which companies have the best practices and that's not always apparent.
- frozenport 12y agoThis is anti-competitive, and regressive, it helps the big guns. Imagine big companies shutting down small ones because they don't have dedicated security staff. We need companies with working security to outsource this service, for example for storing records.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> It doesn't matter how much money you saved from not having a security guy or the tools they need. It's the only thing that matters. It's capitalism. Those who waste money on unneccessary expenses get outcompeted by those who don't. Unless you find a way to make companies financially responsible for crappy security, they won't care. Right now breaches like these seem to be more like free advertising (a typical user will just read "something something Uber something hacked" and next week will just have a vague sense Uber was mentioned in the news).
- VMG 12y ago> Unless you find a way to make companies financially responsible for crappy security From a market perspective, would be enough if customers cared more about these breaches and take took business elsewhere. Apparently they don't care.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> would be enough if customers cared more about these breaches and take took business elsewhere. If only they were spherical humans of uniform density... > Apparently they don't care. Well, they do, but they can't do anything about it. See, it's a very known problem with real humans - from boycotting Coca Cola for slaughtering people in poor countries, to tantalum capacitor production being based on even worse slaughter of men, women and children in poor countries, to the whole environmental fuckup we enjoy today - "voting with your wallet" doesn't work. People can't coordinate on a large enough scale, so they have to stick with the bad choices. Why should I move my business elsewhere, if the risk is unlikely and my competitor here will save money over me if he stays? And my competitor thinks the same, and neither of us move. It's the very case regulations exist for - it's much easier (and in reality, actually feasible) to coordinate people to ban all businesses from doing particular classes of shitty things. But honestly, I thought that's kind of economics 101, that this is market failure mode when it is applied to real, flesh and blood humans.
- engendered 12y agoCurrently when there is a data breach, the source company is usually on the hook for nothing more than signing victims up for credit reporting for a year, a scheme that I would not be surprised is actually money making (e.g. providing thousands of great leads for a credit reporting agency has to be gravy). On the cost/benefit ratio, security of personal information just really doesn't matter in cases like this. There are some other companies, like Google, who would take a serious image hit, but for a pseudo-employer company like Uber there will be no ramifications. It isn't surprising that they deprioritize security -- the market doesn't demand it.
- devonkim 12y agoIf you look at the actual impact to companies by breaches like this, it's almost the same impact that Google, Apple, and Microsoft faced after the PRISM leak - hardly perceptible to revenue. What does happen though obviously is a lot of opex expenditures to deal with it all, and that's where companies are getting squeezed oftentimes in the usual behemoth dysfunctional megacorp landscape. I'm gung-ho about security as much as you but the truth is that users hardly stop using a service after data breaches. The ones that do matter though are like the ones that delete all your AWS instances and custom AMIs when holding your company's assets for ransom. That is what startups should be worried about indeed (as well as enterprises that are transitioning more of their IT into cloud environments that can be scripted and automated much easier - makes it easier for attackers in theory too).
- wslh 12y agoThere are top security professionals in companies such as Google, Microsoft, and Facebook. At the end all of them suffer security issues. The lesson: security is really hard in the real world, even for the best professionals.
- oskarth 12y agoI like security as much as the next HNer, but that's how the world works. It's basic economics. This is reality: Target paid $1.2 BILLION in dividends on $21.8 BILLION sales for 2014, its data breach only cost it $162 Million. Cost of doing business. From https://twitter.com/spacerog/status/570719734230073344 https://twitter.com/spacerog/status/570719734230073344
- mh_ 12y agoYou are spot on.. I mean, look at Target.. They were pillaged because they didn't have.. Oh.. Wait.. They had a security team of over 300 people.. This problem might just be a little more complex than we are giving credit for..
- rasz_pl 12y agoExcept no one cares, and there are no consequences whatsoever, so WHY BOTHER?
- bobofettfett 12y agoTotally wrong assessment. Everyone has security guys. Why does sec get breached? Marketing wants easy access to all data, deep learning wants easy access, lots of data is in transit. Security is not convenient for operations, therefor companies have sec on paper and audits and stuff but no real sec.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 12y agoI completely agree with you, but sadly, this kind of thing will never happen until there is a strong incentive for those companies to hire dedicated security people. Right now it's standard for companies to apologize and give people a year of credit monitoring. It's become such a common issue there is no incentive to invest in security and that's a bad thing.